How Race-Based Quotas Perpetuate Discrimination | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

How Race-Based Quotas Perpetuate Discrimination

Discrimination goes both ways.

107
How Race-Based Quotas Perpetuate Discrimination
emaze.com

Race, an element that distinguishes skin color, identity, and culture, seems to be a contentious topic in our society today. The fact that race is even a considered factor in today’s institutions seems archaic to me, and I think it should be done away with since the only race that matters is the human race.

Affirmative action and the development of race-based quotas in the United States emerged from the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and it continues to be a precedent that shapes the “inclusive actions” made by institutions in the nation in order to reverse the effect of historic racial discrimination against minority groups. While I understand the nature and logic of this legislation, I have become increasingly opposed to it. There is sufficient evidence that can be presented from the fact that affirmative action and race-based quotas are simply a facade to a supposedly more inclusive environment. Inclusiveness should solely be based on merit, and if race is taken into consideration, it creates a system in which skin color determines the quality of the individual. I do not think race should take precedence over an individual’s ability, and the truth is, affirmative action gives precedence to race over merit. This system supposedly creates more equality by dictating a quota and creating an exclusive environment in which certain demographics have to be admitted. This, in turn, lowers the standard of admission into these institutions, and this has become evident over the past 40 years.

Regents of the University of California v. Bakke is a Supreme Court case that proves the discriminatory nature of race-based quotas. Allan Bakke, a Caucasian male who was a veteran of the Vietnam War, graduated with honors in engineering from the University of Minnesota, had a master’s degree in engineering from Stanford, and worked for NASA. He decided to apply for admission into the medical school of the University of California at Davis but was denied admission twice on the basis that he did not meet a certain racial quota because he was a Caucasian male. The University of California became part of the affirmative action program that reserved a certain quota for minorities. Bakke was overwhelmingly qualified for admission into the program, but because he did not fit a certain racial quota, he was denied admission. Bakke then proceeded to sue the University for violation of the Equal Protection Clause which grants equal protection to an individual irrespective of race.

The special admissions program was deemed unconstitutional because it dismissed an applicant solely based on his race. Bakke was more than qualified for his admission, but the reason why he was rejected was because he did not fit a certain racial criterion. Justice Powell states that when an admission program “considers race only as one factor” and dismisses the consideration of “all pertinent elements of diversity in light of the particular qualifications,” discriminates against race even thought the program “professes to have a nondiscriminatory admissions policy.” The University’s race-based preferential program disregards individual rights and is in violation of the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees equal treatment of all. The using of racial quotas in admission programs is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause, and race should not be the focus of consideration in an admission process. The Court did allow for race to be considered as one of the many admissible factors in achieving diversity and the “robust exchange of ideas,” but using race as the basis of selection is discriminatory.

There are many institutions, including Ivy League ones, that have lowered their standards in order to admit a certain demographic and achieve diversity. I think this goes against the Equal Protection Clause, and it is an unfair practice that perpetuates the cycle of discrimination. This not only erodes the standard of institutions in the nation, but it is also potentially detrimental to the economy. This is because there is a possibility of qualified individuals being potentially replaced by other less qualified individuals over the “preferential” element of race.

I am by no means discrediting the success of individuals who are minorities, but I am questioning a flawed system that has become increasingly discriminatory. It is not viable to fix a historically discriminatory system with another discriminatory system. I am a proponent of the Civil Rights Movement and the principles that Martin Luther King Jr. fought for. I think this movement has already set out to achieve equality, and this is evident in the 21st Century. I think it is misconstrued to state that minority groups are oppressed by an increasingly discriminatory system. In contrast, I think minority groups have been given equal opportunity and beyond. There are, of course, other underlying problems that affect certain demographics and hamper their ability to achieve success, and those issues reflect the culture and mentality that has been stemmed forth from the effects of oppression and entitlement, however, the pendulum, over time, has swung to the other end of the spectrum to which the effects are similarly disastrous. I think the remedy for a better system is the improvement of the standard of education, and the reintroduction of the idea of success through merit.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
student sleep
Huffington Post

I think the hardest thing about going away to college is figuring out how to become an adult. Leaving a household where your parents took care of literally everything (thanks, Mom!) and suddenly becoming your own boss is overwhelming. I feel like I'm doing a pretty good job of being a grown-up, but once in awhile I do something that really makes me feel like I'm #adulting. Twenty-somethings know what I'm talking about.

Keep Reading...Show less
school
blogspot

I went to a small high school, like 120-people-in-my-graduating-class small. It definitely had some good and some bad, and if you also went to a small high school, I’m sure you’ll relate to the things that I went through.

1. If something happens, everyone knows about it

Who hooked up with whom at the party? Yeah, heard about that an hour after it happened. You failed a test? Sorry, saw on Twitter last period. Facebook fight or, God forbid, real fight? It was on half the class’ Snapchat story half an hour ago. No matter what you do, someone will know about it.

Keep Reading...Show less
Chandler Bing

I'm assuming that we've all heard of the hit 90's TV series, Friends, right? Who hasn't? Admittedly, I had pretty low expectations when I first started binge watching the show on Netflix, but I quickly became addicted.

Without a doubt, Chandler Bing is the most relatable character, and there isn't an episode where I don't find myself thinking, Yup, Iam definitely the Chandler of my friend group.

Keep Reading...Show less
eye roll

Working with the public can be a job, in and of itself. Some people are just plain rude for no reason. But regardless of how your day is going, always having to be in the best of moods, or at least act like it... right?

1. When a customer wants to return a product, hands you the receipt, where is printed "ALL SALES ARE FINAL" in all caps.

2. Just because you might be having a bad day, and you're in a crappy mood, doesn't make it okay for you to yell at me or be rude to me. I'm a person with feelings, just like you.

3. People refusing to be put on hold when a customer is standing right in front of you. Oh, how I wish I could just hang up on you!

Keep Reading...Show less
blair waldorf
Hercampus.com

RBF, or resting b*tch face, is a serious condition that many people suffer from worldwide. Suffers are often bombarded with daily questions such as "Are you OK?" and "Why are you so mad?" If you have RBF, you've probably had numerous people tell you to "just smile!"

While this question trend can get annoying, there are a couple of pros to having RBF.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments