DEMOLISHING THE CINEMATIC ICEBERG ARGUMENT
Start writing a post
Entertainment

DEMOLISHING THE CINEMATIC ICEBERG ARGUMENT

A brief list outlining twenty arguments against the following invalid phrase: the book is better than the film.

44
DEMOLISHING THE CINEMATIC ICEBERG ARGUMENT
phendvrlistscom

The iceberg argument is a poor excuse for film criticism because it illustrates the speaker's ineptitude for appreciating films as works of art.

I have no tolerance for the following statement: the book/source material is better than the movie. This is commonly referred to as the iceberg argument, which implies that films are mere "snapshots" of a novel's complexity or greatness.

The following list contains many reasons why this statement is invalid and my goal is that by the end of this list, you too will agree to never utter such a phrase again.

Notice: obviously, there are exceptions to some of the following arguments yet despite this, I have, to the best of my ability, crafted each argument with the intention of addressing specific, often outlandish arguments stemming from the iceberg argument.

1. You cannot compare apples and oranges, books to films, because each part is a unique art in and of itself.

2. Because each part is a unique art in and of itself, books possess qualities unique to books and films possess qualities and aesthetics unique to films that may or may not be found in both depending upon the book or film.

3. Interestingly enough, qualities often perceived to belong solely to books are commonly found in films as well: imagery, symbolism, personification, POV, dialect, and others.

4. Books were designed to be read sporadically, as often as one pleases or as sparingly as one pleases, while films must present an entire story, an entire world in one sitting, a fraction of the time it takes to read a book.

5. Focusing on symbolism: a criticism of a film for lacking symbolism is always invalid because of the accuser's lack of attention to detail within the context of a film.

6. Focusing on imagery: a criticism of a film for lacking imagery is always invalid because of the accuser's inability to comprehend a basic quality of film, the set.

7. Focusing on personification: a criticism of a film for lacking personification is always invalid because the ways in which a film can use personification are as numerous as a book's.

8. Focusing on POV: a criticism of a film for lacking POV is always invalid because of the accuser's inability to comprehend basic qualities of a film such as scene changes and camera angles.

9. More often than not, the iceberg argument is used to rationalize the accuser's initial perceptions of the film adaptation prior to actually seeing the film.

10. More often than not, the iceberg argument is used to somehow claim films are in someway inferior to books. According to that logic, paintings are inferior to photographs or vice versa.

11. More often than not, use of the iceberg argument illustrates the accuser's inability to analyze a film versus a book.

12. More often than not, use of the iceberg argument hints at a possible bias. (See argument 9)

13. More often than not, use of the iceberg argument hints at the accuser's inability or lack of will to appreciate different interpretations of source material.

14. More often than not, use of the iceberg argument is intended to justify simple opinions rather than hard evidence (which can include deliberate inconsistencies and/ or alterations to the source's views).

15. Use of the iceberg argument commonly illustrates the accuser's belief that the source material is infallible.

16. Because some users of the iceberg argument believe a source material is infallible, they charge that the film misconstrues the source material when in fact there is a possibility that the film director's intention was to improve upon or simply provide an adaptation of the source material in some way.

17. Use of the iceberg argument, in terms of animated movies, often reveals immature and an un-academic knowledge of the use, power, and practicality of animation.

18. Because some users of the iceberg argument believe that the source material is superior to the film, because the film happens to be animated, users will do well to note that some of the best adaptations of source material have been produced as animated films.

19. Focusing on quality, users of the iceberg argument will do well to note that a film's quality is derived in many areas, just like a book's. These qualities include but are not limited to: cinematography, acting, lighting, screen-writing, and musical score.

20. Focusing on unique qualities: a film's musical score is often one of its greatest assets because it can provide both symbolic and aesthetic meaning to a film, something that cannot be said of books yet users of the iceberg argument, for some reason, do not understand this.

In sum, I will say that I appreciate both books and films simultaneously. Ideally, people need to understand that both mediums are unique and should be treated with respect unless one or the other is unworthy. If such a case arrives, only then should arguments be presented, not simple opinions, with definitive evidence for support.


Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
the beatles
Wikipedia Commons

For as long as I can remember, I have been listening to The Beatles. Every year, my mom would appropriately blast “Birthday” on anyone’s birthday. I knew all of the words to “Back In The U.S.S.R” by the time I was 5 (Even though I had no idea what or where the U.S.S.R was). I grew up with John, Paul, George, and Ringo instead Justin, JC, Joey, Chris and Lance (I had to google N*SYNC to remember their names). The highlight of my short life was Paul McCartney in concert twice. I’m not someone to “fangirl” but those days I fangirled hard. The music of The Beatles has gotten me through everything. Their songs have brought me more joy, peace, and comfort. I can listen to them in any situation and find what I need. Here are the best lyrics from The Beatles for every and any occasion.

Keep Reading...Show less
Being Invisible The Best Super Power

The best superpower ever? Being invisible of course. Imagine just being able to go from seen to unseen on a dime. Who wouldn't want to have the opportunity to be invisible? Superman and Batman have nothing on being invisible with their superhero abilities. Here are some things that you could do while being invisible, because being invisible can benefit your social life too.

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

19 Lessons I'll Never Forget from Growing Up In a Small Town

There have been many lessons learned.

71085
houses under green sky
Photo by Alev Takil on Unsplash

Small towns certainly have their pros and cons. Many people who grow up in small towns find themselves counting the days until they get to escape their roots and plant new ones in bigger, "better" places. And that's fine. I'd be lying if I said I hadn't thought those same thoughts before too. We all have, but they say it's important to remember where you came from. When I think about where I come from, I can't help having an overwhelming feeling of gratitude for my roots. Being from a small town has taught me so many important lessons that I will carry with me for the rest of my life.

Keep Reading...Show less
​a woman sitting at a table having a coffee
nappy.co

I can't say "thank you" enough to express how grateful I am for you coming into my life. You have made such a huge impact on my life. I would not be the person I am today without you and I know that you will keep inspiring me to become an even better version of myself.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Waitlisted for a College Class? Here's What to Do!

Dealing with the inevitable realities of college life.

132697
college students waiting in a long line in the hallway
StableDiffusion

Course registration at college can be a big hassle and is almost never talked about. Classes you want to take fill up before you get a chance to register. You might change your mind about a class you want to take and must struggle to find another class to fit in the same time period. You also have to make sure no classes clash by time. Like I said, it's a big hassle.

This semester, I was waitlisted for two classes. Most people in this situation, especially first years, freak out because they don't know what to do. Here is what you should do when this happens.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments