The de Young Museum and the Failings of the White Cube for the Display of African Art | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

The de Young Museum and the Failings of the White Cube for the Display of African Art

The regressive display of non-Western art in a Western art institution

116
The de Young Museum and the Failings of the White Cube for the Display of African Art
Saeli Eshelman

This past week I visited the African art gallery in the de Young Museum with my West African Visual Cultures class in order to see the art we have been studying in person. Unfortunately, this gallery is currently without a curator, leaving important works' labels inconsistent, sparse, and inaccurate.

Even the items displayed in this gallery are inconsistent, as only art from the continent of Africa is in this wing, with African-inspired pieces by Western artists more prominently featured elsewhere, removing important context, especially from African masks which hugely inspired modern European and American artists in the 1900s.

And more contemporary African artists are excluded from the gallery, too, apparently considered inauthentic due to their "nontraditional" style. The more Western understanding of the individual as a source of artistic genius and expression also explains the decision to keep these works out of the African gallery, where personal contribution was downplayed in favor of societal context (in other words, regional and ethnic types).

Our group viewed these arts with the guidance of a museum docent who tried his best to bridge some of the historical and cultural gaps left by the information provided. While this improved the understanding of the art on display it served more to highlight the shortcomings of the gallery itself--he provided videos of masquerades being performed, but the only masquerade pieces on display were the masks themselves, without their necessarily paired costume or any visuals of the dances performed.


Despite these attempts at crafting a holistic framework, he conveniently avoided the history of colonialism and its effect on African people and their artistic outputs while still managing to discuss European trade for bead- and cloth-work. And he generalized some important societal and religious stories with specific symbolic meaning; these generalizations reframed the dialogue in terms of awe for general artistic conventions rather than understanding the particular.

But what was most concerning was the need to divide art by type even within the gallery, while simultaneously failing to describe pieces with enough accuracy to understand why they would be categorized as such. The best example of this practice was the existence of a separate glass case which was labeled as holding "Useful Objects."

Such separation of art and utilitarian objects is limiting when discussing non-Western art that is not created with the intention of being hung on a wall in the White Cube.

The aforementioned masquerades are one such case, as they are both an artistic endeavor of dance and fashion, and a ceremony imbued with economic, social, and religious function.

In all, the collection of art pieces on display at the de Young is impressive and varied, but the way it is presented leaves much to be desired, failing to communicate a nuanced understanding of the works to a less-informed audience.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Bob's Burgers
Adult Swim

Bob's Burgers is arguably one of the best and most well-written shows on tv today. That, and it's just plain hilarious. From Louise's crazy antics to Tina's deadpan self-confidence, whether they are planning ways to take over school or craft better burgers, the Belchers know how to have fun. They may not be anywhere close to organized or put together, but they do offer up some wise words once and awhile.

Keep Reading...Show less
student sleep
Huffington Post

I think the hardest thing about going away to college is figuring out how to become an adult. Leaving a household where your parents took care of literally everything (thanks, Mom!) and suddenly becoming your own boss is overwhelming. I feel like I'm doing a pretty good job of being a grown-up, but once in awhile I do something that really makes me feel like I'm #adulting. Twenty-somethings know what I'm talking about.

Keep Reading...Show less
school
blogspot

I went to a small high school, like 120-people-in-my-graduating-class small. It definitely had some good and some bad, and if you also went to a small high school, I’m sure you’ll relate to the things that I went through.

1. If something happens, everyone knows about it

Who hooked up with whom at the party? Yeah, heard about that an hour after it happened. You failed a test? Sorry, saw on Twitter last period. Facebook fight or, God forbid, real fight? It was on half the class’ Snapchat story half an hour ago. No matter what you do, someone will know about it.

Keep Reading...Show less
Chandler Bing

I'm assuming that we've all heard of the hit 90's TV series, Friends, right? Who hasn't? Admittedly, I had pretty low expectations when I first started binge watching the show on Netflix, but I quickly became addicted.

Without a doubt, Chandler Bing is the most relatable character, and there isn't an episode where I don't find myself thinking, Yup, Iam definitely the Chandler of my friend group.

Keep Reading...Show less
eye roll

Working with the public can be a job, in and of itself. Some people are just plain rude for no reason. But regardless of how your day is going, always having to be in the best of moods, or at least act like it... right?

1. When a customer wants to return a product, hands you the receipt, where is printed "ALL SALES ARE FINAL" in all caps.

2. Just because you might be having a bad day, and you're in a crappy mood, doesn't make it okay for you to yell at me or be rude to me. I'm a person with feelings, just like you.

3. People refusing to be put on hold when a customer is standing right in front of you. Oh, how I wish I could just hang up on you!

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments