How Compatible Are Islam and Democracy? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics

How Compatible Are Islam and Democracy?

Many believe that Islam and democracy are inherently incompatible, but is this truly the case?

207
How Compatible Are Islam and Democracy?
Tea Party Tribune

Given the West's exposure to the Middle East over the past decade and a half, there has been a lot of dialogue over whether or not Islam is compatible with democracy. Many critics in the West decry the humans rights abuses and autocratic government of many gulf countries as the result of Islam's precepts. Additionally, they point to jihadist groups' hardline interpretation of Islam as additional proof of the incompatibility between Islam and democracy. However, they erroneously equate Islam as a whole and Islamic fundamentalism, and conclude that there is no place for Islam in democracy just as there is no place for democracy in Islam. I argue that Islam and Islamic fundamentalism are not the same, and that while Islamic fundamentalism is not compatible with democracy, Islam itself most certainly is.

Islam as a religion is founded on the Quran (the text of highest authority) followed by the Hadeeth (the text of second highest authority). How one interprets these texts however, is something that not all Muslims agree upon. Thus, when talking about Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), there are four Sunni schools thought (madhab), four Shia madhabs and one "other" madhab totaling for nine schools of thought within the entirety of Islam.

Just as there is a diversity of thought on jurisprudence, there is also a diversity of thought in the way Muslims interpret Islam in general. Some Muslims have a liberal interpretation and others have a more conservative interpretation of it. Within the conservative interpretation of Islam, there is a movement called the Salafist movement which is an ultra-conservative reform movement that calls for a fundamentalist approach to Islam. Salafists can be further divided into the politics-averse quietists, the politically vocal activists and the infamously violent jihadists. It is the fundamentalist groups like the Salafists that play a role in hindering democracy in the Middle East.

The problem with a fundamentalist approach to Islam is that they are not willing to accept innovation (or bida). They believe that all bida runs contrary to the Sacred Law put forth by Allah through Muhammad, and that a strict interpretation of the Quran and Sunna is the only correct way to go about practicing Islam. Because they do not accept innovation, they are unwilling to change their world view. In the political arena, this translates into far-right Islamist factions seeking to impose a seventh century ways of thinking in a 21st century world. While the West has advanced their way of of thinking about things such as governance and human rights, the fundamentalist factions have not, and therefore democracy just simply isn't in the vocabulary of a fundamentalist that thinks the way a seventh century Arabian would. Additionally, a key concept of democracy is compromise, and since Islamic fundamentalists are adamant in their religious convictions and unreceptive to compromise, they are therefore unable to function in a democracy. An autocratic way of governance is much easier for fundamentalism to thrive in because autocracy requires little compromise.

Conversely, interpretations of Islam that do support bida, are much more conducive to democracy because they are innovative and are more receptive to compromise. They are willing to change their thinking in a way that both recognizes, values and is overall compatible with democracy. Allowing innovation to be present in one's interpretation of Islam (or any religion) allows for comprise to be available, and that allows for a compatibility with democracy.

Let's take what I've written above and compare the cases of Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Turkey's Islamist faction, while Islamically oriented, is not one that is fundamentalist due to a variety of factors (namely the Turkish military's historical track record of keeping a tight leash on fundamentalism) and therefore is open to innovation and compromise and the existence of a democratic form of governance. Saudi Arabia, on the other hand, is led by a kingship that has had a history of cooperation with Islamic clerics that subscribe to a fundamentalist movement called Wahhabism. By supporting the Wahhabi establishment with the resources of the state, the Wahhabi establishment supports the king by stifling innovation and therefore any potential democratic movements that might emerge out of Islamic movements that are more receptive towards bida.

Bringing things full circle, Islam is in fact compatible with democracy, as is any other religion. What isn't compatible with democracy is a fundamentalist interpretation of a particular religion, because it promotes a provincial way of thinking by frowning upon innovation and has natural abhorrence towards compromise. By understanding the individual case of Islam and democracy, we can perhaps apply what we've learned to religion in general's compatibility with democracy and factor that into the calculus of the promotion of democracy abroad.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Kardashians
W Magazine

Whether you love them or hate them, it's undeniable the Kardashian/ Jenner family has built an enormous business empire. Ranging from apps, fashion lines, boutiques, beauty products, books, television shows, etc. this bunch has shown they are insane business moguls. Here are seven reasons why the Kardashian/ Jenner family should be applauded for their intelligent business tactics.

Keep Reading...Show less
friends
Photo by Elizeu Dias on Unsplash

If I have learned one thing in my lifetime, it is that friends are a privilege. No one is required to give you their company and yet there is some sort of shared connection that keeps you together. And from that friendship, you may even find yourself lucky enough to have a few more friends, thus forming a group. Here are just a few signs that prove your current friend group is the ultimate friend group.

Keep Reading...Show less
ross and monica
FanPop

When it comes to television, there’s very few sets of on-screen siblings that a lot of us can relate to. Only those who have grown up with siblings knows what it feels like to fight, prank, and love a sibling. Ross and Monica Geller were definitely overbearing and overshared some things through the series of "Friends," but they captured perfectly what real siblings feel in real life. Some of their antics were funny, some were a little weird but all of them are completely relatable to brothers and sisters everywhere.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

11 Types Of Sorority Girls

Who really makes up your chapter...

3932
Sorority Girls
Owl Eyes Magazine

College is a great place to meet people, especially through Greek life. If you look closely at sororities, you'll quickly see there are many different types of girls you will meet.

1. The Legacy.

Her sister was a member, her mom was a member, all of her aunts were members, and her grandma was a member. She has been waiting her whole life to wear these letters and cried hysterically on bid day. Although she can act entitled at times, you can bet she is one of the most enthusiastic sisters.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

10 Reasons Why Life Is Better In The Summertime

Winter blues got you down? Summer is just around the corner!

3465
coconut tree near shore within mountain range
Photo by Elizeu Dias on Unsplash

Every kid in college and/or high school dreams of summer the moment they walk through the door on the first day back in September. It becomes harder and harder to focus in classes and while doing assignments as the days get closer. The winter has been lagging, the days are short and dark, and no one is quite themselves due to lack of energy and sunlight. Let's face it: life is ten times better in the summertime.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments