The Problem With Modern Sport Fencing | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Sports

The Problem With Modern Sport Fencing

It's basically turned into tag with sticks.

1813
The Problem With Modern Sport Fencing
Wikipedia

I encourage anyone reading this to take a brief glance at the fencing in this video:


This is a sabre bout from the 2012 Olympics. If it looks a little underwhelming, you’re not alone. I could only watch up to about the one-minute mark myself before getting bored and closing the tab. It’s the reason I used the word “brief” earlier. I wouldn’t expect anyone to watch for much longer than I did, and I don’t blame you if you didn’t.

And here’s why.

For those who may not know, modern sport fencing is divided into three forms, each of which puts to use different weapons and rules: épée, foil and sabre. The issue I’m about to discuss applies to really all three. All the blades are electric, and sensors determine when the tip (equipped with a spring-loaded button on foils and épées) or blade (in the case of sabre fencing) makes contact with an opponent. You get points by striking the opposing fencer before they strike you, and, essentially, the person with more points wins.

The equipment can detect the amount of time between the two blades’ valid touches all the way down to 1/25th of a second.

See where I’m going with this?

If the goal of modern sport fencing is to get a touch a mere 25th of a second before your opponent, then what results is two guys bum-rushing each other and rapidly trying to whack the other guy before getting whacked themselves. It doesn’t matter if you get hit—as long as it’s a split second after your opponent does. Just take a look at the above video and see for yourself. Those two are only active for about a second each time before someone gets a touch. For an Olympic-level competition, it doesn’t exactly look like there’s much skill involved.

That’s drastically different than what historical duels entailed, and from which modern sport fencing was clearly adapted, however loosely. Back then, fencers wielded rapiers which were sharp and considerably sturdier than modern weapons, and the most urgent, pressing goal while using them was to avoid getting jabbed with a pointy piece of metal at all costs. Actually stabbing your enemy was an added bonus—defense was the most important thing. It’s why 17th-century rapiers often had intricate basket hilts; your hand, which was the closest thing to your opponent’s pointy blade, needed to be protected. Compare that to the guard of a foil pictured above, which is little more than the bottom of a Dixie cup taped to a car antenna.

While the development of technology is great, getting your electronic equipment as precise as possible does have its downsides. If modern fencing takes away the referee being the sole judge of who wins and replaces them with sensors that are able to measure incredibly small increments of time, then it distances itself from its historical roots. It basically becomes glorified tag with flimsy metal sticks, and who stabs who first is left pretty much up to luck.

That’s why I appreciate Historical European Martial Arts so much (HEMA). It takes armed melee combat into the 21st century while remaining true to its original historical context. Compare this video, for example, to the one at the beginning of this article:


(watch at 0:11 for a better angle)

These guys are moving around two-dimensionally rather than in a straight line, they’re actually parrying and performing skillful, deliberate counterattacks, and, most importantly, they take their time. They don’t instantly rush each other like two 3rd graders foot-racing on the playground.

They might as well make that an Olympic sport, too.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

A Few Thoughts Every College Freshman Has

The transition into adulthood is never easy

2436
Mays Island
Courtney Jones

Today I started my third week of college at Minnesota State Moorhead. I have survived welcome week, finding my classes on the first day, and being an awkward loner in the dining hall. Even though I have yet to be here for a month, I have already experienced many thoughts and problems that only a new college student can relate to.

Keep Reading...Show less
college

"Make sure to get involved when you're in college!"

We've all heard some variation of this phrase, whether it came from parents, other family members, friends, RAs, or college-related articles. And, like many clichés, it's true for the most part. Getting involved during your college years can help you make friends, build your resume, and feel connected to your campus. However, these commitments can get stressful if you're dealing with personal issues, need to work, or aren't sure how to balance classes and everything else going on during the semester.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

9 Reasons Why Friends Are Essential In College

College without friends is like peanut butter without jelly.

1280
Bridgaline Liberati and friends
Bridgaline Liberati

In college, one of the essential things to have is friends. Yes, textbooks, a laptop, and other school supplies are important but friends are essential. Friends are that support system everybody needs. The more friends you have the better the support system you have. But you also have someone to share experiences with. And don’t settle for just one or two friends because 8 out of 10 times they are busy and you are studying all alone. Or they have other friend groups that do not include you. Don’t settle for just one or two friends; make as many friends as you can. After the first couple of weeks of college, most friend groups are set and you may be without friends.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

The Power of Dressing Up

Why it pays to leave the hoodie at home.

990
sneakers and heels
Sister | Brother Style - Word Press

For a moment your world is spinning. The phone alarm has just scared you awake and you’re flooded by daunting thoughts of the day ahead. You have three assignments due and little time to work on them because of your job. You’re running late because you’ve hit snooze one to many times after yesterday’s long hours. You dizzily reach for a hoodie, craving its comfort, and rush for a speedy exit, praying you will have time to pick up coffee. Does this sound familiar?

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

11 Signs You Live At The Library As Told by 'Parks And Recreation'

A few signs that you may live in the library whether you'd like to admit it or not.

910
brown wooden book shelves with books

Finals week is upon us. It is a magical time of year during which college students everywhere flock to the library in attempt to learn a semester's worth of knowledge in only a week. For some students, it's their first time in the library all semester, maybe ever. Others have slaved away many nights under the fluorescent lights, and are slightly annoyed to find their study space being invaded by amateurs. While these newbies wander aimlessly around the first floor, hopelessly trying to find a table, the OGs of the library are already on the third floor long tables deep into their studies. Here is a few signs that you may live in the library, whether you'd like to admit it or not.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments