Has The One-And-Done Rule Hurt The Game Of Basketball? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Sports

Has The One-And-Done Rule Hurt The Game Of Basketball?

Is allowing freshmen to leave after one year a good idea?

304
Has The One-And-Done Rule Hurt The Game Of Basketball?
Instagram

What do Derrick Rose, Kevin Durant, Anthony Davis, Andrew Wiggins and Ben Simmons all have in common? They have all benefited from the one-and-done rule that is in place on the collegiate level of basketball. This rule has allowed basketball players to forgo the reminder of their college career to declare for the NBA draft. Has this rule hurt college basketball or has it made the sport stronger?

The question here is not about how their lives have been impacted by this rule, but rather how has the collegiate and professional aspect of basketball been impacted? There have been negative side affects of this rule, primarily on the collegiate side. There have also been positives to this rule which I primarily see in the NBA. First, we will look at the impact on college basketball.

College basketball has been impacted the most by this rule in my opinion. For those of you who remember the 2010 Duke Blue Devils who won the NCAA championship, they were filled with great seniors. The upperclassmen led the Blue Devils to a win over Butler. Back in 2015, Duke won the championship again but were led by three freshmen who were central to this team's success. I bring this up because these freshmen declared for the draft a few weeks after the title game. So, Coach K had to adapt and make sure his team would have success in the following seasons. Instead of having players to groom and help them grow their abilities like the 2010 Blue Devils. We have seen a steady trend of coaches cycling through freshmen phenoms, year after year.

At this rate, college is starting to become irrelevant for these athletes because they know after one year their careers are over. I was surprised to see Coach K go down this route, but then again, he had to adapt because of one coach's strategy, Coach John Calipari.

Coach Calipari, in my opinion, started a trend in college basketball. This is not to say that his teams were the first to have one-and-done players. With Derrick Rose and the 2008 NBA Draft truly starting the trend, we saw more freshmen declare for the draft than ever before.

Since the 2006 draft, when the one-and-done rule was enacted, we have seen 660 players drafted and 110 of those drafted were freshmen. Now, I know some of you are saying, "What's the big deal? That's only 6%." While that percentage is low you have to factor in that the majority of these freshmen have been first round draftees and have dominated lottery picks for the better part of a decade. This is good for the NBA because they continuously have young talent in the league. But, I don't want to go into the NBA just yet.

College basketball's royalty have a steady class of freshmen stars that will eventually leave after one year. The schools I am talking about is Kansas, Kentucky, Duke, UCLA, Arizona and Ohio State. These teams have constantly replaced players after their freshman year and I do not see a stop in the near future of this formula. Since Duke recently got Zion Williamson to commit, they now have the top 3 recruits for the upcoming freshman class. Duke already has a freshman superstar in Malcolm Bagley III is a presumed to declare, so we will see the cycling system happen. There seems to no longer be an emphasis on developing these athletes, but rather just the idea that we need to ship them off for the next batch. I believe this has hurt college basketball to a degree, but it also benefits these young athletes by letting them get minutes on the court. Now onto how this rule impacts the NBA.

I said this already, but the NBA gets young talent every year and that keeps things exciting for the fans. I don't think the NBA will change this rule in the way people want them to. I personally don't think forcing these athletes to stay another year in college will benefit the game. If you are ready and prepared for the NBA, then go ahead and declare. I know a lot of the freshmen that do declare want to help out their family in financial ways, so waiting another year may prove dangerous. I don't see many negatives that the rule has the NBA. There are some where the player should have stayed longer in college and could have matured his abilities, but there is no reason to put the blame on the one-and-done.

To conclude, having the one-and-done rule in place has been a blessing and a curse to collegiate and professional basketball. While my stance on this subject is somewhere in between. There is no change in sight for this rule. NBA Commissioner Adam Silver has talked about going over the rule and seeing if a new approach would be better. I don't want to see the NBA dictate the players' decision more than they already do, but I hate to see college basketball suffer this effect of cycling through 19 and 20 years old. I don't have a solution, but maybe one will surface sooner than later.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

Library Struggles Every College Student Will Understand

Are you really a college student if you don't stay up all night studying in your pajamas?

105
sleeping in the library
Daily Fun Lists

One of the most dreaded places on campus is the library. Nothing awesome ever happens here. Usually, the only reason you're here is because you've procrastinated so long that the library is the only place you'll actually get stuff done. It gives you this feeling of sadness and impending doom. You have no idea how this is going to go or how long you'll be here, but you do know it is about to be the most excruciating experiences yet. But it has to get done, so you drag yourself to the lovely library.

Keep Reading...Show less
Illistrated image of colorful balloons and fireworks
StableDiffusion

With each new year comes new goals.

Deciding on a goal can be hard, unsure of what to change for this new year. A new goal for myself is to be happier and take care of myself more. I am a very driven person; so driven that I commit to a million and ten things.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

Pros And Cons Of Having A Birthday Near The Holidays

The truth of what it is like having a birthday around the holiday season.

3568
Christmas decoration
Flickr

It's the most wonderful time of the year!! But for some people, including myself and my Dad, it can have its ups and downs when it comes to having a birthday near and around the holiday season. I personally share a birthday with my Dad two days before Christmas. Yes, Christmas Eve Eve is our birthday. Here are a few pros and cons for having a birthday near the holidays.

Keep Reading...Show less
Christmas Tree Lights
Pixabay

It is that time of year again. Christmastime. It is one of my favorite seasons for a myriad of reasons. Here are just a few reasons why I love Christmas. This list is in no order of importance.

1. The Christmas decorations

I am that person who will decorate directly after Thanksgiving is over. This year, my roommates and I put the tree up in our apartment before we even left for Thanksgiving break. It is a great stress reliever for me to just sit in my living room and work on the huge amount of work I have before the semester is over.

Keep Reading...Show less
girl with santa hat
Photo by Toa Heftiba on Unsplash

'Tis the season to be jolly folks, and if you're anything like me, then at the stroke of midnight on Halloween your home went from wicked to winter

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments