It's Time To Kill The Death Penalty | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

It's Time To Kill The Death Penalty

Why we must end the immoral and ineffective practice of killing our criminals and citizens.

75
It's Time To Kill The Death Penalty
The Times-Picayune

We find ourselves at a place in history where human rights issues have never been more important. As we continue to push for social equality regardless of race, creed, gender or sexual orientation, we often overlook something far more detrimental to society than any discrimination. We sentence criminals to death, despite a deep understanding that our criminal justice system is flawed and not working for the common good. The death penalty is inefficient, ineffective, fallaciously carried out and racially biased, and it is holding our country back from truly being the land of the free.

1. The death penalty is more costly than life without parole.

One of the most frequently used arguments in favor of the death penalty is the cost of punishing a criminal. Too often, we hear complaints of, “Why should I pay to keep this worthless criminal in jail? Just kill him, it’ll be cheaper." But is it actually cheaper? Former Orange County Judge Donald McCartin disagrees. With the nickname “The Hanging Judge of Orange County,” McCartin knows a thing or two about capital punishment, having sentenced nine men to death. McCartin notes the differences in costs of prosecuting a capital punishment case versus the cost of a non-capital case.

For starters, the Kansas Judicial Council found that “defending a death penalty case costs about four times as much as defending a case where the death penalty is not considered." In addition to the cost of prosecuting and defending a capital punishment case, the time spent on appeals is almost 44 times more (on average) than the time spent on cases where life in prison is at stake. I could continue, but at the end of the day, who foots that bill? State and local governments have to cover these costs — and that is done through taxes. Of course, speeding up the appeals process is not an option, since we already aren't getting it right (more on that at point 3). The wheels of justice move slowly at the best of times, and especially when someone’s life is at stake.

2. The death penalty does not deter crime.

Yet another claim levied in favor of the death penalty is that it deters crime. I mean it's common sense, who would rape, murder or kidnap people if they know they will probably get put to death if they get caught? As logical as that may be, Jeffrey Fagan of Columbia Law School (and many other experts) disagree. Despite pouring over statistics and studies, Fagan admits, “We’re very hard pressed to find really strong evidence of deterrence."

Additionally, even with a global perspective, there is little evidence for capital punishment deterring crime. Take a look at Hong Kong (where the death penalty was abolished in 1993) and Singapore (where the death penalty is mandatory and administered within a year and a half for murder and many other crimes). Despite their drastically different policies, there is little difference in the homicide rates of the two countries.

The same outcome is present in another study comparing the amount of violence in states in the US with and without the death penalty.

While these studies do not prove without a doubt that there is no deterrent to crime, they also do not support the claim that the death penalty actually does much to deter crime. That alone should give us reason to pause and reconsider. Another potential point to consider would be the deterrent effects of life without parole as opposed to capital punishment. Due to a lack of comprehensive data studying, life without parole is not something researchers have the ability to research at this time, but it should be considered nonetheless.

3. We have executed innocent people.

No other point made in defense of the death penalty holds any water if the practice itself is not carried out flawlessly. It would be one thing if we executed the guilty individual 100 percent of the time (spoiler alert, we don’t), but it shocks me that people are OK with continuing to use a broken system. According to one study from the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, it is entirely possible that 4 percent of people who have received the death penalty are actually innocent. Additionally, it makes me wonder at the ignorance of those who suggest speeding up the appeals process in order to save on costs of carrying out the death sentence. If we can't get it right at this pace, what good does it do to speed it up? Regardless of whether you believe in “an eye for an eye” for the most heinous of crimes, we should be disgusted that anyone is subjected to living their life on death row until they possibly get executed, despite the fact that they did absolutely nothing wrong.

(As a disclaimer, it may appear as though I am not giving this section its fair coverage, but if I have to convince you that wrongly killing up to 4 percent of people who have been given the death penalty, then there are bigger issues you need to consider.)

4. The death penalty process is racially biased.

As much as we want to say that we are colorblind, the death penalty certainly is not. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, people of color have accounted for a disproportionate 43 percent of the total executions since 1976. What's more, 55 percent of those currently awaiting execution are also people of color.

Additionally, while only 50 percent of murder cases involve white victims, 80 percent of capital cases involve white victims. This imbalance implies that our system values white lives more than black lives, in that more homicides with white victims are taken to court for capital punishment. Further, as of October 2002, 12 white defendants have been executed for killing a black victim, while 178 black defendants have been executed for killing a white victim. Studies in individual states have found that many states traditionally sought the death penalty for black defendants, even when crimes were almost identical to white defendants who were not considered for the death penalty. Many states also attempted to remove black jurors from capital punishment cases. If our criminal justice system has such an obvious and strong racial bias, calling it “justice” would be laughable, even if people’s lives weren’t at stake.

In short, the death penalty being broken is a symptom of the larger fundamental issues that are far too prevalent in our criminal justice system. While we need to stop and examine all of our laws and how they are enforced, the death penalty takes first priority because once it’s done, it’s done. Arbitrarily throwing around the harshest of penalties under the guise of “justice” is immoral, and at the end of the day, entirely ineffective.

As Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel said that in a democracy, “few are guilty, but all are responsible." We have the obligation to speak out against the injustice that is being carried out “for our own good." Do your part! Contact your elected officials and demand that they do the right thing, and repeal the death penalty.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Adulting

6 Unrealistic Expectations Society Has For Young Adults

Don't let the thesaurus-inspired vocabularies in our résumés fool you. We're actually just big kids.

2230
boy in adult clothes

Well over four feet tall and 100 pounds in weight, many of us "young adults" of the world still consider ourselves children. Big, working, college-attending, beer-drinking children. We may live on our own, know how to cook noodles, and occasionally use a planner, but don't be fooled; the youthful tendencies that reside within us still make their way into our daily lives. From choosing to stay up until 3:00 a.m. playing video games on a school night to going out in 30 degree weather without a coat, we still make decisions that our parents and grandparents would shake their heads at in disappointment. So why are we expected to know exactly how to be a wise, professional, sensible adult? It's not that we're irresponsible (for the most part, anyway). It's that we are young, inexperienced, and still have the sought-after, enthusiastic mentality that we can do and be whatever we want, which has not yet been tarnished by the reality of the world. These are just a few of the unrealistic expectations that society has for young adults.

Keep Reading...Show less
pizza
Fandango

There are a lot of foods in this world, but there is only one dish that stands above the rest: Pizza. If you're close to me or at least know who I am, then you know that I'm totally obsessed with pizza. It's one of my favorite things to eat and I will NEVER turn down a slice, even if it doesn't have my favorite toppings. There isn't a day that goes by where I'm not thinking about pizza. I even sleep with a pizza pillow every night! There are many reasons why pizza stands above all other foods, and here are just a couple reasons why.

Keep Reading...Show less
sex and the city
Warner Bros. Television

1. You don't have to feel guilty about flirting with customers for tips (or just for shits and giggles).

2. You can be obnoxiously flirtatious with anyone you want. You are free to be that girl that flirts with everybody and makes 'em all smile (it's especially fun when the guy is as cute as Collin Jost). No shame.

3. Making random men nervous with your superior beauty and intense eye contact just for the hell of it is really amusing and empowering.

4. No one gives two poops if ya legs are hairy (your man shouldn't either but *Kermit the Frog meme* That's none of my business)

5. The toilet seat will remain down.

6. There's more money to spend on yourself.

7. There's always this secret butterfly in your tummy that marvels at the possibility that when you go out this weekend you're gonna meet someone super handsome/wonderful/prince-like and have this moment of dazzling dalliance.

8. Nothing is that serious...you can take it all with a grain of salt...you don't owe anybody anything.

9. You can dance with anyone and everyone...or no one (Hello frat boi w/ glasses, I see you).

10. You don't have to fluff anyone's ego but your own.

11. Free drinks and dinners from single guys (It's not taking advantage if they're offering; a girl's gotta eat).

12. You have more time to learn how to love and improve yourself rather than constantly pouring your energy into another person.

13. You don't have to sacrifice your cheesy Jen Aniston rom-coms and Gilmore Girls for his Fast and Furious/other dumb action movie featuring blonde that is only in the movie to supply a relationship to the male lead and to make him look more masculine/empowered in juxtaposition (In other words, you don't have to deal with a guy being a crabby Patty while you watch your cute movies).

14. You can daydream about what your future husband may be doing right now (and not get stressed/guilty out because you're not picturing your current boyfriend that's crazy about you as your future husband).

15. There is more time to be spent with your girlfriends.

Girls Night In
Milk + Blush

We've all been there - you've been saying since Tuesday after French that this weekend is the weekend. You're finally going to break out those new heels and actually put on eyeliner on and make this Friday night be one for the memory books! That is, of course, until Girls Night Out turned into...Girls Night In.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

What Is Your Zodiac GIF?

Characteristics of the astrological signs, explained through GIFS.

787
zodiac
Wordpress

Whether you believe astrology is a legitimate "science" or not, we have all found ourselves looking at our horoscopes from time to time. The 12 astrological signs all fall under one of four elements: air, water, earth, or fire. Air signs are rational, social, and love to communicate with others. Water signs are are emotional, intuitive, and mysterious. Fire signs tend to be passionate, creative, and adventurous. Earth signs are conservative, realistic, and loyal.

Each sign is determined by the relative positions of celestial bodies to ourselves at our moment of birth, which is said to influence our personalities. Find your zodiac GIF below, based on the traits and characteristics provided by each sign.

***Disclaimer: GIFS are meant to be lighthearted and are based on descriptions of signs from http://www.astrology-zodiac-signs.com/.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments