Was James Gunn's Firing Justified? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Arts Entertainment

Accountability vs. Overcensorship: A Fine Line? The Case For James Gunn

Today, James Gunn is a man that many will vouch for, and will stand up for.

114
Accountability vs. Overcensorship: A Fine Line? The Case For James Gunn
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/BkDcwDMAz5K/?taken-by=jamesgunn

There is a fine line between accountability and over-censorship. It is difficult to conclusively determine the extent to which free speech should be allowed. Where do we draw the line? When does something become too insensitive to be held unaccountable? Last week, director James Gunn, the mind behind Marvel's "Guardians of the Galaxy" and its sequel, was fired from the third installment of the franchise. Vocal about his political allegiances, Gunn was targeted by a group of Trump supporters, who sought to diminish his credibility by publicly shaming him using his old tweets. These tweets, revolving around sensitive subject matters including rape and pedophilia, joked about these issues under a bad light.

In recent years, Hollywood has moved towards a zero-tolerance policy, shunning actors for social misconduct. Recent high-profile cases include Kevin Spacey, accused of sexual harassment, and Roseanne Barr, dismissed from her show due to racist tweets. While in both the aforementioned cases, there was a near-unanimous consensus in support of the action taken by the respective studios in charge (Netflix and ABC), in Gunn's case, there has been a vocal opposition to Disney's decision of firing him from the project. This outrage comes not just from his fans, but from his fellow colleagues as well, with the likes of Dave Bautista, who plays Drax in the Marvel Universe, and Chris Pratt, who plays Star-Lord, being vocal about their support for Gunn.

The polarizing nature of this controversy begs the question, what makes this case so different from the others? Here is when the line must be drawn between accountability and over-censorship. Is it really justified to hold him accountable for his words from years ago? While the passage of time certainly doesn't make his attempts at humor any less insensitive or in better taste, it doesn't have to necessarily reflect his current views. In a publicly issues statement after his firing, Gunn wrote the following:

"Many people who have followed my career know when I started, I viewed myself as a provocateur, making movies and telling jokes that were outrageous and taboo. As I have discussed publicly many times, as I've developed as a person, so has my work and my humor. It's not to say I'm better, but I am very, very different than I was a few years ago; today I try to root my work in love and connection and less in anger. My days saying something just because it's shocking and trying to get a reaction are over. In the past, I have apologized for humor of mine that hurt people. I truly felt sorry and meant every word of my apologies. For the record, when I made these shocking jokes, I wasn't living them out. Anyway, that's the completely honest truth: I used to make a lot of offensive jokes. I don't anymore. I don't blame my past self for this, but I like myself more and feel like a more full human being and creator today. Love you to you all."

Previously, in 2012, he had issued another public apology for his poor "jokes". Bearing in mind that this apology was put up on the internet long before he was hired by Disney to spearhead the Guardians franchise, what changed?

Disney, presumably with full knowledge of his past history and comments, gave him the job. Yet, years later, after those tweets which he clearly does not believe in anymore, have resurfaced again; does it warrant a sacking?

From a purely ethical perspective, yes. According to Immanuel Kant's theory of deontological ethics, morality is a set of values that is universal. In layman's terms, it postulates that what is wrong is always wrong, and that what is right is always right. Considering this, each action has its own intrinsic morality. In this case, poking fun at the expense of one's tragedy certainly falls under a wrongdoing, and therefore, would be considered ethically wrong.

However, moral relativism is an essential angle to consider. Relatively speaking, a few crass jokes regarding the unfortunate circumstances that people suffer through does not justify expulsion. That is not to say that it's a behavior that should be condoned, however, in this case, the punishment may have been too harsh, hence sparking a massive industrial backlash.

There is a strong irony to this whole issue. Considering that Gunn's tweets were shamed by a known offender of the same crime, Mike Cernovich, the whole affair seems unjust. Not only is Cernovich a sexist, far-right propagandist, he is also associated with people who are somewhat less than holy, including openly racist and white supremacist individuals. One cannot help but wonder, should these people really be preaching about morality?

The biggest irony, however, is that Disney itself has been accused of being racist, sexist, and offensive in stereotyping characters based on their backgrounds in the past, amongst other things. However, they have been moving towards building a more family friendly, respectful, and inclusive brand. Today, Disney is synonymous with happiness. The key thing to remember here is that the company has changed over the years and made themselves better, similar to what James Gunn has done.

Ownership and acceptance of a minor wrongdoing in the past, in my opinion, particularly of an online comment, shouldn't be enough charge to incriminate a man over a decade later, particularly considering it will likely end his career. As, according to his own words, he wasn't "living" his words – what he said was, and will remain, attempts at humor made in bad judgment. What matters is people change. Today, James Gunn is a man that many will vouch for, and will stand up for. Including some of Hollywood's finest, including the thousands that admire his work worldwide.

So, when the question of his legacy comes up, I believe the answer shouldn't be "got fired for being an a-hole". It should be, "he stood accountable for his past, acknowledged he made a mistake, and bore the consequences without complaining." Because, as Batman once said (I know, I know, wrong fandom), "it's not who you are, but what you do that defines you." It doesn't matter what one used to be. What matters is, what you do in the present, and what you will do in the future. Everyone deserves a shot at redemption, a second chance, because faith in each other, and faith in humanity, is how we can make the world a better place.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

12 Midnight NYE: Fun Ideas!

This isn't just for the single Pringles out there either, folks

13705
Friends celebrating the New Years!
StableDiffusion

When the clock strikes twelve midnight on New Year's Eve, do you ever find yourself lost regarding what to do during that big moment? It's a very important moment. It is the first moment of the New Year, doesn't it seem like you should be doing something grand, something meaningful, something spontaneous? Sure, many decide to spend the moment on the lips of another, but what good is that? Take a look at these other suggestions on how to ring in the New Year that are much more spectacular and exciting than a simple little kiss.

Keep Reading...Show less
piano
Digital Trends

I am very serious about the Christmas season. It's one of my favorite things, and I love it all from gift-giving to baking to the decorations, but I especially love Christmas music. Here are 11 songs you should consider adding to your Christmas playlists.

Keep Reading...Show less
campus
CampusExplorer

New year, new semester, not the same old thing. This semester will be a semester to redeem all the mistakes made in the previous five months.

1. I will wake up (sorta) on time for class.

Let's face it, last semester you woke up with enough time to brush your teeth and get to class and even then you were about 10 minutes late and rollin' in with some pretty unfortunate bed head. This semester we will set our alarms, wake up with time to get ready, and get to class on time!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 5 Painfully True Stages Of Camping Out At The Library

For those long nights that turn into mornings when the struggle is real.

2684
woman reading a book while sitting on black leather 3-seat couch
Photo by Seven Shooter on Unsplash

And so it begins.

1. Walk in motivated and ready to rock

Camping out at the library is not for the faint of heart. You need to go in as a warrior. You usually have brought supplies (laptop, chargers, and textbooks) and sustenance (water, snacks, and blanket/sweatpants) since the battle will be for an undetermined length of time. Perhaps it is one assignment or perhaps it's four. You are motivated and prepared; you don’t doubt the assignment(s) will take time, but you know it couldn’t be that long.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 14 Stages Of The Last Week Of Class

You need sleep, but also have 13 things due in the span of 4 days.

1635
black marker on notebook

December... it's full of finals, due dates, Mariah Carey, and the holidays. It's the worst time of the year, but the best because after finals, you get to not think about classes for a month and catch up on all the sleep you lost throughout the semester. But what's worse than finals week is the last week of classes, when all the due dates you've put off can no longer be put off anymore.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments