Trump's Dangerous Iran Obsession | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics

Trump Has An Iran Obsession And It Needs To Be Addressed

The president is wrong that Iran is more dangerous than China or Russia.

142
trump and iran

Since the 2007 financial crisis, democracy across the world have been in retreat. As the United States and other Western countries stagnate economically, authoritarianism calls ever more strongly. In already autocratic states, strongmen have only made conditions worse, like Xi Jinping in China, Kim Jong Un in North Korea and Vladimir Putin in Russia.

To make matters worse, U.S. President Donald Trump has fairly good relationships with all three of those men.

Around the globe, Trump has sought to soothe relations with autocrats, which many have said has emboldened them and their imitators in other countries. But there is one nation with which Trump has been unwavering in his criticism: Iran. Even as he has opened the possibility of a nuclear deal with North Korea, he has ripped up the deal that the previous administration had made with Iran. Last Monday, the leader of the free world threatened on Twitter that Hassan Rouhani would "SUFFER CONSEQUENCES" after the Iranian president said (very menacingly!) that "peace with Iran is the mother of all peace, and war with Iran is the mother of all wars."

It isn't uncommon for a world leader to threaten war with the United States as a way of posturing to his citizens. But before Trump took office, it was virtually unheard of for the U.S. president to even acknowledge such threats. And, as a point of technicality, Rouhani wasn't waving around a declaration of war; he was requesting that the U.S. not wade into another Middle Eastern quagmire, which hardly needed to be said to most Americans.

Rouhani's comments are reflective of Iran's broader position in Middle Eastern geopolitics. Since the Islamic revolution of 1979, Iran has sought to get its fingers into as many regional affairs as possible in an effort to assert its legitimacy. But after decades of weaseling its way to being the foremost Shia Muslim country, Iran's foreign policy elite are more fearful than ever of their position in the region than ever. Compared with Saudi Arabia, its Sunni-majority archrival, Iran is far less connected with its allies; it is hard to imagine the Islamic Republic pulling off a multilateral blockade of one of its neighbors like the Saudis did with Qatar.

This is what makes the American preference for Saudi Arabia so confusing. A more rational actor might side with the weaker rival, which would be Iran. Additionally, America has few cultural ties with either nation, but there are more Iranian Americans than residents from the kingdom. Neither is a particularly democratic state, but Iran has an elected president who submits decisions to a religious leader, who executes them, whereas the Saudi royalty is all-powerful.

Iran does, however, run with the grain of countries Trump does not like. His affection for Putin is well-documented; he has an on-again, off-again friendship with Xi. After a war of words with Kim, the North Korean leader invited the American president to a nuclear disarmament summit, which Trump accepted.

All of these countries have one thing in common: they are run by strongmen whose authority is never questioned. Under Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Saudi Arabia fits this pattern.

Iran, on the other hand, is more complex, with multiple actors at play in any one decision made. Its Ayatollah, Ali Khamenei, is selected by the religious community, while the president is elected by the people. The Revolutionary Guard Corps, Iran's powerful paramilitary force, may also have a say in decision-making. There is also an elected, quasi-parliamentary Consultative Assembly, but as its name suggests, it wields little actual power.

The Trump administration's posture towards autocracies is awkward at best, but the easiest explanation for it seems to be little more than that Trump likes things simple. It's easy to hold a joint press conference with Vladimir Putin for no reason, but who does he call when he wants to address human rights abuses (OK, more like the next Trump hotel) in Iran? Is Rouhani the top authority? Khamenei? Maybe the head of the Guard Corps? This preference for simplicity may explain what some have called Trump's authoritarian tendencies.

Iran is not an ally, but it could become more of a partner in the fight against terrorism in the Middle East or protecting U.S. allies from real threats like Chinese and Russian influence.

What is needed is a more frank assessment of Iran's actual position and its capacity as a player within the U.S.'s sphere of influence.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
April Ludgate
NBC Universal

Everyone who is in college right now, or has ever been, knows the struggle of pulling in the strings at the last second. It seems impossible, and you have to do a LOT of things in order to assure your future for the next semester.

April Ludgate, historically, is a very annoyed person, and she doesn't hide it. Of all the times that I binged and re-binged "Parks and Rec," her attitude relates more and more to me.

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

To The Cheerful Person On Their Rainy Days, You Are Valid

The world is not always sunshine and rainbows, and you do not have to be, either.

293
pug covered with blanket on bedspread
Photo by Matthew Henry on Unsplash

Ask friends of mine to name a quality about me, and one a lot them will point out the fact that I am almost always smiling. I like to laugh and smile -- not to quote Buddy the Elf in April, but smiling is my favorite! It is probably my favorite go-to expression. However, what a lot of people do not see is that I have my down days. I have days when smiling and laughing is a real struggle, or when I have so much on my plate that going out of my way to behappy takes more effort than I have stored in me. Be it a symptom of college and growing up or a facet of life, I cannot always be content.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Struggles of Packing for College

It would be so much easier to just pay someone to do it for you

354
a room with boxes and a window

1. Figuring out when to start

Timing is key, you don’t want to start too early or too late.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

15 Times 'Parks and Recreation' Has Summed Up Your Life

Relatable moments from one of the best shows I have ever watched.

267
parks and rec
Liz Keysmash

Amidst my hectic college career, I always find time for one thing, even on the busiest weeks: Parks and Recreation. This show has made me laugh and has made me cry, but most of all I have related to this show more than I would like to admit.

Here are some "Parks and Rec" moments that relate to life struggles that just about everyone faces.

Keep Reading...Show less
April Ludgate
Facebook

April Ludgate from Parks and Recreation is notorious for her "I don't care" attitude. She speaks her mind without caring what anyone thinks of her. Fans love her because she isn't afraid to be herself. April can seem cold and negative, but she's really just fearless and strong-minded. And despite her sometimes harsh words, April truly cares about the people she's closest to. These are all reasons she is the epitome of a college student. April complains whenever she has to do any kind of work, but ends up doing the work anyway. April Ludgate is the ultimate college student spirit animal.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments