I did what I always do at student events with food: I filled my plate with edible objects, I found my way to a chair, crossed my legs, put on an unamused face, and waited for my friends to migrate over to me. It was a Wednesday, and I hadn’t seen some of the people there since the previous weekend. We had a lot to catch up on!
What the topic of the discussion was, I will never know, but I eventually turned to one of my friends and asked, “I’m too liberal for my own good, aren’t I?” She smiled and said that the issue wasn’t that I was too liberal, but it was more about my vocalization of my views in the wrong environments.
Since I’ve been raised to believe that the best environments to speak your mind are the ones where most of the people don’t agree with you, I don’t necessarily think that the house of an Orthodox Rabbi is an inappropriate place to speak my mind. It’s probably the best venue!
I turned to my friend then and asked, “Would you like to hear a story about my favorite communist?” I should have known this question would elicit some laughter from my friends. As a Russian major, I definitely have some interests (and some modes of viewing the world) that may not be shared with members of the public-at-large. What I was going to tell my friend, if the response was sans-laughter, was that one of my favorite communists, Rosa Luxemburg, was murdered for being too vocal about her leftist political beliefs. But she had faith in the masses, and she was sure that speaking out would do more good than harm. Because this specific individual is one of my best friends, she eventually allowed me (much to her chagrin) to proceed with the story.
Now, I realize most people don’t have a “favorite communist,” but I’m still perplexed at what a taboo topic any type of admiration or support for communist ideology is. People shy away from the word and rarely want to engage in conversations about its implementation.
I think that in America, Communism has become a value term: it’s simply associated with bad ethics, morality, government, and modes of living. People envision gray sidewalks, gray buildings, and gray skies. Just the other day, I was doing my impression of Margaret Thatcher, the world’s most famous capitalist. I was quoting her speech on a free economy being the basis of a functioning society. Someone overheard me and said, “She was right.” I got angry and said, "Communism and socialism don’t seek to squash culture.” The individual responded, “It did in the Soviet Union.” To my historical knowledge (and my historical imagination), his response is not wholly accurate. Yes, many horrible things happened in the Soviet Union, but art did not cease to be produced, books did not cease to be written. Sure there was censorship, and I am not advocating in favor of the Soviet Union’s practices, but to use the Soviet Union -- a state that no longer exists -- as the be-all representative of Communism, which I consider to be a philosophy, is very tricky.
In America, we’ve been trained to “value” Capitalism as good, and “value” Communism as bad. But there’s a new step that’s being taken: many Americans assume that it is only through capitalism that a society can function, and that a people can produce culture. I would like to ask them about what the human race was doing in the thousands of years before capitalism emerged? Do we not have castles from the feudalist period of European history? Do we not have pyramids from a caste society in Ancient Egypt? And lastly, do we not have the Palace of Arts and Sciences in Warsaw from the Communist period? By assuming that Communism automatically means “destroyed culture” would be a slap in the face to all those who tried to make it work, and to all those who envisioned a society where people were given a tabula rasa -- free from constraints of hierarchy, family power, and class.




















