Is "Hamiliton" Racist? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

Is "Hamiliton" Racist?

What responses to a "nonwhite" casting call say about diversity on Broadway.

46
Is "Hamiliton" Racist?
BBC

After going to New York and seeing the hundreds of people flooding the street, desperate to get a simple ticket to the new smash hit musical, "Hamilton,"I never believed that it could spur any type of controversy. But of course, outrage was sparked. And whom was it sparked by? White people.

On Thursday, the musical posted an open casting call seeking specifically "nonwhite" men and women. Immediately, people struck back claiming that they were being discriminated against because of their skin color.

Oddly enough, this was the same musical that was widely praised for its diversified casting when it opened late last year. However now, when the so called "discrimination" affects those interested in being in the show, cries are being voiced. And heard. The casting notice was changed by the next day the Actor's Equity who changed the open call to include all ethnicities, stating, "Our audition rules are created to provide the broadest access possible for our members to be seen for roles."

Yet, one only has to look at the history of musical theater to see that white discrimination is minimal, if not nonexistent. The majority of musicals created in the Golden Age (pre-1960s), featured a predominately white cast. Many of them are set in historical time periods in which, to maintain complete historical accuracy, a fully white cast is needed (i.e. "The Sound of Music," "My Fair Lady," "1776,"etc.). And while new productions of these musicals use a term called "colorblind casting," it is an easily proven fact that musical theater contain a large multitude of parts for the white actor.

"Colorblind casting" refers to casting directors disregarding skin color when casting their shows. This allows more diversity in the predominately white Golden Age musicals and an ignorance of historical accuracy of the time period depicted in the musical.

But what is amazing about "Hamilton" is that it steps outside of the traditional definition of "colorblind casting" and holds to their insistence of a complete nonwhite cast (excluding, of course, King George). Lin-Manuel Miranda, the creator of the show, had a vision of diversity that represented the American public. As Hamilton himself was an immigrant, why shouldn't a show about him feature all races that built this great nation?

When comparing the ratio of "African-American musicals" to the rest of musical theater, you can notice a huge gap. There are only about 20 musicals in the 100+ years of musical theater that feature a predominately or fully black cast. And with white people purchasing an astounding 76 percent of tickets to musicals, according to Broadway's revenue numbers, diversity is needed to show support and awareness of the other races that make up our nation.

While "Hamilton" has received much acclaim and mainstream support, there is a current rise of African-American musicals on Broadway. Jennifer Hudson stars in "The Color Purple," "The Wiz" is returning to Broadway in the next few months and "Shuffle Along" is currently in previews. "Shuffle Along" is both a revival and an original musical. It presents the 1921 musical hailed by many as the "first successful African-American musical," as well as the history of the show and the struggles it faced as they made their journey to Broadway.

But when 30+ shows open on Broadway every year, having only three with nonwhite casts, is still not a huge step in diversity. What "Hamilton" and "The Color Purple"and "Shuffle Along" are doing is amazing, but diversity in musical theater cannot flourish if nonwhite casting choices are being fought by those with thousands of other opportunities.

Theater should be a community of support, and it is incredibly saddening when this community cannot band together to praise and encourage diversity.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
retail
Chor Ip / Flickr

I'm sure, like me, many of you received lots of gift cards over the holidays. After working retail seasonally, here are a few tips that I learned in order to make the employees at your favorite store just a little happier and not want to charge you extra on your purchase for being awful. Here are some times when you should be nicer to retail workers than you actually are!

Keep Reading...Show less
5 Untold Struggles Of The Short Friend

I'm the Short Friend. I've been the Short Friend since about the seventh grade. I'm the one who stands in the front of the photos, gets made fun of for their height, and still shops in the kids department.

This article is not for the Almost Short Friends, i.e. the 5'3" and 5'4" Friends. No no, this is for the Actually Short Friends, i.e. the Barely Scraping 5'1" and shorter Short Friends.

Keep Reading...Show less
fall
Pixabay

Myers/Briggs personalty types are a common psychological assessment that has gone mainstream in recent years and most people know theirs.

If you don’t, check it out

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

12 Thoughts You Have When You're Late to Your 9 AM (Again)

It's a daily struggle to make it on time, but everyone has those days where they just...don't.

1027
man running down on desert

You tried your best to avoid it, but that one statistics class that you need to take in order to graduate was only offered at 9 AM. Sound familiar? Now it's a daily struggle to make it on time, but everyone has those days where they just...don't. If that sounds relatable, then you may have experienced some (or all) of these thoughts.

Keep Reading...Show less
11 Things All Call Center Workers Can Empathize With Better Than Anyone
Youtube

This semester I started my journey as a member of my University's Alumni Outreach Team. This means a lot of things, but primarily it means that I get to make phone calls to parents and alumni two nights a week to update contact information, collect things like business cards and volunteer hours, and even ask for money.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments