Philosophical Views On Reasoning | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Student Life

Philosophical Views On Reasoning

Descartes’s Goals is to find a firm foundation for philosophical certainty and build on this foundation to justify the sciences. While Hume's Goal is to eliminate abstract ideas from the philosophy that has no relationship to experience and limit opinion to what it can explain inexperience.

53
Philosophical Views On Reasoning
Pixabay

After reading Hume's Enquiry and imagine an empiricist response to Descartes's Meditations, one can collect essential facts that prove them to be opposite in their philosophical reasonings and state the empiricist’s most persuasive argument against Descartes’s method and mention any common ground shared by the two perspectives

Epistemology is the rational way of analyzing and studying the disciplinary ideas of science, as well as their methods and their findings. It refers to empiricism which is the theory that applies to all knowledge is derived from sense-experience; rationalism, the epistemological view of actions and opinions to be based on experience and reason rather than on emotional response or religious belief.

Descartes is a rationalist. Therefore, he believes in deductive reasoning which is the reason is the best way to understand reality. Descartes also thinks that experience is uncertain which means Sense experience is unpredictable and full of error, “ therefore reasons and ideas should not come from experience. Hume is an empiricist, so he thinks every ideas and reason are a posteriori which means they must come from experiences to be certain. “If a man cannot have some sensation because there is something wrong with his senses, he will never be found to have corresponding ideas” (2). He also refers to matters of fact and relations of ideas. Relations of ideas includes math logic and intuitive or demonstrative certainty.

Descartes stated that to understand ourselves, we must understand God, “ I exist and have such an idea, I infer that God exists and that every moment of my existence depends on him” (18), while Hume stated that the ability to understand God is within our minds. “The idea of God- meaning an infinitely intelligent, wise, and good Being- comes from extending beyond all limits the qualities of goodness and wisdom that we find in our minds” (2).

According to Hume, this reason can be determined merely by thinking without the need to relate to anything else that exists in the entire universe (11). Matters of fact is related to the custom which is the habit that expects the future to be similar to the past based on historical experience. Relations of ideas is more related to something ahistorical and unchanging; “when we analyze our thoughts or ideas- however complex or elevated they are- we always find them to be made up of simple ideas that were copied from earlier feelings or sensations” (2); one instance is enough. Matters of fact is related to the custom which is the habit that expects the future to be similar to the past based on historical experience. “All the reasonings about matters of fact seem to be based on the relation of cause and effect” (12).

Hume classifies passions in the same way as ideas; he distinguishes original impressions from secondary impressions. We receive the original impressions through the senses. They are internal and take the form of pleasures or physical pains. An initial opinion or an idea always precede secondary feelings. The passions, according to Hume, belong to the field of secondary impressions. Hume also distinguishes direct emotions, such as desire, aversion, sorrow, joy, hope, and fear, from indirect passions, such as pride, humility, love, and hate. Hume then distinguishes between the cause and the object of the desires. Hume attacked the metaphysical systems that seek to prove the existence of God or the soul. Humerefused to consider them as knowledge since the man has no experience, in other words, we do not receive any impressions from them. Therefore, it is impossible to say or believe that the soul or God is pure.

First, Hume demonstrates that all our complex ideas are formed from simple ideas, themselves formed from impressions received through our senses. “However far we push this inquiry, we shall find that every thought that we examine is copied from a similar impression”; therefore, the ideas are not fundamentally different from the experience. Descartes believes that certainty does not apply to steps, experience, sensation, memory, or logic. He thinks that anything that is certain should be imperfect, limited, direct, innate and immediate. Additionally, there should not be any possibility of doubt. For example, we can certainly know that we are humans; we have goals; we have a body; everything has an end.

Descartes thinks there could be an evil genius tricking us when it comes to our thinking. “I would have added that a body cannot start up movements by itself, but now that I suppose there is a supremely powerful malicious deceiver who has set out to trick me in every way he can” (5). Reasons are ideas Hume, on the other hand, believes that ideas and reasons should come from experience. However, they are not caused by us, but in us. Descartes’s Goals is to find a firm foundation for philosophical certainty and build on this foundation to justify the sciences. While Hume's Goal is to eliminate abstract ideas from the philosophy that has no relationship to experience and limit opinion to what it can explain inexperience.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
girl

If it hurts now, it'll hurt again. Not because you're gullible or naive, only because you fall fast, hard, and you do it every time.

We fall each and every time with the complete and utter confidence that someone will be there to catch us. Now that person we SWORE we were never going to fall for has our hearts, and every time we see them our palms start sweating. The butterflies in our stomach start to soar and our hearts are entirely too close to bursting out of our chests.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

10 Things Only Equestrians Understand

Yes, it IS a sport. Yes, I fall all the time. No, I do not ride in jeans with a cowgirl hat on.

413
horses
Barn Pros

Growing up I have always wanted to own a horse. My grandparents own a well known equestrian facility in Georgia, so I have been riding since I was born. A bond between a person and their horse is a bond so strong that it cannot be broken. Everywhere I went I wanted to be around horses, even forcing my family to go on trail rides during vacations. Horses have been a part of my life for as long as I can remember has taught me great responsibility, as well as 14 things that all equestrians can relate to.

Keep Reading...Show less
man wearing white top using MacBook
Photo by Tim Gouw on Unsplash

College is super hard. Between working, studying, and having a social life, it feels like a struggle to just keep afloat.

I understand. When you feel like your drowning and there's no way to stay afloat I understand that it feels like everyone else is doing just fine. I understand all the frustration, long nights in the library, and that feeling that you want to just throw in the towel. I understand that sometimes it's too hard to get out of bed because your brain is already filled with too much information to remember. I understand because I am also feeling pretty burnt out.

Keep Reading...Show less
No Matter How Challenging School Gets, You Have To Put Your Health First — A Degree Won't Mean Anything If You're Dead
Photo by JESHOOTS.COM on Unsplash

Some of the best advice I've ever received was from my social studies teacher in sophomore year of high school. He stated, "If you don't know it at midnight, you're not going to know it for the 8 a.m. exam, so get some sleep."

It's such a simple piece of advice, but it holds so much accuracy and it's something that the majority of college students need to hear and listen to. "All-nighters" are a commonality on college campuses in order to cram in studying for an exam that is typically the next day.

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

Warnings About College To Incoming Freshmen As Told By Gifs

College is hard, but you will make it through.

617
college just ahead sign
Wordpress

1. You will have that special "college" look to you.

2. You will feel like an adult but also feeling like a child.

3. You will have classes that are just the professor reading from their lecture slides for an hour.

4. You will need to study but also want to hang out with your friends.

5. Coffee is your best friend.

6. You don't know what you're doing 99% of the time.

7. You will procrastinate and write a paper the night before it is due.

8. Money is a mythical object.

9. It is nearly impossible to motivate yourself to go to classes during spring.

10. The food pyramid goes out the window.

11. You will have at least one stress induced breakdown a semester.

12. Most lecture classes will bore you to tears.

13. You will not like all of your professors.

14. You will try to go to the gym... but you will get too lazy at some point.

15. When you see high school students taking tours:

16. You will try to convince yourself that you can handle everything.

17. Finals week will try to kill you.

18. You won't like everyone, but you will find your best friends sooner or later.

19. You actually have to go to class.

20. Enjoy it, because you will be sad when it is all over.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments