The Progressive Rewriting Of Thanksgiving | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics

The Progressive Rewriting Of Thanksgiving

A response to “Thoughts on American History and Donald Trump.”

151
The Progressive Rewriting Of Thanksgiving
mukeshbalani.com

Liberals, Progressives, Leftists, whatever you call yourself, I understand you’re unhappy about Trump and conservatives in general. You have shown the observing American public your outrage. Which, by the way, is not doing much besides straining your credibility.

Let me give you an illustration; if a child is swinging a hammer and throwing firecrackers in your house, is your first instinct to talk to the child calmly and find out how it feels or is your first instinct to restrain it?

I understand that the vast majority of leftists are not vandalising property. I’d like to see other leftists, particularly celebrities, news anchors, and politicians come out and condemn these actions, but that’s another issue for another time.

The issue right here at this time is the misrepresentation of historical events to make an argument, as exemplified here.

The summary of the events of Thanksgiving given by today.com isn’t wrong. It’s very broad and simplistic, which is perfectly fine for explaining the event to children, as it’s meant to do.

To the author, I understand you’re a leftist writing to a leftist audience, so maybe your audience has a child’s understanding of Thanksgiving, but not everyone does.

Something this summary doesn’t talk about was the socialist organization of the early colonists which lead to the Starving Time in Jamestown. Was that hidden from you, as you complain about later in your article?

Regardless, the summary was set up as a falsity to be contrasted with the supposed actual event as it is described by the United American Indians of New England or UAINE.

Even then, according to UAINE’s own website, the event concerning Governor John Winthrop is not the first Thanksgiving. In fact, the first Thanksgiving described largely coincides with the children’s summary.

What you also left out was the involvement of Mohegan and Narragansett Native American tribes which helped the colonists defeat and slaughter the Pequot tribe. Something else that was hidden from you, perhaps?

Did the massacre of the Pequot tribe happen on Thanksgiving? Yes, but there is a difference between the massacre causing the celebration and the event and the celebration coincidentally happening on the same day.

With regards to your accusation about not learning about the Native Americans in South America when Columbus arrived, I actually recall learning a lot about the Aztec and Inca tribes in middle and high school. Maybe you didn’t, which is a failure on your teacher’s part.

In my humble opinion, this “America = Bad, Everyone else = Good” hysteria needs to stop. I’m not going to defend Donald Trump. There’s something you should know about history; it writes itself.

How?

Military documents, business reports, personal writings, and so on. Maybe your interpretation of the events happening around you will be excavated in the far future, but unless you're documenting something that has never been documented, you're not adding anything to history. The idea that you can write history for the next generation seems a little arrogant to me, not to mention scary (1984, much?).

Now, that doesn’t mean we can’t write how we feel about history. We as people put our own interpretations on history. We’re the ones who decide whether or not a time period or event was good or bad for humanity based upon our own moral authorities.

With that said, prove to me that socialism is what we as a people ought to strive for before you declare yourself on “the right side of history.”
Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
girl with a hat

This is for the girls who have dealt with an emotionally, mentally, physically or verbally abusive father.

The ones who have grown up with a false lens of what love is and how relationships should be. The ones who have cried themselves to sleep wondering why he hurts you and your family so much. This is for all the girls who fall in love with broken boys that carry baggage bigger than their own, thinking it's their job to heal them because you watched your mother do the same.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf Quote
"DESTINY IS FOR LOSERS. IT'S JUST A STUPID EXCUSE TO WAIT FOR THINGS TO HAPPEN INSTEAD OF MAKING THEM HAPPEN." - BLAIR WALDORF.

The world stopped in 2012 when our beloved show "Gossip Girl" ended. For six straight years, we would all tune in every Monday at 9:00 p.m. to see Upper Eastside royalty in the form of a Burberry headband clad Blair Waldorf. Blair was the big sister that we all loved to hate. How could we ever forget the epic showdowns between her and her frenemy Serena Van Der Woodsen? Or the time she banished Georgina Sparks to a Christian summer camp? How about that time when she and her girls took down Bart Bass? Blair is life. She's taught us how to dress, how to be ambitious, and most importantly, how to throw the perfect shade.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Moments Every College Freshman Has Experienced

Because we made it, and because high school seniors deserve to know what they're getting themselves into

141
too tired to care

We've all been there. From move-in day to the first finals week in college, your first term is an adventure from start to finish. In honor of college decisions coming out recently, I want to recap some of the most common experiences college freshmen experience.

1. The awkward hellos on move-in day.

You're moving your stuff onto your floor, and you will encounter people you don't know yet in the hallway. They live on your floor, so you'll awkwardly smile and maybe introduce yourself. As you walk away, you will wonder if they will ever speak to you again, but don't worry, there's a good chance that you will make some great friends on your floor!

Keep Reading...Show less
laptop
Unsplash

The college years are a time for personal growth and success. Everyone comes in with expectations about how their life is supposed to turn out and envision the future. We all freak out when things don't go exactly as planned or when our expectations are unmet. As time goes on, we realize that the uncertainty of college is what makes it great. Here are some helpful reminders about life in college.

Keep Reading...Show less
students
rowanuniversitypublications / Flickr

1. "If I'm wearing black tomorrow, it's because I'm mourning my grade."

2. "Do you want to try ordering Chinese takeout to take back to the stacks?"

3. "This final paper has me questioning if this professor just sucks or is Satan himself."

4. "Is that person over there OK? They've been sleeping for a while."

5. "Why are you online shopping?"

"I want to motivate myself to study."

"Since when do you have money to buy something anyway?"

6. "I wonder how much I could make as a stripper."

7. "There are no stress relief dogs, and I feel conned. My stress today is worse than yesterday."

8. "Rate My Professor screwed me over."

9. "I wore these clothes yesterday, and maybe even the day before, but it's fine."

10. "I wonder if I could sneak a beer in here."

11. "I just really want chocolate chip cookies."

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments