The Utter Disconnect Between Critics And Audiences | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

The Utter Disconnect Between Critics And Audiences

Are we even watching the same film?

1069
The Utter Disconnect Between Critics And Audiences
20th Century Fox, YouTube

"I laughed, I cried, but I know it's not good because it has a 29% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes."

Have you ever wondered how critical reviews of movies came to be? I sure have. At some time, the act of a few people telling everyone else whether or not a film was worth seeing may have served a legitimate purpose, but only because the critics vision of what constituted a "good" movie agreed with that of the general audience. Nowadays, it's only too clear that critics (with the notable exception of Lane Strawberry) are thoroughly disconnected from the public they intend to serve.

While some films are definitely agreed upon as universally amazing (The Lord of the Rings trilogy, for example) and some as unequivocally horrible (After Earth comes to mind), most fall somewhere in between, in the sweet gooeyness of subjectivity.

A multitude of examples of critics' inability to appreciate their audiences' tastes arises instantly, and memorably, in the form of films such as Warcraft, Justice League, and The Greatest Showman. The Rotten Tomatoes scores are as follows:

Warcraft--28%

Justice League--40%

The Greatest Showman--54%

Based off of these dismal "rotten" scores, one might assume that these films hardly bare any value as cinematic achievements or even vessels of entertainment. But judging them by their audience approval rating tells a different story:

Warcraft--77%

Justice League--77%

The Greatest Showman--90%

Clearly, these figures show that these films (especially The Greatest Showman) were overwhelmingly enjoyed by the general audience.

In the same vein, critical darlings can be found that utterly failed in their attempt to leave a positive impression on the average filmgoer. Such films as Hail, Caesar!, which has a resounding 85% "fresh" critical rating on Rotten Tomatoes, or even Star Wars: The Last Jedi, with its 90% critical approval rating, have proven through their audience ratings that critics must be watching a different movie.

Unsurprisingly, each film's audience approval rating was roughly half of the critical one, with Hail Caesar! earning a 44% and Star Wars: The Last Jedi at an only slightly better 49%. Another keen example of this dissimilarity in taste is mother!, a film originally acclaimed by critics yet it went on to receive an uber-rare "F" rating on Cinema Score from audiences.

Should there be such a disconnect between critics and the general public or should critics function as representatives of moviegoers? Has the movie critic industry reached such self-absorbed state as to be wholly unappreciable by the layman?

You be the judge.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
girl holding phone
NYCPRGIRLS

Now that it seems “talking” is the new way to date, and will stay that way until another idiotic term is used to describe the people who can’t settle down and just date someone, I feel as if it’s time to go over the unwritten rules of “talking.”

Rule 1. Having feeling without feeling.

Keep Reading...Show less
The Stages of Having FOMO in College
iamthatgirl.com

Are you one of those people that gets super upset when you miss out on anything? Well, you may have FOMO, or fear of missing out. In college it’s not hard to experience FOMO every once in a while. You just love doing everything and anything, so hen you have to miss out on something it's the worst possible thing in your mind. Whether you’re sick, have to work, or have so much work to do you could cry – FOMO will hit you hard in college.

Keep Reading...Show less
Vivien Leigh
Revelist

I've lived a whole 21 years with an RBF (Resting Bitch Face), so naturally, I go through most of these struggles on a daily basis.

And before you ask, yes I'm fine. No, I'm not mad. This is just my face, so take it or leave it! To those of you who have been #blessed with an RBF, you'll probably relate to these more than you'd like to:

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

Iconic Duos: Timeless Legends

From Luke and Leia to Beyonce's twins...

774612
Luke and Leia from Star Wars, a iconic duo
Lucasfilm

“Name a more iconic duo... I'll wait." OK, well, if you insist. In no particular order, here's a list of 100 iconic duos that seem to be timeless.

SEE MORE: This Is The ICONIC Disney Sidekick You Are To Your BFF, According To Your Zodiac Sign

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

A Candid Letter to My Best Friends Ex

Because this is the real form of torture you deserve.

769
middle finger
Photo by engin akyurt on Unsplash

What's up Asshat,

I've composed a list of things that I wish upon you, and they're harsh and cruel. These things are things that I wouldn't wish upon my worst of enemies, not even that Starbuck's barista who always screws up my order, not even him. You fall into a whole other category of hate. You surpass Starbucks barista. Congratulations, I'm actually a pretty nice person, making you worthy of every single bit of torture I wish upon you. What are these things I wish upon you you might ask?

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments