A Response To The Ban On 'Looking For Alaska' | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

A Response To The Ban On 'Looking For Alaska'

Banning this book will not fix the real problem.

2547
A Response To The Ban On 'Looking For Alaska'
Teepublic

Recently, the American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom released its list of the top ten most challenged books in 2015. Author John Green's first novel, "Looking For Alaska", was number one on the list, ranking higher than "Fifty Shades Of Grey". While I understand the intent behind banning books from places like school libraries (the desire to protect kids from bad influences), I disagree with the ban on "Looking For Alaska".

Yes, the book contains teen drinking, smoking, sexual content and language, but let's face reality for a moment. Whether right or wrong, these things happen, especially in today's culture, regardless of if a book containing them sits on the shelf in a school library or not. Furthermore, in "Looking For Alaska", these elements serve to give context to the characters and their life situations but are not the main focus of the book.

Additionally, according to a response statement issued by John Green, the scene mentioned in one challenge calling for a ban was completely taken out of context. Green acknowledges that there is a scene containing explicit details of an emotionless oral sex encounter. However, he points out that in the next scene, there is a much more passionate encounter containing simply kissing and no sexual content at all. He concludes by saying, "So in context, the novel is arguing, really in a rather pointed way, that emotionally intimate kissing can be a whole lot more fulfilling than emotionally empty oral sex." Basically, the bigger picture sends the opposite message of what people banned the book for. If I were a parent, the message Green intends through these scenes is exactly what I would want my children to read.

Still, the book is not about sex, drinking, smoking, or swearing. It's about depression, suicide, friendship, forgiveness and, ultimately, hope. It's about, as the characters would say, learning how to navigate and survive the labyrinth of suffering that is life, something we all must do. Instead of turning to suicide (rates are on the rise in young people), which is often romanticized in our culture, "Looking For Alaska"serves as a reminder that life will go on. How? Through forgiveness. As people, we must forgive each other, and we must forgive ourselves. As the characters Pudge and the Colonel discover, we are still alive. In fact, Green concludes the book with Pudge saying "we need never be hopeless, because we can never be irreparably broken. We think we are invincible because we are."

Banning "Looking For Alaska" will not solve the problem of keeping bad influences out of schools because it is not a bad influence. Rather, it teaches that every person has a purpose, a "great perhaps", as Pudge would say. It teaches that life is a beautiful thing, struggles and all. As the Colonel says, "After all this time, it still seems to me like straight and fast is the only way out- but I choose the labyrinth."

"Looking For Alaska" doesn't encourage kids to have sex and drink. It encourages them to live.

So, before condemning this book for a few minor offenses, please consider the bigger picture. As Green says, "If you have a worldview that can be undone by a novel, let me submit that the problem is not with the novel."

You can find John Green's full response here.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Christmas Tree
History.com

Now that Halloween is over, it's time to focus on the Holiday Season. Don't get me wrong, I think Thanksgiving is great and can't wait for it, but nothing gives me greater joy than watching Freeform's 25 Days of Christmas, lighting peppermint scented candles, decking the halls, and baking gingerbread cookies. So while we approach the greatest time of the year, let's watch the 15 best Christmas movies of all time.

Keep Reading...Show less
6 Signs You Are An English Major

There are various stereotypes about college students, most of which revolve around the concept of your major. Unfortunately, we often let stereotypes precede our own judgments, and we take what information is immediately available to us rather than forming our own opinions after considerable reflection. If I got a dollar for every time my friends have made a joke about my major I could pay my tuition. One stereotype on campus is the sensitive, overly critical and rigid English major. Here are six telltale signs you are one of them.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

27 Things 'The Office' Has Taught Us

"The Office" is a mockumentary based on everyday office life featuring love triangles, silly pranks and everything in between. It can get pretty crazy for just an average day at the office.

2627
the office
http://www.ssninsider.com/

When you were little, your parents probably told you television makes your brain rot so you wouldn't watch it for twelve straight hours. However, I feel we can learn some pretty valuable stuff from television shows. "The Office," while a comedy, has some pretty teachable moments thrown in there. You may not know how to react in a situation where a co-worker does something crazy (like put your office supplies in jello) but thanks to "The Office," now you'll have an idea how to behave ifsomething like that should happen.

Here are just a few of the things that religious Office watchers can expect to learn.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

10 Signs You’re A Pre-Med Student

Ah, pre-med: home of the dead at heart.

1611
Grey's Anatomy
TV Guide

Being pre-med is quite a journey. It’s not easy juggling school work, extracurricular activities, volunteering, shadowing, research, and MCAT prep all at the same time. Ever heard of “pain is temporary, but GPA is forever?” Pre-meds don’t just embody that motto; we live and breathe it. Here are 10 symptoms you’re down with the pre-med student syndrome.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

Books were always about understanding for me, about learning the way someone else sees, about connection.

1195
High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

I keep making this joke whenever the idea of books is brought up: "God, I wish I knew how to read." It runs parallel to another stupid phrase, as I watch my friends struggle through their calculus classes late at night in our floor lounge: "I hope this is the year that I learn to count." They're both truly idiotic expressions, but, when I consider the former, I sometimes wonder if there's some truth to it.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments