How New Abortion Bills Plan To Overthrow Roe v. Wade | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post

Alabama, Georgia And Ohio Think They Can Overthrow Roe v. Wade, But Their Success Is Unlikely

But it's not gonna happen.

12
https://www.flickr.com/photos/kneoh/14931652922/in/photolist-oKsCcL-7vzYNY-oXP3gZ-6qCxCW-7bo3eY-BNNc3-7KXtxw-9fY6o-6qCxTy-6qCxFj-6qynUe-GDRLvC-atFVp5-nUrSF9-qt883V-fZFCte-pr411g-pr42KD-pr3Zt4-4HCEEs-fKNuRK-BTiW4C-obWFCD-W2DvTX-LQuYyX-p9xZ4K-obDjyK-4RuL8D-6JrLVJ-9sMQEz-c6iqks-dsvoVH-brcLSm-a8Ty9f-26pt5Ea-qsX4Ra-okgkJD-4Rzomo-dPv9vg-r9Yu5j-Be98vk-9f7RjZ-29WWe8z-2z1yrt-CbwCaH-Be2jLb-fKNjUX-C9dNNL-oGh2Pg-oGh4zv

So a bunch of states lately have been signing bills into laws with the intention to overthrow the 1973 Supreme Court ruling of Roe. v. Wade.

Though it's specifically stated in the language of these documents, a state's ruling cannot overrule the decisions of the United States Supreme Court. So by intentionally enacting legislation that contradicts the predetermined decision of the Supreme Court, states like Alabama, Georgia, and Ohio are using their government to provoke the Supreme Court to retry the existing ruling.

On May 7th, 2019, Governor Brian Kemp signed Georgia's "heartbeat bill" which would ban abortion as soon as a fetal heartbeat could be detected. This legislation immediately became disputed since a fetal heartbeat can be detected as early as six weeks, long before many women know they're pregnant. A fetus may also be aborted if the pregnancy is determined to be "medically futile," which means the fetus has "a profound and irremediable congenital or chromosomal anomaly that is incompatible with sustaining life after birth." This law enforces criminal punishment for abortions performed outside of these qualifications.

This is a direct violation of the 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey's undue burden standard; in that it places too many provisions on what has already been determined as a fundamental right. Since the law so wildly contradicts current abortion standards, it is clear the abortion ban is part of a long-term goal to gain an audience with the Supreme Court to challenge the decision of Roe v. Wade.


On May 15th, 2019, Alabama governor Kay Ivey signed the "most extreme abortion ban since Roe v. Wade," according to Planned Parenthood. This law would permit abortions only if the mother's life is at risk or if the fetus cannot survive—with no other exceptions. This bill also holds doctors criminally responsible for performing abortions outside of these standards, at a felony charge.

Governor Ivey went as far as to publicly state her disagreement with the Roe ruling, stating that pushing the Supreme Court to reconsider the ruling was a major reason legislators pursued the law. "The sponsors of this bill believe that it is time, once again, for the U.S. Supreme Court to revisit this important matter, and they believe this act may bring about the best opportunity for this to occur," Ivey stated. The strictness of this bill without regard to the undue burden standard directly contradicts federal abortion standards, which serve to illuminate the covert intention behind the new legislation: to conceivably gain an audience with the Supreme Court and attempt to overturn the preexisting rule of Roe v. Wade.


On April 12th, 2019, Ohio Governor Mike DeWine signed legislation that would ban abortion upon detection of a fetal heartbeat, similar to Georgia's "heartbeat bill." Ohio had attempted to pass several heartbeat bills in the past, but all of them were deemed unconstitutional and subsequently vetoed. Like Georgia's bill, Ohio's legislation permits abortion to "prevent the death of the pregnant woman" or in cases where there is "a serious risk of the substantial and irreversible impairment of a major bodily function of the pregnant woman." Physicians who perform abortions after a fetal heartbeat is detected, or who fail to check for a heartbeat, would be guilty of a fifth-degree felony and face lawsuits for civil damages.

Like Georgia and Alabama's legislation, the intent to confront the Supreme Court is no secret. State Representative Ron Hood states in an interview with Ohio Public Radio, "Will there be a lawsuit? Yeah, we are counting on it. We're counting on it. We're excited about it." Ohio is but another state to pass aggressive abortion legislation to gain the attention of the United States Supreme Court.


In order to successfully reverse the Roe v. Wade ruling, the Supreme Court would have to go back on its 1973 ruling and readdress the United State Constitution's role in a woman's fundamental right to an abortion. The justices would then have to rule that the interpretation of the law in Roe was mistaken and offer a new interpretation of the Constitution. A historic case like Roe v. Wade is so well-known, that it would take a significant amount of contrasting evidence for the court to decide to overturn it entirely—rather than just make incremental changes. It is more likely that Alabama, Georgia, and Ohio's bills will serve to chip away gradually at Roe and Casey without outright overturning it.


Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Lifestyle

The Great Christmas Movie Debate

"A Christmas Story" is the star on top of the tree.

575
The Great Christmas Movie Debate
Mental Floss

One staple of the Christmas season is sitting around the television watching a Christmas movie with family and friends. But of the seemingly hundreds of movies, which one is the star on the tree? Some share stories of Santa to children ("Santa Claus Is Coming to Town"), others want to spread the Christmas joy to adults ("It's a Wonderful Life"), and a select few are made to get laughs ("Elf"). All good movies, but merely ornaments on the Christmas tree of the best movies. What tops the tree is a movie that bridges the gap between these three movies, and makes it a great watch for anyone who chooses to watch it. Enter the timeless Christmas classic, "A Christmas Story." Created in 1983, this movie holds the tradition of capturing both young and old eyes for 24 straight hours on its Christmas Day marathon. It gets the most coverage out of all holiday movies, but the sheer amount of times it's on television does not make it the greatest. Why is it,
then? A Christmas Story does not try to tell the tale of a Christmas miracle or use Christmas magic to move the story. What it does do though is tell the real story of Christmas. It is relatable and brings out the unmatched excitement of children on Christmas in everyone who watches. Every one becomes a child again when they watch "A Christmas Story."

Keep Reading...Show less
student thinking about finals in library
StableDiffusion

As this semester wraps up, students can’t help but be stressed about finals. After all, our GPAs depends on these grades! What student isn’t worrying about their finals right now? It’s “goodbye social life, hello library” time from now until the end of finals week.

1. Finals are weeks away, I’m sure I’ll be ready for them when they come.

Keep Reading...Show less
Christmas tree
Librarian Lavender

It's the most wonderful time of the year! Christmas is one of my personal favorite holidays because of the Christmas traditions my family upholds generation after generation. After talking to a few of my friends at college, I realized that a lot of them don't really have "Christmas traditions" in their family, and I want to help change that. Here's a list of Christmas traditions that my family does, and anyone can incorporate into their family as well!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 5 Phases Of Finals

May the odds be ever in your favor.

1982
Does anybody know how to study
Gurl.com

It’s here; that time of year when college students turn into preschoolers again. We cry for our mothers, eat everything in sight, and whine when we don’t get our way. It’s finals, the dreaded time of the semester when we all realize we should have been paying attention in class instead of literally doing anything else but that. Everyone has to take them, and yes, unfortunately, they are inevitable. But just because they are here and inevitable does not mean they’re peaches and cream and full of rainbows. Surviving them is a must, and the following five phases are a reality for all majors from business to art, nursing to history.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

How To Prepare For The Library: Finals Edition

10 ways to prepare for finals week—beginning with getting to the library.

3245
How To Prepare For The Library: Finals Edition
Photo by Clay Banks on Unsplash

It’s that time of year again when college students live at the library all week, cramming for tests that they should have started studying for last month. Preparing to spend all day at the library takes much consideration and planning. Use these tips to help get you through the week while spending an excessive amount of time in a building that no one wants to be in.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments