Why Grammar is Overrated | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Student Life

Why Grammar is Overrated

A look at Linguistics

471
Why Grammar is Overrated

There is a difference between the way we speak and the way we are taught to speak. Inherently, language is different for each person-- the environments in which we learn language in, the words that we hear, the way the words are strung together, and even the way words are pronounced gives each person an individual language, or an idiolect. And since this is the case, it can be difficult to understand why certain idiolects are often judged as not being as proper or intelligent as others.

Cultures attempt to regulate which languages and which language principles are used. This gap between what we "should" say and what we "do" say can be described using the linguistic terms prescriptive and descriptive grammar. Prescriptive grammar are the rules that we, as a community of language speakers, have set for ourselves to follow. In contrast, descriptive grammar is the way that we actually speak when communicating in a language.

To be more specific, while it is not grammatically correct to use "Me" instead of "I", many English speakers often say things like, "It was me who called you?" This is an example of descriptive grammar, since it is not grammatically correct, but it has been accepted and understood as "normal" by English speakers. Many linguists use the terms acceptable or unacceptable to describe descriptive grammar and proper or improper to describe prescriptive grammar.

So while it is improper to use "Me" instead of "I", it is acceptable in the general population of language speakers. However, if a language speaker violates the rules of descriptive grammar, the sentence is unintelligible and the meaning cannot be derived from it, making it both improper and unacceptable. For instance, if someone said "We were going to go right afterwards and like and be there and just like hopelessly wandering" the point of the sentence is not understood by the listener. This violates prescriptive and descriptive grammar rules.

Another example, "I'm going to the FFC, want to come with?" violates prescriptive grammar because it ends with a preposition. But ending with a preposition is a common way of speaking in the English language. Although the phrase is technically improper, it is an acceptable way of speaking when looking at descriptive language rules.

One of the reasons linguists use and support descriptive grammar instead of prescriptive grammar is because there is an inherent judgement about the value of a someone's sentence and idiolect when using prescriptive grammar. As long as the sentence structure and words can and are understood by the listeners of a language, the language should be seen as acceptable. The language of one class or culture is no better or more right than that of another class.

Dialects, or generalizations of similar idiolects by culture or region, vary due to environments, and the differences do not illustrate superiority. Saying that one dialect is worse than another would be equivalent to saying that English is better than Spanish, Japanese, or Korean. Neither language is more "right" than the other.

Today, there are many people who shame those who speak without prescribing to prescriptive grammar rules. One of these situations is Black English Vernacular (BEV) in which the dialect has a stigma-- and is looked down on by many who believe it is not "proper" or intelligent English. However, BEV has its own set of descriptive language rules that determine the acceptability. For instance, double negation is very common in BEV, saying, "I didn't do nothing" is common in BEV even though it might not be "proper" in the rules of prescriptive grammar that have been set in society.

As a result, stereotypes have resulted that affect the way other classes view BEV speakers. Black English Vernacular is just one example of hundreds of different dialects that can be found in English. There are pervasive prejudices toward non-standard dialects in our society. But because of what we know about descriptive and prescriptive grammar, these attitudes should no longer be valued or prevalent conceptions.

By eliminating the rumor that certain dialects are "better" than others, society will be able to accept different ways of speaking without placing values on certain ways of speaking. Prescriptive grammar is a way of looking at and analyzing language, but it shouldn't be the basis for which we judge the acceptability of language.

Descriptive language is the rule that linguists use because it eliminates the inherent stereotypes and value placements when comparing dialects and idiolects. The beauty of language is its infinite possibilities and arrangements, and descriptive language allows us to embrace these differences instead of judging them.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
college just ahead sign
Wordpress

1. You will have that special "college" look to you.

2. You will feel like an adult but also feeling like a child.

3. You will have classes that are just the professor reading from their lecture slides for an hour.

4. You will need to study but also want to hang out with your friends.

5. Coffee is your best friend.

6. You don't know what you're doing 99% of the time.

7. You will procrastinate and write a paper the night before it is due.

8. Money is a mythical object.

9. It is nearly impossible to motivate yourself to go to classes during spring.

10. The food pyramid goes out the window.

11. You will have at least one stress induced breakdown a semester.

12. Most lecture classes will bore you to tears.

13. You will not like all of your professors.

14. You will try to go to the gym... but you will get too lazy at some point.

15. When you see high school students taking tours:

16. You will try to convince yourself that you can handle everything.

17. Finals week will try to kill you.

18. You won't like everyone, but you will find your best friends sooner or later.

19. You actually have to go to class.

20. Enjoy it, because you will be sad when it is all over.

girl with a hat

This is for the girls who have dealt with an emotionally, mentally, physically or verbally abusive father.

The ones who have grown up with a false lens of what love is and how relationships should be. The ones who have cried themselves to sleep wondering why he hurts you and your family so much. This is for all the girls who fall in love with broken boys that carry baggage bigger than their own, thinking it's their job to heal them because you watched your mother do the same.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf Quote
"DESTINY IS FOR LOSERS. IT'S JUST A STUPID EXCUSE TO WAIT FOR THINGS TO HAPPEN INSTEAD OF MAKING THEM HAPPEN." - BLAIR WALDORF.

The world stopped in 2012 when our beloved show "Gossip Girl" ended. For six straight years, we would all tune in every Monday at 9:00 p.m. to see Upper Eastside royalty in the form of a Burberry headband clad Blair Waldorf. Blair was the big sister that we all loved to hate. How could we ever forget the epic showdowns between her and her frenemy Serena Van Der Woodsen? Or the time she banished Georgina Sparks to a Christian summer camp? How about that time when she and her girls took down Bart Bass? Blair is life. She's taught us how to dress, how to be ambitious, and most importantly, how to throw the perfect shade.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Moments Every College Freshman Has Experienced

Because we made it, and because high school seniors deserve to know what they're getting themselves into

669
too tired to care

We've all been there. From move-in day to the first finals week in college, your first term is an adventure from start to finish. In honor of college decisions coming out recently, I want to recap some of the most common experiences college freshmen experience.

1. The awkward hellos on move-in day.

You're moving your stuff onto your floor, and you will encounter people you don't know yet in the hallway. They live on your floor, so you'll awkwardly smile and maybe introduce yourself. As you walk away, you will wonder if they will ever speak to you again, but don't worry, there's a good chance that you will make some great friends on your floor!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

21 Things I've Learned About College Life

College is not what everyone expects it to be.

347
laptop
Unsplash

The college years are a time for personal growth and success. Everyone comes in with expectations about how their life is supposed to turn out and envision the future. We all freak out when things don't go exactly as planned or when our expectations are unmet. As time goes on, we realize that the uncertainty of college is what makes it great. Here are some helpful reminders about life in college.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments