This Is How NOT To Argue About Abortion | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics

This Is How NOT To Argue About Abortion

Clearing the path for thinking about the abortion controversy.

228
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/99/Human_fetus_10_weeks_-_therapeutic_abortion.jpg

I was searching today on the main Odyssey homepage using the word "abortion" to see what pieces had been written on the topic. Even though I did not find many that actually offered a defense of abortion or a critique of pro-life arguments, the ones I did discover had certain valuable nuggets of truth but left me with a glaring impression. I am honestly curious as to whether most undergrad students in secular schools are aware of more sophisticated pro-choice authors, such as "A Defense of Abortion" by David Boonin or "Abortion and Infanticide" by Michael Tooley, as well as pro-life critics, including "The Ethics of Abortion" by Christopher Kaczor and "Defending Life" by Francis Beckwith – or if these students' knowledge doesn't surpass what they have heard from their classrooms or on social media.

I am not here today to defend the position that abortion is immoral, but I will attempt to set the record straight on what is not at stake in this issue. So here we go.

First, abortion is not an issue of science vs. religion. It is sometimes claimed that opposition to abortion can only come from a faith-based perspective but not from a "scientific" one. One possible reason given is that a religiously motivated opposition to abortion is primarily based on a commitment to a sacred text and nothing more. It basically amounts to the idea that a Christian, Jew, or Muslim can only find their "support" for being opposed to abortion because that's what their sacred texts teach. On the other hand, we're told, those who hold to "science" will support abortion rights and have good reason to because that's where "reason" is. What does a pro-choice advocate have? Reason. What does the pro-lifer have? Faith.

This is misguided for two reasons. One, science cannot tell us whether we should value the unborn over pigs. The claim that a creature is valuable because it can feel pain or pleasure (sentient) might have some scientific basis, but it is not a purely scientific inference. It is both a metaphysical and ethical conclusion that one draws. The pro-choice advocate wants to draw a line between the unborn and newborn and say we can protect the newborn but not the unborn, despite the fact that both are members of the human species. What makes the newborn valuable enough for a right to life but not the unborn? Science will not do all the work.

Second, this is really a debate over different ways of understanding what a human is. You can define a human primarily in reference to his or her mental states (consciousness, self-awareness, rationality, relationality, etc.) or to having a certain kind of nature. Pro-lifers typically – though not always – will appeal to the latter. But this is nothing religious. It is something that could be easily recognized by an atheist.

The last thing I want to draw on here is an issue of inconsistency. It is not uncommon for someone to defend the right to an abortion and to land-blast a pro-life advocate for "imposing" his or her values on others while simultaneously saying that it's wrong to impose one's moral views on others. I am talking about ethical relativism. In one sense, this says that each person defines what is morally right and wrong and cannot be subjected to any other outside moral views about right and wrong. If that is true, then no right to abortion can be defended. Why? Because to say that a woman has a right to an abortion is also to say that it is morally wrong for her to be hindered in seeking out one. But this is to impose the pro-choice's morality on the pro-lifer which is *exactly* what the relativist says we *cannot* do!

I make no claim in saying that there aren't any good arguments for abortion. I just know that the ones I just talked about are not. Get yourself educated and don't make elementary logic mistakes.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Entertainment

Disney magic for New Year!

The "Happiest Place on Earth" has a lot of characters with some pretty great advice.

4994
Disney magic kingdom castle on new years
StableDiffusion

Disney movies are well known and very popular in today's world. Although many people appreciate the plot and the storyline, not many people appreciate the wisdom these characters possess. Every Disney movie has unique advice that can be applied to everyday life. Here are 11 Disney quotes to help start your New Year off right:

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

40 Gift Ideas for the Indecisive

It's a time of love, family, memory-making, and gift-giving. But also a time of stressing over the perfect gift.

119279
Christmas gifts around a tree
StableDiffusion

It's officially December. There is less than a month of 2024, and I still feel like yesterday was summer. Now comes the merriest time of the year, the Christmas season.

Everyone has been waiting for this time of year since mid-October (which is way too early, in my opinion) or before. It's a time of love, family, memory-making, and gift-giving. A lot of times when I ask friends and family what they want, I get a lot of "I don't know" or "I don't care."

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

Bucket List To Live In The Now

Find excitement in your life and start exploring wherever you are right here, right now.

1189
mu bucket list

I was sitting at my cubicle, now that I am an adult, looking at the rain pouring down on the windowsill, bumming on life, wishing for the rain to just stop for a full day.

There are moments where we count down the hours until work is over and how many more days till the weekend, and this many weeks until something exciting. Or something like that? Well, I was bumming because my next day off from work is not until Memorial Day weekend, which is not until the end of May. And since this is my first year out of college being a “real person,” I am totally missing the winter, spring and summer breaks. I am sure all of us have felt this way even if just for a hot minute…

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

11 Ways To Survive Finals As Told By Leslie Knope

Because you know you're going to be stressed out, and Leslie knows exactly how to survive.

853
Everything hurts and I'm dying

So finals are on their way. That's right everybody, finals are about to start.

But hey, don't panic. Start getting your affairs in order and prepare for a week of hell. Here's a few things Leslie Knope wants you to do to make your finals week just a little bit less stressful:

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

10 Signs You Go To Kent State

You know you're a true Kent Stater when...

914
Kent State University
Great Value Colleges

If you go to or went to Kent State, then more than likely you have done or will do some of these things.

1. You’ve slipped and fallen on the ice at least once.

The winters at Kent are brutal, and while the heated sidewalks and some great snow boots are always a help, there’s no chance you won’t bust it on the ice at least once in your four plus years at school.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments