Where’s YouTube’s Line? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

Where’s YouTube’s Line?

Are the YouTube Community Guidelines even worth it?

39
Where’s YouTube’s Line?
youtube.com

As a person following YouTube site drama, I’d always felt like “it would never happen to me”. I’m not a big YouTuber by any means. I watched the Adpocalypse and heard about videos being demonetized and taken down left, right, and center, hitting the big people on the platform and threatening their livelihood.

So last Sunday I uploaded a video I had just spent six hours the night before finishing, a Game of Thrones edit I was incredibly proud of. Within a half hour, I went to check on if it had gotten any views and found it had disappeared. It had violated YouTube’s Community Guidelines (never said which one specifically, but I guessed it was the “violence” one) and had been removed from the site. I had one strike against my channel in the Community Guidelines section but it would drop in 3 months. From following other channels’ troubles, I knew I could appeal. So I did. Last Thursday it was back up.

From my research, I know it is often an algorithm that initially takes down videos. There’s no way a human could go through the thousands of minutes of video content uploaded to YouTube every minute. But no algorithm is perfect, and way too many videos have been dinged for things taken out of context. A robot doesn’t know the difference between comedy and reality, fantasy and journalism.

I understand why advertisers started getting snippy. No one at Wal-Mart wants a Wal-Mart ad playing next to a journalist being beheaded by the Taliban. In my experience, I know that does not mean Wal-Mart supports the Taliban, but that is what the advertisers think. So YouTube lost many sponsors and was pressured to crack down on content, creating their Community Guidelines.

Is YouTube getting too sensitive?

They are a company, and companies need to have policies that partners have to follow in order to be a part of it. If a partner violates the policies, they will no longer be a part of the company. And before I hear the argument of “free speech”, even though YouTube is based in the United States, it is a worldwide company with contributors from around the world. There is a line.

THAT BEING SAID there is a big difference between fantasy violence knowingly consumed by the viewer and very real journalism taking place in our very real world that needs to be spread to raise awareness of things that are sometimes just words and numbers.

Some of the Guidelines make sense. Threats, hateful content, and spam should be stopped in their paths. But the others make less sense. Language, violence, and dangerous content are things found in movies and TV shows and people have the choice to watch them. At the very least, I would recommend YouTube starts doing the thing Facebook has done and put before a video “this video has graphic content; would you like to proceed?”. Age-gating should work to an extent as well, if necessary.

I will be watching even more carefully in the future to see what YouTube is coming up with next. Will there be a solution, or will there be a new platform ready to take its place?

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
girls with mascot
Personal Photo

College is tough, we all know. Here are 8 gifs you will 99% relate to if you are in college.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

7 Things College Has Taught Me

Other than knowledge and all those important things

318
7 Things College Has Taught Me
We Know Memes

So, college is the place where you're supposed to learn all of these amazing life skills.

Here are the top seven skills I have learned thus far.

Keep Reading...Show less
college

College is some of the greatest years of anyone's life. Its a time to be outrageous, different and free; a time to do everything you were afraid to do. Here are 38 things you will learn during your four (maybe, five or six) years in college!

1. As a freshman, one does get to be called “freshman” by upperclassmen when they walk to parties in a mob of people.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

6 Unrealistic Expectations Society Has For Young Adults

Don't let the thesaurus-inspired vocabularies in our résumés fool you. We're actually just big kids.

2991
boy in adult clothes

Well over four feet tall and 100 pounds in weight, many of us "young adults" of the world still consider ourselves children. Big, working, college-attending, beer-drinking children. We may live on our own, know how to cook noodles, and occasionally use a planner, but don't be fooled; the youthful tendencies that reside within us still make their way into our daily lives. From choosing to stay up until 3:00 a.m. playing video games on a school night to going out in 30 degree weather without a coat, we still make decisions that our parents and grandparents would shake their heads at in disappointment. So why are we expected to know exactly how to be a wise, professional, sensible adult? It's not that we're irresponsible (for the most part, anyway). It's that we are young, inexperienced, and still have the sought-after, enthusiastic mentality that we can do and be whatever we want, which has not yet been tarnished by the reality of the world. These are just a few of the unrealistic expectations that society has for young adults.

Keep Reading...Show less
pizza
Fandango

There are a lot of foods in this world, but there is only one dish that stands above the rest: Pizza. If you're close to me or at least know who I am, then you know that I'm totally obsessed with pizza. It's one of my favorite things to eat and I will NEVER turn down a slice, even if it doesn't have my favorite toppings. There isn't a day that goes by where I'm not thinking about pizza. I even sleep with a pizza pillow every night! There are many reasons why pizza stands above all other foods, and here are just a couple reasons why.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments