I believe in escapism through fiction. So right now, in this time of political turmoil and controversy, I'm not surprised to see a lot of entertainment news trying to break through the discussions and news reports. Yet there are the times where our entertainment becomes political, and sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Marvel Comics, however, has done both. I am not going to talk about the movies, or movements such as #givecaptainamericaaboyfriend (that's a whole other argument), because those pertain to the Marvel Studios films, and simply because I'd like to point out the diversity and changes happening in the comics, some of which are exactly what the non-comic Marvel fans are looking for. The company has changed and altered many characters to fit the new, current, everything-must-be-diverse ideology, and while there are some great stories being told, there are also ones that are very obviously just there to make the Marvel Universe more politically correct.
The first big “change” to a
character occurred in the pages of "Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man," an alternate universe "Spider-Man" title.
Following the death of Peter Parker at the hands of the Green Goblin,
the mantle was taken by Miles Morales, a African-American/Hispanic
high school student. Miles struggled with being known as “the new
Spider-Man” and started wearing a primarily black costume to differ
himself from the original. When Marvel revealed this to the world,
the media ran crazy. Rumors began circulating that the then-upcoming "The Amazing Spider-Man"
film would feature a black actor as Peter Parker. Some outlets said
that the biracial character is Peter
Parker. Despite all this, Marvel continued to publish stories
featuring Miles within the “Ultimate” universe, and his
popularity increased dramatically over the next few years. After
appearing in the “Spider-Men” storyline and the Spider-Verse event series, Miles was brought
into the mainstream universe via the world-shattering 2015 Secret
Wars. Currently, he is on the
main Avengers team, and since his inclusion within the main titles,
the controversy of a biracial Spider-Man has almost faded away.
Year 2014
featured two major changes to characters – one that worked, one
that is hit or miss, and one that contradicts previous storylines.
The first, was the introduction of Kamala Khan, a sixteen-year-old
Muslim girl from Jersey City, who would become the next Ms. Marvel.
This title and character was already a C-list title, so there was
little to no coverage in the news. It should be noted that Kamala
Khan's family is devout Muslim, but they are not the stereotypical
Pakistani immigrants. Her father often is at odds with her older
brother, who is studying to become an imam at the local mosque.
Neither Kamala or her mother wear a veil, and Kamala's friend Nakia
is asked in the first issue whether or not she is being “forced to
wear it” by her father. Nakia tells the classmate that he actually
wants her to stop wearing it. This series has been called “the most
important comic” of that year, and has been praised for shattering
the stereotypes of Muslims in America. However, the draw to the
character is not that she is Muslim – instead, Marvel advertises
the series as about a girl who discovers that she is an Inhuman, and
she must struggle with family, school, and being a superhero. A
change that worked, because the team behind it is keeping the story
first, not her religion.
The
other “new take” on a character was when Jane Foster became Thor.
The series has been good, but has also had many bad/disappointing
stories – which could just be the problems of writing for someone
who is essentially a god, but I digress. The news was announced on
The View, and Marvel
was accused of pandering to feminists. The talk show did not
acknowledge that this female Thor was not the same character as the
“classic” Thor, but simply somebody who wields the hammer while
Thor Odinson is deemed unworthy of the weapon. To this day, the title
is a very controversial one, with constant debate over whether or not
the original Thor should just come back and prove himself worthy
again. The use of the character also has ups and downs – she is
well used in her starring title, but her work in Mark Waid's
All-New-All Different Avengers
leaves much to be desired. It is an interesting note that Miles
Morales, Ms. Marvel, and Thor are all on the same team.
The
last big change to a character that year was not passing the mantle
onto a new person, but a total change in the characterization of one.
Brian Michael Bendis' "All-New X-Men" featured
the original five X-Men being transported to the modern day, where
they met their future selves and have to figure out a way to return
home. In #40 of the series, Jean Grey probed the mind of Iceman, and
found out that he is gay. She confronted him about it, and he tried
to deny it, saying that his “future self isn't gay!” The older
Iceman met with his past self, and confirmed this as truth. This
change was one of those “let's change it for the sake of changing
it” events. This revelation contradicted much of Iceman's past,
including romances and near-engagements. The X-Men series has been
often used to introduce diverse characters, such as the first openly
gay hero, Northstar, who was also the focus of the first gay marriage
in comics. Yet in this instance, it was panned by both audiences and
critics, because it came out of nowhere and was simply used to bring
an emotional arc to the series. The series is still being published,
and Iceman's sexuality has almost been ignored altogether, at least
so far.
The
next year featured the death of Wolverine, and the question of
whether or not the name should continue. The previously-established
young female clone of Wolverine, X-23, was revealed to be taking over
the main "Wolverine" title,
with an alternate universe version of the original being the lead in "Old Man Logan." X-23 as
Wolverine proved to be a welcome passing of the torch, but not
without some controversy over the name. It is still questioned among
the fanbase whether or not it is right that she is using the old
callsign while wearing a similar costume. Her title is selling well
according to recent figures, but there hasn't been too much news and
discussion over the content of the series. This could simply be
because of a lack of advertisement or popularity of X-Men
comics, possibly due to
Marvel-Fox relations over the film series.
Lastly,
the most recent alteration of a character recently made headlines. In
the fall, following the Civil War II
storyline, Tony Stark will be replaced as Iron Man by a 15-year-old
black girl named Riri Williams. This announcement led to much
controversy and debate, some thinking this would happen in the
movies, others questioning how exactly she gets the mantle. She has
built her own armor using scrap metal, and is said to be smarter than
Stark himself – another aspect that has led to a lot of argument.
She also has been confirmed to be using the name “Iron Man,” and
while some celebrate this representation, many longtime fans are
disappointed that Marvel did not create a new armored character, but
is simply giving her the name. We have seen James Rhodes in the Iron
Man armor before – he was in the armor during the first Secret
Wars in 1984. However, he had
been established as a longtime friend, and was not portrayed as
“better” than Stark. Only time will tell if Riri Williams will be
a great character, or a forgettable moment in the overall Iron
Man series.
So
yes, Marvel is much more diverse than many believe. It is not within
their blockbuster films or television programs, but within the pages
of the source material. However, these are all characters using names
of others. To truly be the diverse universe Marvel wants to be, they
must first create new characters with their own names and their own
stories. It may take time for them to catch on, but there very well
could be another Ms. Marvel type success with an original character.
Until then, we have new takes on old classics, and considering the
medium, it is all up in the air when they'll hand it back over, so
for now, we'll just have to make do with what we have. If you're
looking for comics with leads that are not the usual comic book hero,
check out these all-new, all-different Marvel titles. Or, if I'm
being honest here, look for the independent comics. They'll be much
more original and diverse than the mainstream.