A Response To Time Magazine's Critique On "Love, Simon" | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

A Response To Time Magazine's Critique On "Love, Simon"

I don't even know where to begin

367
A Response To Time Magazine's Critique On "Love, Simon"
Pexels

“Love, Simon”, released on March 16th, shows a plot-line that follows a high school boy in the closet. Falling for a classmate online, Simon has no idea of this anonymous person’s identity. It is a light-hearted film intended to show gay characters in a positive, normative light.

On March 8th, an article appeared in Time Magazine entitled “Love, Simon Is A Groundbreaking Movie. But Do Today’s Teens Actually Need It?”.

The author, listing the apparent abundance of LGBT films saturating the industry such as “Moonlight”, “Blue Is the Warmest Color” and “Call Me By Your Name”, basically is saying that there are already enough of these films in Hollywood. He explains that the industry has already “made stirring and provocative art out of growing up - both what it’s like to discover your sexuality and how to reconcile it with the rest of yourself”. He criticizes the film for its possible inability to appeal to today’s adults, as compared to popular TV shows it lacks an edgy, dark quality.

By saying an LGBT film cannot be successful without having some deeper meaning, by displaying these characters in a light different than those of straight characters in typical romantic comedies, the author unknowingly proves that yes, we do need this movie.

Straight plot lines saturate the media without us even thinking about it. In today’s world, straight is the norm. There are straight characters in basically every film out there, even LGBT ones. Just the other day, I watched the hilarious classic "Wedding Crashers", yet another enjoyable film following the storylines of two straight couples. With these types of movie's success, we see plenty of tender rom-coms featuring a guy and a girl as main protagonists. The Time article author criticizes "Love, Simon" for being almost so mainstream and YA it hurts, but it is like that for a reason.

I remember growing up, unsure of my identity, trying to find characters like me on screen. I remember thinking that these romantic, idealized storylines just wouldn’t happen for me if I chose to be with a girl.

Does that concern make much sense? Probably not. Yet, I am not the only one who grew up thinking this, because as teens our view of the world is so highly shaped by the media we are consuming. The closest thing I had seen to a mainstream lesbian movie growing up was “Blue Is the Warmest Color”, a film about a girl falling for her art teacher.

Not only did actress Léa Seydoux describe scenes in the movie as “psychologically humiliating” to film, but it was also nothing remotely close to the light-hearted positivity of “Love, Simon”. This is a teacher/student love story, already set up to show lesbians in a scandalous light, a light that gay characters are so often limited to.

The author of this article writes that “kids like Simon, in 2018, already have a good shot of fitting in. They don’t need this movie”. It should not be hard to see how irrelevant and downright untrue this statement is. For one, straight kids have a pretty good shot of fitting in as well. However, how many films do they get to see in which other straight couples are the focus? How many films, strictly about romance plots and mainstream teen life, do they get to see themselves in? Why can’t gay teens get the privilege of seeing the same?

Also, the idea that homophobia has ended is the same as saying that sexism is dead just because women have the right to vote or work. Undoubtedly, today’s gay teens are coming out to a less judgemental world than their parents and grandparents. That does not mean they are coming out to one free of hate. Statistically, 9 out of every 10 LGBT teens have reported being bullied at school. These teens face hateful peers, as well as possibly unaccepting families, and not to mention the internal homophobia that often many feel without realizing it. These teens may have a better chance at fitting in than ever before, but the odds are certainly not in their favor.

So yes, Time, we are seeing more gay characters on screen. The need for this movie, however, lays not only in its inclusion of a gay teen but in a storyline that follows him without scandal, without a storyline that ends in tragedy. This film shows today's kids, who may be struggling to come to terms with their own sexuality, that despite what the media shows you do get a story. You do not need to be forced into the background. Your life, your love, can be just as romantically cheesy and mainstream as any other straight kid.

I may not speak for the LGBT community as a whole, but I do know that growing up, I sure needed this movie. I am sure there will be kids searching for someone like them on screen, just as I was, and I am glad they will be able to find this film.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Disney Princesses
The Odyssey
Tiana would no doubt be disappointed in the food our cafeteria has to offer.

And hopefully she would cook for everyone in her dorm.

She definitley would not take any 8:00 am classes because she would be up late baking and cleaning up the communal kitchen that are available in every dorm.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

The Struggles of Being A Last Semester Senior, As Told By Michael Scott

25 reasons your last semester in college is the best and worst time of your life

1128
Michael Scott

The day you walked onto your school's campus for the first time you were scared, excited, and unsure of how the next four years of your life were going to turn out. You doubted it would go fast and even though you weren't positive about what your future plans would hold, you had plenty of time. You figured out your major, added a minor or two, joined a handful of organizations and all of the sudden you're here. Your final semester of undergrad. Now you've got 25 problems and graduation is only one.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Syllabus Week At UD Explained By "The Office"

"The Office" understands the struggle of the first week back from winter break.

957
the office

January 19th is the first day of the second semester at the University of Dayton, and students couldn't be more excited. However, the excitement that students are experiencing may be short-lived once they see what this semester's courses will entail. Although students will be happy to be back at Dayton, they may realize this semester will be more difficult than they predicted. Here are some things that happen during syllabus week explained by " The Office."

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

Your Friend Group, As Told By Disney Princesses

Each Disney Princess has their own personality, and chances are you've got a friend in your group to match it.

1375
Disney Princesses

The dynamics of any friend group are usually determined by the personalities which make it up. Chances are, while personalities may overlap, each person in your friend group holds his or her own place. It is the differences which bring the groups together and keep them functioning. No matter how functionally dysfunctional your friend group may be, if you're anything like me, you feel absolutely blessed to have found such a wonderful group of humans to call "your people." Here is what your friend group might look like if they were Disney princesses (and that wasn't just a thing you all pretended in your heads):

Keep Reading...Show less
dorm roon
Tumblr

College is a place where you spend four years exploring opportunities you never knew were there, creating the person you are, and making life-long friends. College is hard, but it is worth spending four years there. Just because college is difficult doesn't mean that it's not fun. There are plenty of great memories you can make during your four years if college. Here are ways college is designed to be the best four years of your life:

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments