Disabled Or Dominant? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Sports

Disabled Or Dominant?

Prosthetics on athletes change the game

40
Disabled Or Dominant?
Business Insider

A jumper and sprinter are two professional athletes who have stirred up plenty of controversy for their success. They've won many competitions and bested world records, but they're both disabled. Normally, the disability would highlight their success despite adversity. The problem is that we've reached a point where prosthetics might give athletes an unfair advantage.

Markus Rehm and Oscar Pistorius are both famous for their achievements, but perhaps more well known for achieving with prosthetics. They're exceptional athletes, but the question is whether they're exception for their prosthetics and, if so, should we make an exception for them?

An investigation into Oscar Pistorius — known as the "Blade Runner" because of his hooked prosthetic legs (pictured as the article's cover photo) — barred him from competing. On March 26, 2007, the IAAF (International Association of Athletics Federation) altered its rules to ban "any technical device that incorporates springs, wheels or any other element that provides a user with an advantage over another athlete not using such a device." This decision was followed by a series of scientific tests.

A professor of biomechanics, Dr. Peter Brüggemann, conducted two days of tests on Pistorius. The report stated his limbs used 25% less energy than natural legs and they required 30% less mechanical for lifting the body vertically. Dr. Brüggemann declared that Pistorius has "considerable advantages over athletes without prosthetic limbs who were tested by us. It was more than just a few percentage points. I did not expect it to be so clear."

That would appear to close the case permanently on Pistorius. If his legs do give him a considerable advantage, how can he compete fairly with natural runners? Nevertheless, the decision to ban him was eventually revoked. Further testing and persistent advocating allowed Pistorius to overturn the doctor's findings. Other tests found that Pistorius' limbs did not give him a clear advantage and that if they did, Brüggemann's findings did not account for the unique conditions of a sprinting field or Pistorius' difficulty in starting and stopping.

Similarly, Marcus Rehm is an amazing disabled athlete. He's jumped further than the second longest record. Rehm's record best is 8.40 meters and Tomlinson's is 8.35. The world record is 8.31m. Rehm has also won a gold medal at the 2012 Summer Paralympics, in which he set a world record.

I want to focus more on Rehm because he's a fellow German and not a murderer. The IAAF also investigated Rehm's disability and declared him unfit for this year's Rio Olympics. The German Athletics Association stated: "'With respect to their actual legal situation Rehm will not be nominated by the German Olympic Association to compete in the Olympic Games."

Should Rehm be allowed to compete? Should Brüggemann's findings have been kept? These questions don't have easy answers and, as the technology continues to progress, the issue will only grow more complicated. Shows like "Superhuman" appeal to our interest in the underdog narrative: promising athlete loses limbs, overcomes hurdles of prosthetics, and excels.

It's great that prosthetics are improving, but the rate of progress requires further investigation into how we integrate mechanical parts into our sports.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Sorority
Rebekah Lee

I remember my freshman year oh so well. I remember feeling terrified the night before orientation. The one thing that I dreaded the most was not the new people, the new environment, or even the academic pressure. I was dreading having to talk to sorority girls about Recruitment. I remember cutting off and avoiding any Rho Gamma/Panhellenic Officer that came my way during First Week. I looked at them like they had asked me to cut my arm off whenever they asked me if I wanted to rush. To be honest, I did not even know what rush was, but I knew that I did NOT want to be a part of it. To me, it was dumb. It was a waste of money. It was a waste of my time.

And guess what? I did not rush my freshman year. I spent the first half of my freshman year isolating myself from everyone on campus. I spent all of my time in the library, and then (since I was a commuter) went back home once my work was finished.

Keep Reading...Show less
10 Must Watch Shows During Winter Break
Netflix

Now that the semester is over, you are probably wondering what your purpose of life is beside writing essays and constantly studying. Breaks give you time for some rest and relaxation, and what better way to relax than cuddling with some hot cocoa and some Netflix. Here is a list compiled of shows that must make it into your binge watching sessions, with the website in which you can find it. Enjoy!

Keep Reading...Show less
Disney Princesses
The Odyssey
Tiana would no doubt be disappointed in the food our cafeteria has to offer.

And hopefully she would cook for everyone in her dorm.

She definitley would not take any 8:00 am classes because she would be up late baking and cleaning up the communal kitchen that are available in every dorm.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

The Struggles of Being A Last Semester Senior, As Told By Michael Scott

25 reasons your last semester in college is the best and worst time of your life

1547
Michael Scott

The day you walked onto your school's campus for the first time you were scared, excited, and unsure of how the next four years of your life were going to turn out. You doubted it would go fast and even though you weren't positive about what your future plans would hold, you had plenty of time. You figured out your major, added a minor or two, joined a handful of organizations and all of the sudden you're here. Your final semester of undergrad. Now you've got 25 problems and graduation is only one.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Syllabus Week At UD Explained By "The Office"

"The Office" understands the struggle of the first week back from winter break.

1214
the office

January 19th is the first day of the second semester at the University of Dayton, and students couldn't be more excited. However, the excitement that students are experiencing may be short-lived once they see what this semester's courses will entail. Although students will be happy to be back at Dayton, they may realize this semester will be more difficult than they predicted. Here are some things that happen during syllabus week explained by " The Office."

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments