"Carve The Mark" Has Missed Its Mark | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

"Carve The Mark" Has Missed Its Mark

Unless Roth was intending to be racist and ableist. Then she was spot on.

1491
"Carve The Mark" Has Missed Its Mark
Wikipedia

The bestselling author of the "Divergent" series, Veronica Roth, released her latest fantasy novel "Carve the Mark" this past Tuesday. While many authors tweeted their support of Roth and her latest book, reviewers who received ARCs (advanced reader copies) have begun stepping forward and calling out this book as being extremely racist and ableist.

On January 14, Scott Simon of NPR interviewed Roth about her upcoming novel, a new fantasy novel taking place in a new world of Roth's creation. During this interview, Roth explains the basic premise of her novel, in which everyone receives a "gift" once they come of age. Simon has Roth explain a little bit more about one of her main characters' gift; she experiences and utilizes chronic pain.

Roth goes on to explain that the inspiration behind this character's gift comes from "several friends who experienced chronic pain" who were "underestimated by doctors." This is not an uncommon practice; oftentimes writers draw inspiration from their own lives and the lives of others that they are close to for reference and influence toward their characters actions.

However, the nature of Roth's use of this chronic pain that her character experiences is extremely ablest. In the interview, Roth compares her friends' chronic pain stoires to that of her character, Cyra, saying that, "[this chronic] pain takes over your life and limits your potential," and that, "that's kind of Cyra's struggles."

Members of the book community, particularly on Twitter, have taken on the matter, particularly members of that community who experience chronic pain.

While the book community has been begging author's for diversity, particularly in young adult novels as teenagers desperately need representation within the books they read, ablest representation such as Roth's can be particularly harmful. As Heather put it, "my chronic pain? It is not a gift."

The ableism present within "Carve the Mark" is not the end of the list of criticisms from the community. In Justine Aireland's blog post entitled "The Continent, Carve the Mark, and the Trope of the Dark Skinned Aggressor," Aireland points out the toxic trope often found in fantasy novel world-building where African (and other non-white, non-European) culture is taken and appropriated into the novel, almost always within the "savage race" of the story. Aireland goes on to list the different ways Roth's newest novel takes these cultures and calls them savage and barbaric when compared to the other, more European based, culture the other race of people have.

Racism in books is not a new concept by any stretch, and neither is ablism. However, we are now in 2017. It is time to start allowing representation without any skewed perception. It is time to let the people who belong to these cultures reclaim them in the media and tell their stories. It is time for all of the privileged white people (myself included) to stand up for our brothers and sisters and call out those who choose to enable this unhealthy viewpoint.

And if this isn't enough to make you take "Carve the Mark" off of your reading list, maybe it's time to reevaluate where you stand.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Entertainment

A Year At JMU As Told By 'Bob's Burgers'

The world's greatest university meets the world's greatest show.

978
Bob's Burgers
collegian.com

A year at JMU promises many great adventures. The journey of becoming a duke and learning what being a duke is all about is really exciting and a lot of fun. Of course, we all know that James Madison University is the greatest university in Virginia (perhaps even the entire country). There are many events and moments at JMU that are cherished and remembered by all dukes.

Keep Reading...Show less
birthday party

My birthday has never been my favorite holiday. I've found that I'm more excited to celebrate my friends' and family members' birthdays more than my own. I don't like being the center of attention, so I usually celebrate over dinner with a small group of family and friends. This way, I can enjoy myself naturally without feeling like I have to entertain everyone and make sure they are satisfied. In the past when I've had large parties, I was so nervous that people weren't perfectly content that I didn't enjoy myself at my own celebration.

Keep Reading...Show less
thinking
College Informations

Most of us have already started the spring semester, and for those of you who haven't started yet, you suck.

It seems like coming back from winter break wouldn't really be a break all things considered, since we all come back to school and pick up right where we left off. We know exactly what to expect, yet we're unprepared every single time.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

Dear Future Me, Life Is Tough But Please Remember These 14 Things

You can forget to breathe OR to buy fruit OR to even pet a dog but you cannot forget these things!!

323
Dear Future Me, Life Is Tough But Please Remember These 14 Things
Distractify

Dear Future Me,

I know you still overthink everything and you care too much, but I hope you're loving life regardless of what you're going through. Trust me the ups and downs in life are helping you and shaping you remember that. I know that you think you are wiser and "cooler" than me now but I hope you remember these 14 things that have taught you so much already.

Keep Reading...Show less
I'm serious

There are tons of unisex names that are popular: Taylor, Alex, Bailey, etc. There are also numerous names that are used for both sexes, but they’re not seen as “unisex” yet. People are slowly becoming accustomed to the dual use of these names, but for the most part, in their minds they associate certain names with certain sexes. And that leaves those of us with these names in many awkward situations.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments