Caster Semenya: Should a biological advantage be considered cheating? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Sports

Caster Semenya: Should a biological advantage be considered cheating?

What constitutes an unfair advantage?

39
Caster Semenya: Should a biological advantage be considered cheating?
youtube

If one were to watch a video about Caster Semenya's win in the 800 meter final, they would see a South African woman pull ahead and finish far ahead of her competitors, besting her second place finish in London. Unlike most videos from the Olympics, however, when they pull down to the comments section, there are not words of support or awe. In fact, there are very few positive comments at all. Instead, they will be slapped in the face by an onslaught of bigotry and foul language that is no stranger to the internet, but rarely found in response to a gold medal win. What is the difference in this case, and why do these people hate Caster Semenya so much?

There will be words thrown around, words like "hyperandrogenism." Along with much ruder words, these commenters are claiming that Caster Semenya had a biological advantage coming into the competition since she was born intersex. The definition of interesex is broad, and it refers to any condition which a person is born with a combination of male and female sex organs. Their argument is that since Caster has much higher levels of testosterone than other women, that means her competing against women is cheating, as the testosterone makes her more manly, and thus more athletic.

The hate to Semenya goes farther than just being concerned about cheating. Although Semenya has parts of both female and male sex organs, many people refuse to use female pronouns for her, and say "he" when referring to the athlete. Since she was born, Semenya has lived her life as a woman. Since she has some male sex organs, has high levels of testosterone, and is married to a woman, she is apparently not considered enough of a woman. This is not only transphobic, but also homophobic. Some people have gone even farther, referring to her as "it," stripping her of her humanity because of a biological condition that she has no control over. Cruel people on the internet are not the only people who have given Semenya grief. Some of her own teammates even refused to congratulate her on her win.

The question remains: Does Semenya's condition give her a biological advantage over other competitors?

Yes, higher levels of testosterone could help her performance. But what about a woman with elevated testosterone levels who is not intersex, would people care, or is their hate for Semenya elevated by their own biases against anyone who does not fit into the gender binary? And why is sex advantage always an uproar, but other advantages are not? Should we ban every tall person from the NBA since they have an unfair biological advantage over short people? Should swimmers with large feet like Michael Phelps be banned from swimming since they give him a flipper-like advantage while swimming? Should short gymnasts be banned? Almost all Olympic athletes have some sort of biological advantage that they can't control either, but this one doesn't fit into society's views as normal.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

12 Midnight NYE: Fun Ideas!

This isn't just for the single Pringles out there either, folks

15023
Friends celebrating the New Years!
StableDiffusion

When the clock strikes twelve midnight on New Year's Eve, do you ever find yourself lost regarding what to do during that big moment? It's a very important moment. It is the first moment of the New Year, doesn't it seem like you should be doing something grand, something meaningful, something spontaneous? Sure, many decide to spend the moment on the lips of another, but what good is that? Take a look at these other suggestions on how to ring in the New Year that are much more spectacular and exciting than a simple little kiss.

Keep Reading...Show less
piano
Digital Trends

I am very serious about the Christmas season. It's one of my favorite things, and I love it all from gift-giving to baking to the decorations, but I especially love Christmas music. Here are 11 songs you should consider adding to your Christmas playlists.

Keep Reading...Show less
campus
CampusExplorer

New year, new semester, not the same old thing. This semester will be a semester to redeem all the mistakes made in the previous five months.

1. I will wake up (sorta) on time for class.

Let's face it, last semester you woke up with enough time to brush your teeth and get to class and even then you were about 10 minutes late and rollin' in with some pretty unfortunate bed head. This semester we will set our alarms, wake up with time to get ready, and get to class on time!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 5 Painfully True Stages Of Camping Out At The Library

For those long nights that turn into mornings when the struggle is real.

3033
woman reading a book while sitting on black leather 3-seat couch
Photo by Seven Shooter on Unsplash

And so it begins.

1. Walk in motivated and ready to rock

Camping out at the library is not for the faint of heart. You need to go in as a warrior. You usually have brought supplies (laptop, chargers, and textbooks) and sustenance (water, snacks, and blanket/sweatpants) since the battle will be for an undetermined length of time. Perhaps it is one assignment or perhaps it's four. You are motivated and prepared; you don’t doubt the assignment(s) will take time, but you know it couldn’t be that long.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 14 Stages Of The Last Week Of Class

You need sleep, but also have 13 things due in the span of 4 days.

1828
black marker on notebook

December... it's full of finals, due dates, Mariah Carey, and the holidays. It's the worst time of the year, but the best because after finals, you get to not think about classes for a month and catch up on all the sleep you lost throughout the semester. But what's worse than finals week is the last week of classes, when all the due dates you've put off can no longer be put off anymore.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments