I Don't Care About His Record | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

I Don't Care About His Record

When someone dies without a trial, we don't become the jury.

78
I Don't Care About His Record
Philando Castile

An interesting thing often happens after a person of color dies at the hands of law enforcement. It's a trend we've seen many times in the past few years: suddenly, every single prior criminal charge or infraction, every arrest or police stop, major or minuscule, becomes the first thing people want to know about the victim.

It's hard to believe it's a coincidence, first of all, that black victims are slandered on social media and presented to the public as mug shots and criminal records while convicted criminals who are white are represented with images of them at their most photogenic:

But let's put that aside for the moment.

Let's ask ourselves when and why it became our "duty" to investigate victims of police violence. Let's ask ourselves why we think we can determine someone deserving of extrajudicial execution by law enforcement officers when the victims never even got a trial. Let's ask ourselves why those officers can act as judge, jury and executioner and be put on paid leave while grieving families are left to pay funeral costs for their loved ones who allegedly committed misdemeanors such as resisting arrest, for example.

This extreme interest in black and brown victims' possible criminality after they are killed suggests a number of things. It suggests we do not want to feel grief, but instead want a reason to feel happy that this person is dead.

It suggests we believe police are an infallible authority on justice; that they always use the appropriate amount of force and enforce the law equally and have perfect, unquestionable judgement and an inability to make mistakes. It suggests we believe police exist outside of due process, are above the law, even though all people are capable of breaking laws (and it is unfortunate that it can take a suicide note to reveal that the police are capable of admitting to it. However, many officers who speak out against unjust policing are punished for it).

It suggests that we are less interested in the stories their loved ones share of the good things they did in their lives, and the people who loved and treasured them, than we are in the accounts of the law enforcement officers who did not have relationships with them, but were so afraid of them that they had to be killed. But why are they so afraid?

Even fellow law enforcement officer Nakia Jones questioned this in a viral video.

The problem being discussed shouldn't have to be reasons why black and brown people are scary or criminal. Their appearance, mood and past are not responsible for their deaths in fatal police encounters if they are being stopped for broken lights, legally carrying licensed weapons, selling CDs, etc. Fear and suspicion of dark-skinned people carries the suggestion that they are inherently more violent, aggressive, selfish and criminal. That is racism.

All people should be allowed to have flaws and live, yet respectability politics continue to dominate discussions around police violence toward people of color. Police tell children that there are disproportionate and fatal consequences to not being perfectly compliant or showing unpleasant manners during police stops, when in reality, that is not actually how the law is written to work. If it is so easy for police to abuse the system, we cannot act as though it is difficult to believe that sometimes they do.

When we know that racism is alive and well all over our country, shaping the way we look at one another, we cannot insist that it doesn't affect members of law enforcement. But introspection is not the only evidence we have that suggests that.

The ASA, Leadership Project,Human Rights Watch, US Sentencing Commission, ProPublica, American Civil Liberties Union,Ohio State University,Bureau of Justice Statistics and many other organizations and institutions offer thorough evidence that racial profiling is absolutely real. So why, after subjecting darker skinned communities to harsher policing and higher rates of arrest and criminalization, do we insist that the most important thing to know about black and brown people is all the times they have been arrested and charged?

Philando Castile was not only initially pulled over for his "wide nose," basing his police encounter on his physical appearance, he was then subjected to the classic "dig up his criminal record so we can justify his death" treatment after he was shot to death by law enforcement. But what it also revealed was what the above studies also showed: as a black man, he was living under constant police attention.

So, what I'm really trying to say is this: I don't care about his record. I don't care about Alton Sterling's record. I don't care about Eric Garner's record. I don't care about Michael Brown's record. I care about addressing the biases that make the world more deadly and the system more harsh to people of color.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
one tree hill
Wikipedia Commons

If you need a new series to watch, I recommend One Tree Hill. I watched this series three times now and it only keeps getting better. If you need any more reasons beside the fact that all of the seasons are on Netflix for your binge-watching pleasure, here are seven more reasons to watch it.

Keep Reading...Show less
University of Mount Olive
University of Mount Olive

College is the most exciting time of a person's life. It really is. Exciting is not always a positive feeling though. Excited is a feeling that can be associated with nervousness, anxiety and more. Here are some real tips for college freshman that go beyond the typical, "Go to class," lecture.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

The 5 Pros and Cons Of Long Distance Friendships

Being friends with someone thousands of miles away has its drawbacks and perks.

1149
friends on the beach

True friendship is incredibly rare, and to find a friend that will be there for you through all of life's curveballs is something quite unique. To add distance into the equation, maintaining a real, true friendship can be a struggle. There are good and bad parts that come with long distance friendship.

Keep Reading...Show less
high school girls
Tori Horne

Friendship. It's defined as the state of being attached to another person by feelings of affection or personal regard, but what really is friendship? Is it that occasional hallway talk with that one person who always manages to cheer you up? Is it that relationship you have with someone where they can be gone for a long period of time, but when they come back, it's like they never left? Is it spending every waking hour with someone, and knowing every detail about their life? Is it the relationship that's filled with fighting, but filled with even more resolution? I've learned that it's all of these things, and every friendship is different. It's a beautifully dysfunctional mess that should always be cherished and never be taken for granted.

Keep Reading...Show less
cousins
Bailey Totten

I've known you your entire life. More than likely I held you in the first three days of it and at least one of us cried. Cousins are truly one of the best things in the world and while sometimes I complain about how many people crowd Grandma's living room on Christmas Eve, I wouldn't trade you all anything.

You are my best friends, the only people who can understand what it's like on Thanksgiving, and you are the spunkiest people I have ever met. But you as so so young, most of you are just now starting your adventures in the public education system. I mean, I'm so very young too. I'm not married, I don't have children, heck, I just started my adult life, but I do want to give you what little advice I have. My dears, these are the things I want you to know.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments