Is Celebrating Thanksgiving Just As Bad As Celebrating Columbus Day? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Student Life

Is Celebrating Thanksgiving Just As Bad As Celebrating Columbus Day?

What Thanksgiving represents to some Native Americans may make you want to reconsider celebrating it.

2815
Is Celebrating Thanksgiving Just As Bad As Celebrating Columbus Day?
Wiki Commons

To Start off, the fact that we are still honoring a man who was a murderer, but is falsely taught in grade school as a hero who so-called "discovered" America by making the day of his arrival into a federal holiday is just ridiculous to me. It's 2017 going on 2018, and I'm sure a majority of Americans know the truth about Christopher Columbus. With this being so, the fact that Columbus still has his own holiday is beyond me! I'm now starting to wonder if celebrating Thanksgiving is like celebrating Columbus Day?

Don't get me wrong, I love Thanksgiving and celebrating it.

However, after reading an article from Independent.co.uk about how Native Americans feel about Thanksgiving and the American traditions makes me wonder if we should stop celebrating Thanksgiving the way we have been. A video embedded in the article is of Native Americans explaining what this holiday means to them. Most of the opinions are negative. Words such as lies, slaughter, and massacre were used by many of the volunteers as a way to describe the holiday. Columbus is linked to Thanksgiving so anything that he is connected to must be negative, right?

I was taught in school that Thanksgiving is a day for giving thanks. The pilgrims and Wampanoag Native Americans shared in a feast together in celebration of the pilgrims having a successful harvest. The feast was a way for the Pilgrims to thank the Native Americans for their help. What I later learned was that a feast between the pilgrims and this Native American tribe did occur, but it wasn't as friendly as I was taught for it to have been.

According to News.nationalgeographic.com, a year before the "first" Thanksgiving, the pilgrims robbed corn from Native American graves and storehouses in a desperate attempt to survive. The so-called peace that led to the first Thanksgiving was also just driven by trade and tribal rivalries. Let's also not forget about the thousands of Native Americans being killed by a disease that was brought over by the pilgrims.

Richard Schiffman stated in one of his articles from theHuffingtonPostthat, "A Thanksgiving which ignores the systematic destruction of Indian cultures which followed hot on the heels of the Plymouth feast not only does a disservice to indigenous peoples, it falsifies our understanding of ourselves and our history."

For some, Thanksgiving is the national day for giving thanks, but we have to remember that for others it's the"national day of mourning." While many of us will be with our family and friends eating our very own feasts on this day, we must also remember the actual history behind Thanksgiving, and what it really represents.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
two women enjoying confetti

Summer: a time (usually) free from school work and a time to relax with your friends and family. Maybe you go on a vacation or maybe you work all summer, but the time off really does help. When you're in college you become super close with so many people it's hard to think that you won't see many of them for three months. But, then you get that text saying, "Hey, clear your schedule next weekend, I'm coming up" and you begin to flip out. Here are the emotions you go through as your best friend makes her trip to your house.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Syllabus Week As Told By Kourtney Kardashian

Feeling Lost During Syllabus Week? You're Not Alone!

482
Kourtney Kardashian

Winter break is over, we're all back at our respective colleges, and the first week of classes is underway. This is a little bit how that week tends to go.

The professor starts to go over something more than the syllabus

You get homework assigned on the first day of class

There are multiple group projects on the syllabus

You learn attendance is mandatory and will be taken every class

Professor starts chatting about their personal life and what inspired them to teach this class

Participation is mandatory and you have to play "icebreaker games"

Everybody is going out because its 'syllabus week' but you're laying in bed watching Grey's Anatomy

Looking outside anytime past 8 PM every night of this week

Nobody actually has any idea what's happening this entire week

Syllabus week is over and you realize you actually have to try now...or not

Now it's time to get back into the REAL swing of things. Second semester is really here and we all have to deal with it.

panera bread

Whether you specialized in ringing people up or preparing the food, if you worked at Panera Bread it holds a special place in your heart. Here are some signs that you worked at Panera in high school.

1. You own so many pairs of khaki pants you don’t even know what to do with them

Definitely the worst part about working at Panera was the uniform and having someone cute come in. Please don’t look at me in my hat.

Keep Reading...Show less
Drake
Hypetrak

1. Nails done hair done everything did / Oh you fancy huh

You're pretty much feeling yourself. New haircut, clothes, shoes, everything. New year, new you, right? You're ready for this semester to kick off.

Keep Reading...Show less
7 Ways to Make Your Language More Transgender and Nonbinary Inclusive

With more people becoming aware of transgender and non-binary people, there have been a lot of questions circulating online and elsewhere about how to be more inclusive. Language is very important in making a space safer for trans and non-binary individuals. With language, there is an established and built-in measure of whether a place could be safe or unsafe. If the wrong language is used, the place is unsafe and shows a lack of education on trans and non-binary issues. With the right language and education, there can be more safe spaces for trans and non-binary people to exist without feeling the need to hide their identities or feel threatened for merely existing.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments