Trump's National Emergency Is A Sham | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Dear Trump, Your National Emergency Is Sham, Pick Up A Constitution

The President's declaration is nothing short of an illegal, unconstitutional power grab.

232
Dear Trump, Your National Emergency Is Sham, Pick Up A Constitution
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=55L60jkk-nE&t=7948s

On Friday, February 15th, President Trump declared a national emergency to secure funding for his wall after failing to get this funding from Congress. As I write this, 16 states are challenging the emergency declaration in court.

While I believe that there are certainly more effective ways to deal with the issue of illegal immigration than building a physical wall, Trump's actions are not only disturbing as a matter of public policy; they fundamentally upend the constitutional norms of our federal government, subverting our precious system of checks and balances and fueling Trump's authoritarian tendencies.

The Constitution clearly gives Congress the power of the purse. Congress is the body that is supposed to decide how to spend taxpayer money, and on what federal policy programs. So controlling government revenue is the domain of the legislative branch, not the executive. The Trump Administration has invoked the National Emergencies Act of 1976 to justify the President's action. While this statute certainly gives Presidents sweeping authority to declare an emergency, the act has up until now been used only for real emergencies, like a terrorist attack or a hurricane.

Bush declared a national emergency after Hurricane Katrina and Obama declared one to deal with the Swine Flu Epidemic. The purpose of the act was to allow the President to immediately deal with a crisis and direct the resources of the federal government to this end. By taking this law and applying it to his signature policy issue to build his vanity project, Trump is going against the legislative intent and circumventing the will of Congress while usurping their constitutional authority.

Illegal immigration certainly is an important policy issue and the US immigration system is in dire need of reform. But to say, as Trump does, that this is a national emergency is the textbook definition of fear-mongering, blowing up a problem for the sake of political gain. If Trump cared about facts, he would acknowledge that illegal border crossings have in fact declined in recent years. Even the use of the word "invasion", conjuring up images of war and disease reflects Trump's ugly xenophobia.

The National Emergencies Act allows the President to direct military construction that is necessary to support the armed forces; Trump's wall does not fit that description. While such action helps Trump with his base, it does violence to the fundamental norms of our political system. The Founding Fathers are probably rolling in their graves.

It's also been frustrating to see Republicans, who constantly claim to wholeheartedly defend the liberty of Americans against big government, falling in line. Republican politicians who regularly criticized Obama for his immigration executive orders are now supporting this unconstitutional overreach. During the Obama Administration, conservatives constantly complained about an Imperial Presidency.

Now that a Republican is in the White House doing using executive power to do something they like, they have forgotten these concerns. But this new embrace of expanded Presidential authority may come back to haunt Republicans when a Democrat wins the White House and starts declaring national emergencies over climate change and gun violence.

At the end of the day, it comes down to this- If, as the Trump Administration seems to believe, the President has the power to declare a national emergency over any important issue of public policy, then our country isn't a constitutional republic; it's a dictatorship. Though I don't think Trump has even read the Constitution. To echo Khizr Khan's iconic moment at the 2016 Democratic Convention, I would gladly lend him my copy.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
coffee

It's finally flu season! It's around that time in the school year where everyone on campus is getting sick, especially if they live in the dorms. It's hard to take care of yourself while being sick at school, but here are some coping mechanisms to get you on the path to feeling better!

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

The Battle Between College And My Mental Health

College isn't easy, and I'm afraid I'm not going to make it at the rate my mental health is going.

570
woman sitting on black chair in front of glass-panel window with white curtains
Photo by Anthony Tran on Unsplash

Everyone tells you that college is hard, but they fail to explain why. Sure, classes are hard. Math sucks, and political science can be so boring. But that's not even what's killing me about college. What's killing me about college is my deterioating mental health.

As a college student, I feel as if people don't understand just how exhausted I, and fellow college students are. We have so many things going on, all the time, and sometimes it's hard to explain to people how we feel. Personally...I'm tired. I'm sad. And I'm struggling every single day with my emotions. But the thing is, it hasn't always been this way. I haven't always hated school, so why am I feeling like this now?

Keep Reading...Show less
manager

For the average 20-something, life moves pretty fast. You’ve got classes, friends, relationships, jobs, family, and whatever else we overcommit ourselves with. I probably should have learned to say no to adding more to my schedule a long time ago, but instead here are 11 things that can be more helpful than coffee.

Keep Reading...Show less
Parks And Rec
NBC

Your professor mentions there's a test in a few days and you didn't know about it.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf

Resting b***h face. Defined as a person, usually a girl, who naturally looks mean when her face is expressionless, without meaning to. Many of you suffer from this "condition." You are commonly asked what's wrong, when nothing is. What people don't know is that is just your facial expression. Here are some things they wish you knew.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments