The Truth About Eyewitness Testimony | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

The Truth About Eyewitness Testimony

Eyewitness memories aren't as reliable as they seem.

54
The Truth About Eyewitness Testimony
Wynn & Wynn

Recently I had a friend come to me with a stressful situation. Her grandfather, someone who she loved dearly and completely trusted, had been accused of raping a young woman. My friend swore by everything up and down that he could have never done anything so malicious. The only convicting evidence against her grandfather was the eyewitness testimony of the alleged victim.

From everything I heard about the case from that point, it was obvious that this young woman had been victimized and sexually assaulted. She did have to suffer through a horrible experience that many of us shudder to imagine. But I do not believe that my friend's grandfather was the man who assaulted her.

Many people do not realize the faults in eyewitness testimonies, and yet these testimonies often hold the power to completely turn the judge and jury in a court of law.

Based on a study conducted by the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, it is estimated that one in every 25 people sentenced to death is innocent. Since 1973, 144 innocent people on death row have been exonerated from their sentence through new DNA inspections. The House Police Department states that 80 percent of exonerated men were put behind bars because of a false eyewitness testimony.

False eyewitness testimonies are not limited to lying to the court under oath. Actually, it's much more common for an eyewitness to have a lapse in memory than to lie in the courtroom.

For example, the time between the act of the crime and the testimony in the courtroom can span from weeks to months or even years. Psychologist Jack P. Lipton found in his study that after a one week period, memory recall had an 18 percent difference in the amount of the event that could be recalled. This 18 percent could include the color and model of a car or the face of the person harming them.

Other fallacies in testimonies also occur due to the bias of investigators who subtly push victims into believing a certain person is guilty because the police already suspect that person.

Despite all of the errors that could easily occur in eyewitness testimonies, they still are paramount to assigning of guilt in a courtroom. According to a study conducted by psychologist Cindy Laub, jury members are more influenced by the testimony of a witness than the association of weapons, drugs, violence, or disguising in a crime.

It's importance to raise awareness on this subject to keep innocent men and women out of prison. It's important to realize that people make mistakes, even seemingly confident eyewitnesses. Perhaps through raising awareness, we can also instill changes in the court system from the beginning, such as to not allow biased investigators to interview a possible victim. Something this simple could alleviate biases influencing the witness to make a wrong conviction and testimony. Something this simple could save lives.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

8 Things I Realized After My First Semester In College

Actually, Kylie Jenner, 2018 is the year of realizing things.

93
Friends

The first semester of college is famous for being one of the most difficult transitions of one's young adult life. You're thrown into a completely new area where the majority of the people surrounding you are strangers in an academic environment that's much more challenging then what you've grown accustomed to for the past twelve years. On top of that, you probably share a room with another person (or even multiple people) on the lumpiest "mattress" you've ever slept on.

With this change comes a lot of questions: what do I want to major in? What am I passionate about? Is what I'm passionate about something I'm actually good at? Why does the bathroom smell like cranberry juice and vodka? What is that thing at the bottom of the shower drain?

Keep Reading...Show less
girls with mascot
Personal Photo

College is tough, we all know. Here are 8 gifs you will 99% relate to if you are in college.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

7 Things College Has Taught Me

Other than knowledge and all those important things

396
7 Things College Has Taught Me
We Know Memes

So, college is the place where you're supposed to learn all of these amazing life skills.

Here are the top seven skills I have learned thus far.

Keep Reading...Show less
college

College is some of the greatest years of anyone's life. Its a time to be outrageous, different and free; a time to do everything you were afraid to do. Here are 38 things you will learn during your four (maybe, five or six) years in college!

1. As a freshman, one does get to be called “freshman” by upperclassmen when they walk to parties in a mob of people.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

6 Unrealistic Expectations Society Has For Young Adults

Don't let the thesaurus-inspired vocabularies in our résumés fool you. We're actually just big kids.

3054
boy in adult clothes

Well over four feet tall and 100 pounds in weight, many of us "young adults" of the world still consider ourselves children. Big, working, college-attending, beer-drinking children. We may live on our own, know how to cook noodles, and occasionally use a planner, but don't be fooled; the youthful tendencies that reside within us still make their way into our daily lives. From choosing to stay up until 3:00 a.m. playing video games on a school night to going out in 30 degree weather without a coat, we still make decisions that our parents and grandparents would shake their heads at in disappointment. So why are we expected to know exactly how to be a wise, professional, sensible adult? It's not that we're irresponsible (for the most part, anyway). It's that we are young, inexperienced, and still have the sought-after, enthusiastic mentality that we can do and be whatever we want, which has not yet been tarnished by the reality of the world. These are just a few of the unrealistic expectations that society has for young adults.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments