Mainstream Environmentalism As An Exclusionary Narrative | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Mainstream Environmentalism As An Exclusionary Narrative

A response to Dorceta Taylor's "Race, Class, Gender, and American Environmentalism."

425
Mainstream Environmentalism As An Exclusionary Narrative
California Environmental Protection Agency

I recently read a paper by Dorceta Taylor entitled "Race, Class, Gender and American Environmentalism" (the article can be found here) in which she traces the history of the American environmental movement and its interactions with various segments of society from the first half of the 19th Century until the present time. After reading this paper I was inspired to write a piece about what I perceive to be Taylor's central goal: to challenge the dominant explanation, or narrative, about what it means to be an environmentalist and what sorts of issues environmentalists should be concerned with. For although environmentalism is a very broad term, it is often used in a very narrow sense. Allow me to explain.

Taylor's piece amounts to approximately 45 pages of descriptive text, and presents a huge volume of information, yet it only barely skims the surface of each topic it covers. The primary reason for the summary nature of the piece is that it highlights a plethora of factors that mainstream accounts of the history of the environmental movement in the United States tend to ignore. These accounts focus on a few key figures and events (for example, the publication of "Silent Spring" by Rachel Carson in 1962). They also gloss over the impact of contributing movements such as the Feminist Movement, The Civil Rights Movement, the American Indian movement, and a whole slew of others. Moreover, mainstream accounts focus on a distinctly white, middle-class and predominantly male vision of environmentalism. By rewriting this history, Taylor broadens our conception of the environmental movement and of environmentalism.

The dominant narrative of environmentalism, the one that most of you are probably familiar with, emphasizes the creation of National Parks and wildlife preserves, creation of urban parks and green spaces, efforts to reduce production of CO2, cleaning up of the oceans, and other globalized issues. What it excludes are the stories of individual people, who are closer to us than we perhaps expect, and who have experienced the dangers of environmental degradation first hand. These people are disproportionately poor and people of color. Throughout the history of the environmental movement, the concerns of these groups were considered secondary to the concerns of the dominant group of white, middle-class males. Thus, these groups were subjected to toxic dumping near their homes, eviction (to create the urban parks we love so much), hazardous working conditions (as other groups began to avoid occupations such as coal mining and manufacturing that were clearly damaging to both the environment and the workers), job loss (as factories were slowly subjected to environmental protection measures and began to close) and much more. What the dominant narrative ignores is that as the powerful members of society sought to avoid environmental problems and improve their own lot, these problems were then displaced onto other groups.

Furthermore, the dominant narrative advertises a certain brand of interaction with nature, a brand that just so happens to be available only to a select few. In this view, nature is a site for recreation, sensory pleasure and sometimes self-improvement. In other words, a place where one goes to hunt, to enjoy the scenery, or to escape into a simplicity that promotes contemplation. It is a vacation of sorts from the stress of everyday working life. This perspective neglects the experience of millions of migrant farm workers in the U.S. who depend on the literal and figurative fruits of the earth for a living. And it glosses over the fact that for many, going camping is not an option. It is not an option because it requires taking time off from work, spending money, driving to non-central locations, knowledge of the outdoors and other things that many of us take for granted. Spending time in the outdoors for the purposes listed above is a privilege.

As a white college student from a financially stable background I have to confront my own privilege when thinking about my role in the environmental movement. Coming from a politically liberal city and an environmentally conscious family, I have been exposed to many environmental issues in theory but not in practice. I have not had to deal with water contamination, air pollution or workplace safety concerns first hand. I have had the privilege of going hiking and backpacking and spending time in beautiful city parks. I think it is important to acknowledge the multidimensionality of the environmental movement and to realize that our own privileges may sometimes blind us to the concerns of others.


Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
students
Sophia Palmerine

Dear High School Friend Group,

My sweet angels, where would I be without you guys. We all grew up together because we either met in middle school or high school and watched each other grow up and get "old." We got to go to prom together and then graduate together. Then watched each other as we continued our lives in college, joining sororities and meeting people who will impact our lives forever. It all has happened so fast.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

College In Gifs

Because we are all sad Jim Halpert

879
head on desk
Wise GEEK

Oh college, we can’t live with you, but we can’t live without you. It’s a love/hate relationship, really. College is an experience that no one can ever prepare you for, and maybe that’s a good thing. You never really expect any of the things that college encompasses until you are there. College is fun, but don’t have too much fun. C’s get degrees, but they don’t get you into graduate school.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf

The "Gossip Girl" series may be over, but Blair Waldorf's iconic character lives in our hearts forever. Blair was the queen of the Upper East Side, and a character you either loved or hated. She taught us everything we needed to know about life, love and of course, how to score a Chuck Bass. So the next time you feel a bit lost and are in need of guidance, look no further than to the Queen B herself.

As I spend my Sunday avoiding my homework and other adult responsibilities, I realized that I've watched this series over and over about a million times. Sadly, there isn't a Blair quote I don't know, so I came up with a list of a few favorites. You know you love her...xoxo

Keep Reading...Show less
class
Odyssey

College is an endless cycle of crappy, sleepless nights, tedious, boring lectures, and hours of never-ending piles of homework.

Keep Reading...Show less
two women enjoying confetti

Summer: a time (usually) free from school work and a time to relax with your friends and family. Maybe you go on a vacation or maybe you work all summer, but the time off really does help. When you're in college you become super close with so many people it's hard to think that you won't see many of them for three months. But, then you get that text saying, "Hey, clear your schedule next weekend, I'm coming up" and you begin to flip out. Here are the emotions you go through as your best friend makes her trip to your house.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments