'Harriet' Biopic Falls Flat | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

'Harriet' Biopic Falls Flat

A mediocre film adaptation for a national icon.

21
'Harriet' Biopic Falls Flat
https://cdn3.movieweb.com/i/article/BgCVImoeEJSk6IApw7Y9UPU31ZTziN/798:75/Harriet-Movie-Review-2019.jpg

Shallow, conventional, and uninspired.

These are the three words that came to my mind as the credits of Kasi Lemmons' Harriet rolled out onto the screen.

While not out-and-out "bad," and certainly entertaining, at the same time this failed fishing attempt for an Oscar denies Harriet Tubman that nuance and grace that her incredible life story deserves. This is a film without subtlety. And that is not to say that it is bold, which could be misconstrued as a compliment, but rather blunt, obvious, and one dimensional.

If you'd like to plop down on the couch and be blasted with a feel-good adventure and quasi-religious narrative where you won't have to think too hard, this is the movie for you. Shallow, uncomplicated, and formulaic. There's no shame in that. There are huge markets for these kinds of films, and at the end of the day, one of the biggest engines of the film industry is pure profit. Not everything thrown up onto the big screen has to be art.

In fact, if the film had been marketed as such and passed off as the uncomplicated, predictable one-woman heroine flick that it is, perhaps I would be speaking about the film more kindly. Unfortunately, the marketing for the film made it look like some heavy, sprawling thriller with high drama and a powerful action engine.

Instead, the Harriet that we received was flat in its action, deflated in its drama, and far less powerful a delivery of the tale of the woman called Moses than what said figure rightfully deserves. Perhaps that's my biggest gripe with the movie: that is gives this treatment to a story as epic, dramatic, and socially relevant as Harriet Tubman. As a teen and young adult, her story of escape and salvation is Joan of Arc-esque. As a woman, her legacy of military prowess is righteous but brittled by the horrors of the Civil War. As a grandmother, her legacy of heroism is a bright streak against a backdrop of continued racism and civil slaughter against her race.

There were a million different ways this movie could have been made. Give us that action-packed, high drama thriller we were promised of a young Harriet, religious inspiration and all. Give us a dark, gritty espionage and battle film of Tubman leading her brigade against the tyranny, complication, and tragedy of an enemy army comprised of foolish, ignorant young men unwittingly perpetuating a legacy of evil. Give us an old Tubman, Lincoln-esque, in a deep drama wherein the aging war-hero and national icon reflects on the terror, pain, and beauty of her life and the legacy she will leave behind.

Had you given any of us these, critics of the film would have treated it far more kindly. That being said, this film doesn't deserve hate of any kind. It's a mediocre movie that squandered an incredible collection of source material. That's all. These kinds of flops and disappointments are a dime a dozen. It doesn't deserve praise or hatred. Rather, it has well earned its mid-50s to 60s range of critical reception, with an understandably higher viewer satisfaction rating.

Keeping in mind leading actress Cynthia Erivo's inspired take on Harriet Tubman, as well as Janelle Monáe's ever-beautiful musical accompaniment (which I believe did win an Oscar for best original song), the film still summarily comes off as entirely mediocre. It's fine, I suppose, and has stirred up some necessary dialogue about filmic representation of blackness and black legacy.

However, the film itself, looking at it for its own merit and what it earns solely on its own account, hardly deserves the long and important discussions that it has helped to stir up. With that in mind, I'll keep this review as short and sweet as this one-note feel-good film itself deserves and leave you with a final send-off verdict: meh. I

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Adulting

The Struggles of Being A Last Semester Senior, As Told By Michael Scott

25 reasons your last semester in college is the best and worst time of your life

676
Michael Scott

The day you walked onto your school's campus for the first time you were scared, excited, and unsure of how the next four years of your life were going to turn out. You doubted it would go fast and even though you weren't positive about what your future plans would hold, you had plenty of time. You figured out your major, added a minor or two, joined a handful of organizations and all of the sudden you're here. Your final semester of undergrad. Now you've got 25 problems and graduation is only one.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Syllabus Week At UD Explained By "The Office"

"The Office" understands the struggle of the first week back from winter break.

619
the office

January 19th is the first day of the second semester at the University of Dayton, and students couldn't be more excited. However, the excitement that students are experiencing may be short-lived once they see what this semester's courses will entail. Although students will be happy to be back at Dayton, they may realize this semester will be more difficult than they predicted. Here are some things that happen during syllabus week explained by " The Office."

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

Your Friend Group, As Told By Disney Princesses

Each Disney Princess has their own personality, and chances are you've got a friend in your group to match it.

1164
Disney Princesses

The dynamics of any friend group are usually determined by the personalities which make it up. Chances are, while personalities may overlap, each person in your friend group holds his or her own place. It is the differences which bring the groups together and keep them functioning. No matter how functionally dysfunctional your friend group may be, if you're anything like me, you feel absolutely blessed to have found such a wonderful group of humans to call "your people." Here is what your friend group might look like if they were Disney princesses (and that wasn't just a thing you all pretended in your heads):

Keep Reading...Show less
dorm roon
Tumblr

College is a place where you spend four years exploring opportunities you never knew were there, creating the person you are, and making life-long friends. College is hard, but it is worth spending four years there. Just because college is difficult doesn't mean that it's not fun. There are plenty of great memories you can make during your four years if college. Here are ways college is designed to be the best four years of your life:

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

You Know You Go To The Ilstu When...

If you are an ISU student, you will come across most of these things during your time on campus.

83
You Know You Go To The Ilstu When...
Community Link

When it comes to Bloomington-Normal, there are many outstanding factors that any Illinois State student can say are unique to our college town (and maybe others too). Proud or not, we Redbirds know all the ins and outs of Blono.

1. The wait for Buffalo Wild Wings is always going to be long on Thursday nights.

As hard as we try, it's nearly impossible to resist the 69-cent wings on a college student budget. Plus, they are always delicious!

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments