Saying You 'Believe' In Science Is Counterproductive | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Student Life

Saying You 'Believe' In Science Is Counterproductive

When science is framed as a "belief," it gives merit to those who trust in pseudoscience

178
Saying You 'Believe' In Science Is Counterproductive
Sci News

Between creationism, anti-vaxxers, and Flat Earth conspiracy theorists (yes, there are people who still think the Earth is flat), people often feel the need to say that they believe in science.

Stop.

Seriously, stop.

Belief implies a question. If you believe in science, it gives people the option to not believe in it. Think of almost every other usage of belief.

Children believe in Santa. You might believe that one day you will have your dream job and be fabulously rich. Voters who support a particular candidate do so because they believe their candidate will do good for them. In all these cases, the belief signifies that most people do not believe it. And there is a certain chance that you might be wrong, not just a sliver of a possibility. And by sliver, I mean nothing in the world can be certain. I might secretly be an alien trying to infiltrate the Earth one article at a time. But that's highly improbable. You can probably say that you know I am a human being, not that you believe I am a human being (unless you're really into conspiracy theories).

There's one other large category where belief is the right word and used extensively: religion.

We often use the word "believe" for religion. Or if you are agnostic or atheist, you usually say you "don't believe" or don't know what to believe. There is a choice. There's no absolutely incontrovertible proof that one belief or lack thereof is factual.

So back to science. It might seem a good idea to boast about how progressive and smart you are because you "believe in science", but that's still implying a belief rather than something you can be sure of. If someone asks you what your name is, you would simply state your name, not "I believe my name is..." Because you know what your name is. There's no question in your mind what it is. Other than another conspiracy in which everyone has been lying to you about your name for your entire life.

Belief does have a place in science. For example, one can believe that the entire universe is a projection, or one can chose not to believe. it.

At this point in time, the evidence may be growing according to some scientists, but it's far from hard proof. But when it comes to the normal things I often here people saying they "believe" in, it's not a question of belief. It's a fact. Your child absolutely should get vaccinated. The only evidence "against" it was more or less admitted to be fabricated and it has been proven quite thoroughly by the fact that it has in fact eradicated many old diseases. If you say you "believe" in vaccinating your child, that implies that others might not "believe" in doing so for their child. Instead, it's something you know to be good for your child. Whether or not it can be considered a "moral duty", that is something you can or cannot chose to believe in. But believing in vaccinating your child? There should be no such thing. It should just be something everyone knows you should do, like how everyone knows you should wash your hands regularly. Just common accepted fact, not a belief.

Evolution is another such fact which has ample proof, in this case from many different fields of science. There's literally no reason it should be a question of "belief". If someone asked me if I believed in Creationism, that's an easy no. If they ask me if I "believe" in evolution, I would just give them a look, questioning what exactly is there to believe. It's just as true as distance being equivalent to velocity times time. It just...is. No need for belief to get you those last few steps.

Generally, the people using the word "belief" and science together tend to be people who have no problem with science, but feel the need to point out that they are smart because they believe in science. Slightly better is when people are trying to use it to correct the misconception that major religions believe in creationism or other such b.s, such as saying, "The Catholic Church believes in the Big Bang Theory" (understatement seeing as the Pope was really, really  excited when that first came out). In this second context, it makes sense since the alternative is in fact a fallacious belief. It also somewhat makes sense if you consider religion to be its occasional opposite, as religion itself is a belief, although almost a fourth of creationists have never or rarely attended church, so if it is their religious convictions, you would think those convictions would also make them go to Church more often. Really, none of these incorrect beliefs are really that religious, which is partially why I have no problem attacking them.

Well, that, and mountains and mountains of evidence in favor of the science. There are somethings in science that do require belief. There are the things we then test thoroughly. Things we have already tested thoroughly? Not so much. So if you truly support science, stop saying you "believe" in it. You wouldn't say that about it's equivalent in any other subject. You wouldn't say you "believe" Washington was the first American president because you "believe" in history. You treat that as a fact that doesn't have other legitimate alternatives. If you do in fact support good science, stop giving merit to fallacious ideas by treating the scientific truth as just something you "believe".

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
legally blonde

College is filled with many things, and we're so often lectured to make the right decisions as we head out on our own into the college life. But sometimes it's necessary to indulge in some guilty pleasures as well as just doing things because you can. And honestly, a lot of the time it's inevitable. College is no piece of cake that's for sure, so it's okay to do some things you deep down know you shouldn't....once in a while anyways.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

10 Things to avoid your freshman year of college

Having this list as you enter college will be extremely valuable and beneficial to experiencing the best year of your life!

1563
girl friends
Madison Morgan

Ahhh good ol' freshman year. The best times and the worst times. Going to college six hours from home was the best decision I had ever made for myself, but the transition would have been much smoother had I known the things I know now. You cannot take on this beast by yourself, so allow me to lend a hand and guide you through one of the most exciting and different years of your life thus far. I have compiled a list of 10 key things to avoid your freshman year of college in order to ensure a smooth, happy, and fun first year!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

13 Thoughts Everyone Has During Lecture

Chances are, they have nothing to do with what you're actually supposed to be learning.

130
student in class
Polish Magazine

Let's face it. We've all had those days when it's almost impossible to stay awake or focus during lecture. We often find ourselves dozing off or just staring out into space when we really should be paying attention to what's going on in class. Regardless of whether or not you admit this happens, here are 13 thoughts every student has during lecture:

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

A Deep Dive Into Taylor Swift’s Albums: 1989 (Taylor’s Version) Edition

I just know that the idea of releasing vault tracks came out of the moment Taylor remembered she wrote 'Is It Over Now?'

225
A Deep Dive Into Taylor Swift’s Albums: 1989 (Taylor’s Version) Edition
Edited by Hailey Hastings

I am fully emersed into diving deep into every single Taylor Swift album, which I do on my own all the time, but wanted to do it in a way where I am sharing what a special discography she has. I feel like 1989 is the perfect place to start, it's an era that changed everything, and will always be an album people automatically think of when you say "Taylor Swift."

Keep Reading...Show less
friends

Here you will find a list of many of the people you will come across in your life, and if you're lucky, you'll be able to give a name to all these characters that you hopefully see day to day. Don't take these friends for granted because they all add a little something to your life, and if you can't name all of them to your personal friends, chances are it might be you...

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments