When Is A Refugee Not A Refugee? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics

When Is A Refugee Not A Refugee?

Developed countries continue failing to solve the refugee crises and favor closing off their borders against sanctuary seekers, instead.

17
When Is A Refugee Not A Refugee?
themuslimissue.wordpress.com

Text Box: A refugee is ‘someone who is unable or unwilling to return to their country of origin owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion’
- UN Convention on refugees

No one chooses to become a refugee. To flee one’s home and traditions to the uncertainty of a different country is against human nature, itself, and those who seek this path as a refugee have no other choice. The UN Convention itself states that a refugee is"‘someone who’s unable to return to their country." They fear that their rights as a human being will be violated if they return to their countries of origin and have no alternative but to leave everything behind and flee their home.

A refugee is ‘someone who is unable or unwilling to return to their country of origin owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion’

- UN Convention on refugees

From the past five years and on, the world has a growing refugee crisis that now extends to 19.5 million people trying to reach sanctuary Text Box: When is a refugee not a refugee?
Examining the Eritrean refugee experience (TBC)
abroad. With multiple crises brewing up in the Middle East and Africa in addition to the Syrian Republic critical situation, the number of forced displacement of people grew exponentially in the past three years, a 40 percent rise according to UNHRC.

This increasing rate of displaced people made developed countries try to shut their border and take "Deterrence Tactics" to avoid the problem and conveniently leave developing countries and overwhelmed humanitarian agencies to host and help more than 80 percent of all refugees. Xenophobia is a major factor in most of those cases, and European nationality has been growing due to this fear of the foreign.

Besides obnoxious border control practices that keep people from a relatively physical security, countries are now looking for legal deterrent schemes to put in practice against refugees. In January 2016, both Swiss and Danish government approved a law to seize refugee’s valuable assets to cover the costs of them seeking help there. The news of inhuman treatment of refugees from Denmark and Switzerland spread fast, and refugees try to look elsewhere for asylum.

This is not the right solution to the problem of millions of displaced people seeking security from mass crimes, war and rapes. This new law sparked, rightly so, an outrage from the global community, but many of the deterrent practices still go unnoticed by the citizens of the world, in particular against the refugees from African countries like Eritrea.

The Eritrean conflict has been going many years before the Syrian refugee crisis sparked in 2015, and the United Nations Human Rights Council established a Commission as early as 1991 to investigate violations of human rights in Eritrea, with crimes as serious as torture, violations during compulsory national service and extrajudicial killings and abductions. People have been fleeing Eritrean dictatorial rule for more than a decade trying to seek asylum in Ethiopia, Sudan, Israel and European countries, especially in the UK.

In desperation to back away from all this crime and violence that came with the dictatorial political partText Box: ‘On the basis of the body of information collected by the end of its investigation, the Commission concludes that some of the violations identified may constitute crimes against humanity and recommends further investigation.’
- Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in Eritrea

y in power, Eritreans take dangerous routes with deserts and neighboring warring countries to find protection mostly in Sudan and Ethiopia, plus many that come to Europe through the Mediterranean deadly seas. Many can’t even make it to Europe due to the dangerous trip, but the alternative is to be oppressed and scared in “Africa’s North Korea,” a nickname based on lack of civil liberties this government has imposed since it started in 1991.

Developed countries were receptive to the Eritreans that found themselves there in previous years of the Eritrean crisis. Those were the years where compassion was greater than fear.

This receptiveness changed with the recent refugee crisis development and refugee’s number boost in the past few years. In December 2014, the Danish Immigration Service released an Immigration Report on Eritrea that suggested that the same authoritarian government is working towards change in the abusive national conscription program.

Human Rights Watch pointed out how deeply flawed the report was, since the specialists writing it just interviewed members of the government itself and anonymous diplomats, thus ignoring the cries of thousands of forcibly displaced people witnesses of the human rights violations.

Despite the multiple contradictory statements and the highly contested Report, Danish government still used it as an argument to deny asylum to the Eritrean refugees ever since it was published, with the UK following it. This Danish Report has been used by developed countries to deny refugee status for displaced Eritrean, and they're often deported because of it.

Even as a UN report from June 2015 states that people returning to Eritrea are often arrested and tortured in infamousText Box: ‘The sources also often qualify their statements, noting that there is no independent access to detention centers, that the fate of people returned to Eritrea is unclear, and that government reforms of the national service conscription are rumored, but not confirmed.’ 
- Human Rights Watch

prisons, the practice since last year was to reject Eritrean asylum seekers more quickly using this unclear report. This adjustment ended up plummeting the 73 percent approval rate of Eritreans granted protection in the UK in the first quarter of 2015 to a shocking 34 percent in the second quarter. According to Dr. John Campbell, a specialist in anthropology in Africa and Law at the University of London, “(The Home Office) based on a highly selective use of information and it deliberately distorts information to support its own conclusions.”

This distortion of the situation in Eritrea by the UK Home Office is one of the many deterrence tactics used by governments to mistreat Eritrean refugees: Sudanese government deported at least 2000 Eritreans back to their home country without allowing them full International Rights early 2016 and European governments are strictly tightening their border control practices. Countries like Denmark, UK, Switzerland, Sudan and Israel choose to deny refugees coming in by either forcibly deporting them or by mistreating them to the point where even their jewelry is confiscated to cope with the costs of having them there.

Developed countries, especially in Europe, are choosing to apply all these inhuman practices rather than working together with other countries to end this refugee crisis. This needs to stop.

Developed countries need to be concerned with finding solutions to the refugee crises rather than wasting efforts with new ways to close borders. There's no easy solution to the multiple refugee crises around the world, but shutting off your country to them and washing your hands away of responsibility is no right way to deal with this.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
students
Sophia Palmerine

Dear High School Friend Group,

My sweet angels, where would I be without you guys. We all grew up together because we either met in middle school or high school and watched each other grow up and get "old." We got to go to prom together and then graduate together. Then watched each other as we continued our lives in college, joining sororities and meeting people who will impact our lives forever. It all has happened so fast.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

College In Gifs

Because we are all sad Jim Halpert

650
head on desk
Wise GEEK

Oh college, we can’t live with you, but we can’t live without you. It’s a love/hate relationship, really. College is an experience that no one can ever prepare you for, and maybe that’s a good thing. You never really expect any of the things that college encompasses until you are there. College is fun, but don’t have too much fun. C’s get degrees, but they don’t get you into graduate school.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf

The "Gossip Girl" series may be over, but Blair Waldorf's iconic character lives in our hearts forever. Blair was the queen of the Upper East Side, and a character you either loved or hated. She taught us everything we needed to know about life, love and of course, how to score a Chuck Bass. So the next time you feel a bit lost and are in need of guidance, look no further than to the Queen B herself.

As I spend my Sunday avoiding my homework and other adult responsibilities, I realized that I've watched this series over and over about a million times. Sadly, there isn't a Blair quote I don't know, so I came up with a list of a few favorites. You know you love her...xoxo

Keep Reading...Show less
class
Odyssey

College is an endless cycle of crappy, sleepless nights, tedious, boring lectures, and hours of never-ending piles of homework.

Keep Reading...Show less
two women enjoying confetti

Summer: a time (usually) free from school work and a time to relax with your friends and family. Maybe you go on a vacation or maybe you work all summer, but the time off really does help. When you're in college you become super close with so many people it's hard to think that you won't see many of them for three months. But, then you get that text saying, "Hey, clear your schedule next weekend, I'm coming up" and you begin to flip out. Here are the emotions you go through as your best friend makes her trip to your house.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments