Trump Country Isn't Just the Country | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Trump Country Isn't Just the Country

Why aren't we talking about suburban and upper-class Trump voters?

18
Trump Country Isn't Just the Country
Sean O'Flaherty/Wikimedia Commons

I’m sick of post-election articles about “understanding the white working class.” Not because I’m a Trump supporter who hates the “biased” media—I proudly voted for Hillary Clinton—nor because I’m a coastal liberal elite afraid to leave my bubble—I’m certainly not an elite, and while I may be a liberal now, I spent much of my life in the equally-as-strong conservative bubble. It’s because I’m from a small town in Michigan; my family is that very white, working class that coastal pundits are now wringing their hands trying to understand, as if we’re an exotic species to be studied.

Now, this increased focus on my demographic isn’t all bad. It’s true that changes like automation have gutted the traditional manufacturing economy of the Rust Belt, and that rural areas feel ignored or scoffed at by urbanites. What frustrates me is that these articles are overly simplistic. There’s more at work here than just the Democratic party not pandering enough to disaffected ex-factory-employees. What I’ve found lacking in many post-election analyses is a critique of a group that was just as responsible for Trump’s victory and that worries me more: the white upper class.

I can, to some extent, feel compassion for the white working-class who gravitated to Trump’s bravado about bringing their jobs back and recreating a world where rural America wasn’t gutted by falling wages, depopulation, and meth and opiates. It’s much harder to do that with the white upper-classes. If they weren’t voting for Trump because of his empty promises on the economy—then why? His xenophobia? His misogyny? His strongman persona? It’s hard to find a justification I don’t find abhorrent.

Between college graduation and finding a job in Chicago, I lived at home from June through November of last year. I became fascinated with observing which areas of my county had higher proportions of Trump or Clinton signs. Unsurprisingly, the more rural areas had more Trump signs. St. Joseph—my hometown, 90 percent white and much wealthier and better educated than the rest of the county—was more of a mixed bag. Except there was one area of town with a pro-Trump trend: the beachfront houses, some of the most expensive and coveted in town. These are people who, in all likelihood, have not had their way of life shattered by automation and globalization. They may even own two homes, since, in the summer, they run a side business renting out their beachfront home to Chicagoland tourists.

Post-election, I decided to take these observations further by looking at precinct-level election results. On the whole, my county went solidly Trump. St. Joseph voted for Hillary, but barely. Her margin of victory was 51 votes, and it was the slimmest—just seven votes—in precinct one: downtown St. Joseph, which encompasses the historic mansions, the riverfront condos, and those beach houses I ran past. St. Joseph Township, where income is even higher than in the town proper, went for Trump by a much larger margin: 664 votes, or 11.8 percent. St. Joseph Township is the closest my county has to the suburbs, and, like suburban voters nationwide, their precincts voted Trump.

I know enough about statistics to know that correlation doesn’t imply causation. There are certainly upper-class people in St. Joseph who voted for Hillary; I know some personally. But based on those numbers, there also have to be upper-class people who looked the other way on Trump’s problems. I know some of them personally, too.

And, to broaden my data, let’s look at the other place I call home: Chicago. Unsurprisingly, Hillary got 84 percent of Chicago’s votes. She won in 76 of the city’s 77 official community areas. The exception was Mount Greenwood, at the very edge of the city, heavily white and with a median household income of almost $90,000.

These examples abound when we look at national news: Peter Thiel. The Cubs owners. Speaking of sports, Patriots owner Robert Kraft, along with coach Bill Belichick and quarterback Tom Brady. Executives at, among other companies, New Balance, who decided Trump’s stance on the Trans-Pacific Partnership outweighed all else. The roughly half of people with incomes over $100,000 who voted for Trump, or the half of white college graduates who did (according to New York Times exit polls).

These are people who decided that Trump’s ability to make them even more fabulously wealthy was all that mattered. These are people who likely went to a college where they met a diverse range of people but still did not decide to value that diversity. These are people who were willing to throw everyone less privileged under the bus. These are the people who, post-election, I truly disdain.

So why all the reporters travelling to Rust Belt towns like trailblazing anthropologists? Why so many people reading Hillbilly Elegy? Maybe because urban liberals don’t want to admit that their cities are not the multicultural utopias they think they are. It’s easier to imagine hate crimes only happen somewhere else, are only committed by uneducated, Bible-thumping hicks in Mississippi or Iowa. It’s much more comforting to put all the blame on others instead of paying attention to the ugliness in their own backyards: in the Manhattan high-rises and the picket-fence-surrounded houses of the suburbs, in the rich, white, college-educated Americans comfortable enough in their own lives to ignore everyone else.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
man wearing white top using MacBook
Photo by Tim Gouw on Unsplash

College is super hard. Between working, studying, and having a social life, it feels like a struggle to just keep afloat.

I understand. When you feel like your drowning and there's no way to stay afloat I understand that it feels like everyone else is doing just fine. I understand all the frustration, long nights in the library, and that feeling that you want to just throw in the towel. I understand that sometimes it's too hard to get out of bed because your brain is already filled with too much information to remember. I understand because I am also feeling pretty burnt out.

Keep Reading...Show less
No Matter How Challenging School Gets, You Have To Put Your Health First — A Degree Won't Mean Anything If You're Dead
Photo by JESHOOTS.COM on Unsplash

Some of the best advice I've ever received was from my social studies teacher in sophomore year of high school. He stated, "If you don't know it at midnight, you're not going to know it for the 8 a.m. exam, so get some sleep."

It's such a simple piece of advice, but it holds so much accuracy and it's something that the majority of college students need to hear and listen to. "All-nighters" are a commonality on college campuses in order to cram in studying for an exam that is typically the next day.

Keep Reading...Show less
college just ahead sign
Wordpress

1. You will have that special "college" look to you.

2. You will feel like an adult but also feeling like a child.

3. You will have classes that are just the professor reading from their lecture slides for an hour.

4. You will need to study but also want to hang out with your friends.

5. Coffee is your best friend.

6. You don't know what you're doing 99% of the time.

7. You will procrastinate and write a paper the night before it is due.

8. Money is a mythical object.

9. It is nearly impossible to motivate yourself to go to classes during spring.

10. The food pyramid goes out the window.

11. You will have at least one stress induced breakdown a semester.

12. Most lecture classes will bore you to tears.

13. You will not like all of your professors.

14. You will try to go to the gym... but you will get too lazy at some point.

15. When you see high school students taking tours:

16. You will try to convince yourself that you can handle everything.

17. Finals week will try to kill you.

18. You won't like everyone, but you will find your best friends sooner or later.

19. You actually have to go to class.

20. Enjoy it, because you will be sad when it is all over.

Obsessive Thoughts Keep My Brain Stuck On A Loop And Me Stuck On My Couch
Photo by Annie Spratt on Unsplash

Sometimes my brain just starts turning on an idea and it doesn't want to stop.

I don't know if it is related to my anxiety, perfectionism or depression. I don't know why it happens. It's frustrating, it's painful and it stops me from functioning.

Keep Reading...Show less
girl with a hat

This is for the girls who have dealt with an emotionally, mentally, physically or verbally abusive father.

The ones who have grown up with a false lens of what love is and how relationships should be. The ones who have cried themselves to sleep wondering why he hurts you and your family so much. This is for all the girls who fall in love with broken boys that carry baggage bigger than their own, thinking it's their job to heal them because you watched your mother do the same.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments