Legal Positivism and Natural Law | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Arts Entertainment

Legal Positivism and Natural Law

An interesting look into the relationship between law and morality in legislation.

24
Legal Positivism and Natural Law
Kelly Peterson

For my required freshman writing class this semester, I chose "Issues in Law and Social Justice." Sounds pretty boring, but at the same time extremely intriguing. Just earlier today we handed in our first paper. The topic was: to which does one owe greater deference: law or personal morality? This was question extremely hard to answer, especially in today's political climate, law and morality do not always align. Amidst my research, I found two interesting concepts that are fun to ponder: legal positivism and natural law.

Legal positivism is a concept that I found to be the closest to what American politics follows. It basically derives from three theses that state that 1) a law is only valid when it's enforced by an institution with consequences, 2) law doesn't necessarily have to derive from morality, and 3) legal precedents are set by judges who reach outside of written law to decide cases. Sounds familiar, doesn't it?

Natural law, on the contrary, is all about morality. It is formed from two theories of natural law, one of morality and the other law. The theory of morality says that doing good by mankind is realizing a purpose. More specifically a purpose that promotes happiness, through rationality, abstract knowledge, free choice, imagination, friendship, and social cooperation--all based on a sense of justice. It also rejects ethical subjectivism and accepts ethical objectivism. The prior means that morality is defined by each person, and the latter implies that some morality is good and other is bad because morality is defined as a consensus of cultural values. The theory of law says that unjust laws are not laws at all, but just perversions of justice. It also says that we have no legal or moral responsibility to follow those laws that conflict with natural law.

Now with this knowledge in mind, think about some legal issues in society. Let's think about the border wall, from a legally positive perspective the wall is, without objection, totally fine. Leaving morality out of the picture, no problems arise. However, natural law despises the border wall. There are so many moral objections to the creation of this division. Not only are people actually dying in the countries that they are fleeing, they are also dying at the wall itself. What is more immoral, denying refugee's asylum? Or allowing them to die by not intervening?

Of course no situation is obviously good or bad, and political, economic, social, and environmental issues complicate what society defines morality as. Despite this, we as a society need to look at our methods for creating legislating. Democracy is thought to best express the values and morality of the constituents, but morality is constantly failed by this system of government. The wall stands (figuratively and literally) as a symbol for how law isn't always what is moral, and issues of civil rights, like trans people in the military, represent the injustices that are still faced by so many today. Natural law says that human good is based in social cooperation, and so many events in the American government show day by day that we do not only lack cooperation, but we reject it.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Honorary Roommate
Rachel Zadeits

For some of us, coming to college was the first time we ever had to share a room. It was a big change, but a fun one. As you meet more and more people over the course of your college career, it seems to be a pattern that you will at some point have that one friend that doesn't live with you, but acts like they do. We call those people, "Honorary Roommates" and here are 11 signs you have one in your life.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

10 Reasons Why It's Awesome When Your Best Friend Gets New Friends

She may not be with you 24/7 but it's all good because you're soul sisters.

1175
super friends
Gabi Morales

We all have a person, and when that person makes some new friends, we tend to forget all the great things that can come out of it. Never forget how special they are to you and why you are best friends.

Keep Reading...Show less
mountains

If you're like me, then the last semester kicked your butt, big time. Lots of papers, projects, and overall chaos. While some things are beyond our control, there are some things you can do to make this semester one of your best ones yet!

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

8 Cringey College Tinder Stories

. Cringey Tinder stories from some Tinder girls

3025
a man and a woman sitting at a table
Photo by Good Faces on Unsplash

Toilet Troubles

"So, usually I would never go on a Tinder date but when you are out with girlfriends and a hot Bosnian guy says he wants to hang with you and his friends, you oblige. We head to their apartment and when I realized I may pee my pants if I don't find a bathroom soon. I ask for the bathroom and a friend of my tinder date shows me to it and said in all seriousness that I was not allowed to flush the toilet under ANY circumstances. Having a few drinks--or five--I relieved myself to, nevertheless, flush the toilet. Within seconds, his bathroom was flooded and towels were laid out everywhere to catch the toilet water. To say the least, we were not invited back"

Keep Reading...Show less
Girl with a Guy Bestfriend
vignette3

I can confidently say that about 90 percent of all the friends I have are male. It's just always been that way since I was a kid. Over the years, I've heard a lot of things and I've learned a lot of things, and here it all is. Enjoy!

If you're a girl with a guy best friend you know that...

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments