O Say Can You See: A New Cultural Dilemma | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

O Say Can You See: A New Cultural Dilemma

The land of the free, because of the brave.

8
O Say Can You See: A New Cultural Dilemma
Perform Group

"O say does that star-spangled banner yet wave
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave?"

Those are the final words of our national anthem, the Star Spangled Banner, written by Francis Scott Key while imprisoned on a ship during the Battle of Baltimore in the War of 1812. Pretty courageous stuff by a near nobody. But that's not what's in the news today. That's not what's making the headlines.

Instead, famous athletes across multiple platforms are making a stand by refusing to stand for the anthem prior to the start of their respective events. The first to do so was San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick, who sat down during the anthem because of what he sees as social injustice. Specifically, Kaepernick states that he will not stand and celebrate a country that in his words, "oppresses black people and people of color." Although following the initial protest, the QB was seen wearing a shirt that celebration Cuban dictator Fidel Castro. So much for being against oppression. His actions caused a national discussion and many heated debates that involved political figures, law enforcement and sports personalities across the country.

The floundering QB is not alone, however. Since initially protesting, he has been joined by teammate Eric Reid, Seattle Seahawks CB Jeremy Lane, Megan Rapinoe of the Seattle Reign, and most recently Brandon Marshall of the Denver Broncos.

Are they right in doing so? I'll explore that in a few minutes.

Rapinoe admitted that her action was a "nod to Kaepernick and everything that he's standing for right now." Though her choice was met with resistance by another women's soccer club, the Washington Spirit. They decided to play the anthem before teams took the field in order to avoid future conflict. Their reasoning was based on that fact that they did not want to "subject our fans and friends to the disrespect we feel such an act would represent." Further, they believed that allowing others "to hijack this tradition that means so much to millions of Americans and so many of our own fans for any cause would effectively be just as disrespectful as doing it ourselves."

Marshall's stance on Thursday night was met with immediate press and reaction, since it was clear that the NBC television crew was on the lookout for such protests and therefore focused their attention on the entire sideline during the anthem. Marshall has since lost his sponsorship with the Air Academy Federal Credit Union.


Though Marshall explained his action more than the others did. Following the game he said, “I’m not against the military, police or America. I’m against social injustice. I think the more people do it, the more it’s seen — there’s going to be hate mail, hate comments, but at the same time, people will talk about it."

That's really the crux of the matter. It isn't a conservative/liberal issue or a race issue per say. It could be, but it's mostly about free expression, agenda setting, and anterior motives.

Colin Kaepernick has every right to do what he pleases regarding free speech and protest. As does Rapinoe, Marshall, Lane, Reid, and ultimately every citizen of the United States. It is a right that our soldiers, sailors, marines, and airmen fight for every day. It is a right held close to all Americans, regardless of demographic.

Those who sit or kneel for the anthem wish to protest what they see as oppression by police against minorities. That is their worldview and their subsequent right. However, there is also agendas to be set and personal motives at hand. For example, Kaepernick probably knew that sitting for the anthem would cause a national debate; so what better way to set a national debate than to create one? His mission is accomplished because a) we are now discussing the issue, and b) other athletes are following suit.

Sitting for the anthem is bold, blunt, and considering the backlash, pretty brave because it's noticeable in large sporting and entertainment events. But the anthem doesn't represent the U.S. Government, it represents the American people. It represents those who died for our freedoms. It represents the values to which our nation was founded, free expression being one of them.

But the question does remain, to stand or not to stand?

That is ultimately up to them. It is their right as Americans to speak, act, and behave freely about what they believe as long as it's not violent. In fact, non-violent protest have brought out the most social change in our country's history.

However, these individuals that protest should realize that their right to sit during the anthem was fought for by people who died protecting that flag they refuse to celebrate. Likewise, the veterans who died for the flag died to protect the right of free speech. So in essence, it is a double-edged sword.

In conclusion, the choice and opinion is ours to decide.

We must value everyone's rights while keeping in mind those who fought to protect them.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

11 College Misconceptions Every Incoming Freshman Needs To Know

Think of everything that you've heard about college... and completely forget it.

2547
Helen Horton and friends
Helen Horton

College is a crazy, beautiful, amazing whirlwind. It is highly popularized in television and movies, but not necessarily in the most accurate way. Yes, there's frats, dingy dorms, raging house parties—but there's also a lot that people fail to mention.

1. If you thought that you knew how to study, you're wrong.

All of your classes aren't taught every day, so professors aren't on your case constantly about reading and memorizing material. Once you get back that "questionable" first exam grade, you'll kick it into high gear and figure out what works for you

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

18 Things Your Mom Does

Moms: the only reason voicemail still exists.

1809
woman in black turtleneck shirt smiling beside woman in black shirt

Your mom: you can't live with her, but you can't live without her. You love your mom, but she is insanely predictable. Here is a list of things your mom has probably done.

Keep Reading...Show less
Girl With Bleached Hair
Tumblr

I've been a bleach blonde for over a year now, and let me tell you, it is a lifestyle. More hair appointments, longer showers, and special shampoo. But it is totally worth it!

1. Mentally preparing yourself to convince your hair dresser that white is the way to go.

2. Or the anxiety of what could go wrong by bleaching your hair at home.

3. You could either become a ginger

4. Or a pixie

5. The face you make in the mirror when you take off your towel to unveil the perfect white strands.

6. Taking a million selfies the day you bleached it, because you know your roots will be back in literally 2 days.

7. Having to get bangs or a big chop because your hair is so damaged.

8. Having orange highlights in between touch-ups.

9. Going out for a drink afterwards to debut your updated look.

Despite the struggles, you love your platinum blonde hair! You make sure Instagram knows it, too. You don't need a filter, because the color is flawless by itself!

Entertainment

10 Things About Finals Week

As told by "Parks and Recreation" GIFs.

315
Parks and Recreation
The Playlist

Finals: just thinking about them gives you anxiety. Only two weeks separate you from summer, but they're the longest of the semester. There's a familiarity to this season, now that you have had so many testing cycles under your belt. But that doesn't quell the ever present stress to pass your finals and your classes. Even better, as a package deal during these wonderful weeks, you get to wake up early to study and you get to take exams that can begin anytime from 7 A.M. to 7 P.M. Now that we have established that this week is not fun, here are some super relatable moments that punctuate finals week.

Keep Reading...Show less
girl partying
HeyMIkeyATL

I've been at this college thing for almost three and a half years, and while I thought that high school was truly the lowest point of my existence, I'm beginning to realize that it was a walk in the park. Like, I miss the days when the biggest white lie I told my parents was my made up excuse about being late for fourth period. These days, the white lies are a tad more complex, and as ashamed as I am to admit it, I've definitely told a few of these.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments