Movie Review: "The Girl On The Train" | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

Movie Review: "The Girl On The Train"

6 differences between the novel and movie versions.

9
Movie Review: "The Girl On The Train"
Instagram

This post contains SPOILERS for both the movie and book versions of "The Girl on the Train."

Director Tate Taylor’s portrayal of Paula Hawkins’ best-selling novel “The Girl on the Train” offers a one of a kind emotional thriller experience. The movie was released on October 7, starring Emily Blunt, Haley Bennett and Rebecca Ferguson.

The movie is divided into different perspectives just like the book, telling the story of three troubled women: Rachel Watson (Emily Blunt), Megan Hipwell (Haley Bennett) and Anna Watson (Rebecca Ferguson).

The filmmakers did a decent job following the book. However, like most transitions from page to screen, “The Girl on the Train” fails to incorporate scenes that are found in the novel. The following is a list of six ways the movie differs from the book.

1. It’s set in the suburbs of New York City instead of the suburbs of London. This information has been public knowledge since the summer, but it doesn’t really affect anything but the characters’ accents. Emily Blunt’s character Rachel retains her British accent though.

2. Rachel’s drink of choice is vodka instead of gin. In the book, Rachel spent her fake commutes chugging canned gin and tonic, which is apparently a thing you can purchase in a store using your real money. Depending on your point of view, her movie choice is either better or more tragic — straight vodka poured into a giant water bottle.

3. Scott and Rachel’s relationship isn’t quite as developed as it was in the book. Rachel still inserts herself into Scott’s life by claiming to be a friend of Megan’s, but she never meets his mother, or shares a bed with him.

4. Dr. Kamal Abdic's role. In both the novel and the film, Megan's therapist Kamal plays a supporting character in the plot line. However, in the novel Megan makes it seem like Kamal is starting to return some of the affection she has for him. They kiss a few times, usually prompted by Megan but also by Kamal. In the film, Kamal is more firm in his resistance of Megan. Also, the number of times Rachel goes to see Kamal later on in the book when she wants to know more about him, is downplayed.

5. Tom’s history of lying is slightly different. Rachel eventually figures out that Tom is playing her, Anna, and pretty much every woman he’s ever met, but in the book, this deception is a little more fleshed out. Rachel thinks that she never met Tom’s parents because he was estranged from them, but that turned out to be a lie too. In the movie, there are no parents at all.

6. Lisa Kudrow's character Martha and her role in Rachel's realization. In the novel, Rachel begins to realize that Tom was not honest about what happened while she was intoxicated. After conversations with Kamal, her therapist, Rachel discovers that the reason her memories of her feelings don't match up with what Tom told her she was feeling is because Tom was inventing situations. In the film, Martha helps Rachel realize Tom was lying.

I thought this was a good movie based on a fantastic book. I always believe that books are much better than the movies based on books. However, this movie did a decent job of bringing the book to life. I highly recommend reading the Hawkins’ novel before seeing this movie.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Relationships

10 Reasons Why It's Awesome When Your Best Friend Gets New Friends

She may not be with you 24/7 but it's all good because you're soul sisters.

239
super friends
Gabi Morales

We all have a person, and when that person makes some new friends, we tend to forget all the great things that can come out of it. Never forget how special they are to you and why you are best friends.

Keep Reading...Show less
mountains

If you're like me, then the last semester kicked your butt, big time. Lots of papers, projects, and overall chaos. While some things are beyond our control, there are some things you can do to make this semester one of your best ones yet!

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

8 Cringey College Tinder Stories

. Cringey Tinder stories from some Tinder girls

2388
a man and a woman sitting at a table
Photo by Good Faces on Unsplash

Toilet Troubles

"So, usually I would never go on a Tinder date but when you are out with girlfriends and a hot Bosnian guy says he wants to hang with you and his friends, you oblige. We head to their apartment and when I realized I may pee my pants if I don't find a bathroom soon. I ask for the bathroom and a friend of my tinder date shows me to it and said in all seriousness that I was not allowed to flush the toilet under ANY circumstances. Having a few drinks--or five--I relieved myself to, nevertheless, flush the toilet. Within seconds, his bathroom was flooded and towels were laid out everywhere to catch the toilet water. To say the least, we were not invited back"

Keep Reading...Show less
Girl with a Guy Bestfriend
vignette3

I can confidently say that about 90 percent of all the friends I have are male. It's just always been that way since I was a kid. Over the years, I've heard a lot of things and I've learned a lot of things, and here it all is. Enjoy!

If you're a girl with a guy best friend you know that...

Keep Reading...Show less
Greek Life
Clare Concannon

With being a member of Greek life, you are going to come across people who HATE Greek life and who always want to say something negative towards it. If you're not a part of Greek life, there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But maybe try and keep some of the not-so-nice comments to yourself.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments