The Trouble with Genres | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

The Trouble with Genres

Why is literary fiction supposedly better then genre fiction?

108
The Trouble with Genres
Mercy Home for Boys and Girls

I am a lover of books. While initially obsessed with encyclopedias and atlases(honestly, in my earliest years I would read anything), what introduced me to the wonderful world of fiction was Eragon. Afterwards I was hooked, devouring volume after volume of The Mortal Instruments, Isaac Asimov's Foundation, Discworld, and, with only mild regret, Twilight. These stories capture my mind and inspire my creative spirit, and I hope I can one day write a novel that inspires others in the same way. Unfortunately, to some, this means I will never be a real writer.

One major divide in the writing community is between "literary fiction" and "genre fiction", where genre is often considered to be more "vulgar" or "worse" than literary. Genre fiction encapsulates all the stories and novels that share particular groups of concepts or trappings, e.g. science fiction, fantasy, westerns, thrillers, romances, etc. Literary fiction is...well, it's hard to generalize. For instance, I just read this one book, Anywhere But Here by Mona Simpson on my creative writing professor and major advisor's recommendation. It's about this girl, Ann, and her mother Adele who move from Wisconsin to California to become famous and marry up because...I'm not entirely certain. Don't get me wrong, it is quite well written, I can get a strong sense of character and setting and how the different narrators are feeling, but it's hard for me to follow what's happening. The multiple points-of-view and nonlinearity don't help. (Ultimately this is a compliment; this book is so socially realistic, my autism makes it hard to understand.)

I guess if I had to condense what makes literary fiction "literary", it's that emotional depth and focus on the craft of writing. Which, apparently, is mutually exclusive from any sort of definable genre: I doubt mine is the only writing class that levied a ban on "genre fiction" in assignments (which in my writing professor's eyes is science fiction/fantasy, and supernatural horror, judging from comments and what I submitted without complaint). Whose to say that genre can't be skillfully written? Things like Brave New World and 1984, dystopian fiction, Slaughterhouse-Five, about a World War 2 veteran who supposedly time-travels and lives in an alien zoo, and fable-like allegories like Lord of the Flies and Animal Farm are all held as literary classics. One thing that genre certainly does better than literary fiction is tell a good story. Take for instance, Heinlein's The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. Sure, Heinlein is sexist as hell(but, surprisingly sexually liberal), and you don't really get to understand the characters like in a literary book , but it tells a well-paced, thrilling tale of revolution on the Moon. Honestly, the stories are why I read books in the first place.

Why can't you do both; write a good, well-plotted story and explore the characters at the same time? For instance, take Margaret Atwood. I first discovered her as one of the few names I recognized on a list of approved poets in my high school creative writing class. While the author presentations we were supposed to use the list for never materialized, I read a lot of her that semester. While her poems were very well written, producing images and feelings with a scant selection of words, the more memorable work of hers I read, and the one that should be most familiar to most, was The Handmaid's Tale. For those of you who haven't been binge-watching the Hulu series, the book is about Offred, a woman forced into sexual slavery in a dystopic, fundamentalist United States. Atwood uses her skill with language to paint a horrific yet enthralling image of this world, although coming to a strange conclusion. While most dystopian novels are often lumped under the science fiction genre, Atwood considers The Handmaid's Tale and her other similar books as "speculative fiction", as science fiction is full of "talking squids in outer space". Of course, not everyone uses these labels; The Handmaid's Tale won the first ever Arthur C. Clarke Award, a prestigious award in the field of science fiction.

I want to write the way Atwood writes. Call it speculative fiction, call it magical realism, call it whatever you like: I want to explore the relationship between a boy and his immortal wizard father. I want to show the slow realization by the executives that their company is secretly run by an eldritch monster slowly killing the planet, and the effect that has on day-to-day operations. I want to write about a gay AI who has to persuade an mentally-damaged hacker to destroy his fascist videogame. Sure, it's not realistic fiction. But honestly, reality is boring.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Drake
Hypetrak

1. Nails done hair done everything did / Oh you fancy huh

You're pretty much feeling yourself. New haircut, clothes, shoes, everything. New year, new you, right? You're ready for this semester to kick off.

Keep Reading...Show less
7 Ways to Make Your Language More Transgender and Nonbinary Inclusive

With more people becoming aware of transgender and non-binary people, there have been a lot of questions circulating online and elsewhere about how to be more inclusive. Language is very important in making a space safer for trans and non-binary individuals. With language, there is an established and built-in measure of whether a place could be safe or unsafe. If the wrong language is used, the place is unsafe and shows a lack of education on trans and non-binary issues. With the right language and education, there can be more safe spaces for trans and non-binary people to exist without feeling the need to hide their identities or feel threatened for merely existing.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf
Stop Hollywood

For those of you who have watched "Gossip Girl" before (and maybe more than just once), you know how important of a character Blair Waldorf is. Without Blair, the show doesn’t have any substance, scheme, or drama. Although the beginning of the show started off with Blair’s best friend Serena returning from boarding school, there just simply is no plot without Blair. With that being said, Blair’s presence in the show in much more complex than that. Her independent and go-getter ways have set an example for "Gossip Girl" fans since the show started and has not ended even years after the show ended. Blair never needed another person to define who she was and she certainly didn’t need a man to do that for her. When she envisioned a goal, she sought after it, and took it. This is why Blair’s demeanor encompasses strong women like her.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

20 Feelings Anyone Who Loves To Sing Has

Sometimes, we just can't help the feelings we have

1119
singing
Cambio

Singing is something I do all day, every day. It doesn't matter where I am or who's around. If I feel like singing, I'm going to. It's probably annoying sometimes, but I don't care -- I love to sing! If I'm not singing, I'm probably humming, sometimes without even realizing it. So as someone who loves to sing, these are some of the feelings and thoughts I have probably almost every day.

Keep Reading...Show less
success
Degrassi.Wikia

Being a college student is one of the most difficult task known to man. Being able to balance your school life, work life and even a social life is a task of greatness. Here's an ode to some of the small victories that mean a lot to us college students.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments