Why The BMI Scale Is A Joke | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Health and Wellness

Why The BMI Scale Is A Joke

The common misconception.

348
Why The BMI Scale Is A Joke
www.women.thenest.com

Every health class we have ever sat through, whether it was in high school or college, made us calculate our Body Mass Index. It is based off of only your height and weight, so it completely disregards strong bones and good muscle tone. So you can only imagine there are many issues with the BMI Scale that can really make someone self-conscious.

In high school, I played lacrosse year round and had other sports keeping me busy. I was in shape, but still was considered “overweight” in the eyes of the BMI Scale. Luckily, my parents knew the BMI Scale was a joke and told me I had nothing to worry about, but some people don’t know that it’s a joke, and it can lead people to turn to eating disorders and other means of unhealthy weight loss.

According to the BMI scale, a person who is 5’5” and weighs 150 pounds is overweight, as well as a person who is 6’2” and weighs 195 pounds, but what about athletes, bodybuilders, and power lifters? The ideal weight for a male bodybuilder who is 6’2” is 220 pounds, which is still considered overweight on the BMI Scale. Meanwhile, these athletes train with heavy weights day after day, have very minimal body fat, and are in better health than a person who does not work out, but is considered a normal weight.

Just because you are at a “normal weight” on the BMI Scale doesn’t mean you are healthy. This can give people a false sense of security when it comes to their overall health, and although you are “normal” on the scale, that doesn’t mean you don’t have a high percentage of body fat or other health issues.

You have probably heard someone tell you, “a pound of muscle weighs more than a pound of fat,” but a pound of feathers weighs just as much as a pound of bricks. The difference is that a pound of muscle is about 18 percent denser than fat, and one pound of muscle takes up less space than one pound of fat. So pound for pound, muscle and fat weigh the same, but this is why you cannot solely base your health on the number on your bathroom scale. You can be in great shape, but weigh more than if you are out of shape.

If you are concerned about your health, there are plenty of other methods. There are no right measurements for good health, but measuring your waist circumference is a pretty good way when it comes to gauging your overall health. You can also use body calipers, which takes measurements from your waist, shoulder blade, bicep, and tricep. The measurements are combined into a single number and are compared based on your sex and age.

What to take away from this: do not use the BMI scale as a basis for your overall health. Look in the mirror, choose healthy options, work out regularly, and finally, do not become discouraged by the number on your bathroom scale. Remember that if you are living a healthy lifestyle, the number on the scale no longer matters.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
cousins
Bailey Totten

I've known you your entire life. More than likely I held you in the first three days of it and at least one of us cried. Cousins are truly one of the best things in the world and while sometimes I complain about how many people crowd Grandma's living room on Christmas Eve, I wouldn't trade you all anything.

You are my best friends, the only people who can understand what it's like on Thanksgiving, and you are the spunkiest people I have ever met. But you as so so young, most of you are just now starting your adventures in the public education system. I mean, I'm so very young too. I'm not married, I don't have children, heck, I just started my adult life, but I do want to give you what little advice I have. My dears, these are the things I want you to know.

Keep Reading...Show less
ORHS Graduation
Kristen Sack, ORHS Graduation

You are a senior in high school, you have made it to the final year that you have been looking forward to since the first day of freshman year. Whether this has been the worst or best four years of your life, appreciate it. You will never have these times back, you will never be in high school again. It is hard for someone still in high school to wrap their brain around, but there will be a day when you wish you could be in the shoes you're in right now. Here are 15 things I have learned being in college that I wish I knew as a high school senior:

Keep Reading...Show less
one tree hill
Wikimedia

Everyone, and I mean everyone has heard of the show "One Tree Hill". Many people think that this show is the best thing they've ever watched and others won't bother watching it because they know they'll get hooked. And yes, I know many people have written about this show before, but I couldn't resist. I could re-watch every season multiple times to the point where I can almost quote an entire scene. Trust me, once you start "One Tree Hill", you will be hooked. There's way too many reasons to list as to why you'll love this show, and these are just a few.

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

5 Ways To Bring Positivity Into Your Life When All You Want To Do Is Drown In Self-Pity

It seems like life has been serving up more bad than good and in all honesty, the only thing you want to do is crawl under your covers and hide from the rest of the world.

2243
5 Ways To Bring Positivity Into Your Life When All You Want To Do Is Drown In Self-Pity
Photo by Kinga Howard on Unsplash

The first two weeks of classes have come to an end and they have been anything BUT easy. It seems like life has been serving up more bad than good and in all honesty, the only thing you want to do is crawl under your covers and hide from the rest of the world.

Although this seems like the best solution, it is also the easy way out. Take it from the girl who took basically a whole week off from her life because she just could not handle everything that was being thrown at her. This caused her to feel extremely lonely and even more stressed out for being behind in classes that JUST began.

Keep Reading...Show less
friends

1. Thank you for being my person.

2. Thank you for knowing me better than I know myself sometimes.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments