Brett Kavanaugh's controversy | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Student Life

Brett Kavanaugh Should Not Be Appointed Before Midterms Are Over

Donald Trump's nomination for the replacement of Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy, Brett Kavanaugh, has been the cause of much of the political disarray happening now.

339
https://www.politico.com/story/2018/08/30/kavanaugh-senate-hearing-prep-supreme-court-white-house-805490
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

In the world of politics, the name Brett Kavanaugh has been mentioned numerous times in these passing months. Why is there so much hype and concern over this man?

Brett Kavanaugh is Donald Trump's nominee for Supreme Court Justice in order to replace the retiring Justice Kennedy. Justice Kennedy has been, for about 30 years now, the famous swing voter between the liberal and conservative justices of the Supreme Court. He has been a saving grace for important rulings such as Obergefell v. Hodges back in June of 2015, which was the court case decision that finally legalized same-sex marriage in all 50 states. The case turned in favor of love, 5-4, Justice Kennedy being the swing vote that made it possible. However, in other cases, he has leaned towards conservative values when it came to not allowing the passage of many gun-control regulations and giving leeway to the extent of corporate spending on political campaigns.

Justice Kennedy retired in July of 2018, making room for Donald Trump to nominate Brett Kavanaugh for the next Supreme Court Justice. Brett Kavanaugh is infamously conservative and has people of the left wing fearing for their basic rights, as Kavanaugh holds many of them in his hands. In the past years, we have undoubtedly seen an increase in mass shootings, many of which have been in schools. Due to the vehement belief in the second amendment, the majority republican congress has blocked many attempts at banning automatic and semi-automatic rifles from the hands of the public. There is a natural fear amongst the general public that with appointing Kavanaugh, gun control will turn in the favor of the NRA rather than the public safety. Women are also fearing for their health and reproductive rights with Trump's nominee, due to Trump threatening many times about overturning Roe v. Wade, the court case that allows women to have access to safe and legal abortions.

Trump makes clear Roe v. Wade is on the chopping block.

Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) is threatening to withhold her support. But Trump isn't backing off his past rhetoric.

However, the main reason why the appointment of Kavanaugh would be controversial is that we are currently amidst the 2018 midterm elections, in which the citizens of the United States are voting for who they would like to represent them in the Senate. This is important because the Senate is who votes to confirm the president's nominee for Supreme Court Justice. This vote goes by majority approval. The anger from more left-wing supporters stems because back in 2016 when Justice Antonin Scalia passed away, President Barack Obama nominated a Supreme Court Justice and the Senate refused to have a hearing with his nominee because the United States was in the middle of the presidential election. They believed that his nominee wouldn't best represent what the citizens of the United States would want. Hypocritically, Republicans are now saying that appointing a Supreme Court Justice in the middle of a mid-term election is completely different than appointing one during a presidential election. Regardless, I think it would be fair to say that this round of senators voting on the next Supreme Court Justice is not adhering to the voice of the people when we are in the middle of voting for who we want to represent us as our senators now.

Mitch McConnell, the Senate Majority Leader, defended the Senate's position of ignoring President Obama's supreme court nominee back in 2016 by claiming that the presidential election at the time was politically loaded. Today, right now, the midterms are charged with a different kind of energy: with mass shootings, family separations at the border, the attack on the environment, and many many more parts of this country going awry.

Remember, a Supreme Court Justice does not get voted on by the people; they get voted on by the Senate who should be a fair representation of what people vote for.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
female tv characters
We Heart It

Over the past decade, television has undergone a very crucial transition: the incorporation of female lead characters. Since it's a known fact that girls actually do run the world (Beyonce said so herself), it's time for the leading ladies of the small screen to get some credit. Without these characters, women would still be sitting in the background of our favorite shows. These women are not only trailblazers for female empowerment, but role models for women worldwide. With that, here are 15 of the smartest, sassiest ladies gracing our screens that remind us that women do, indeed, rule:

Keep Reading...Show less
New Now Next
New Now Next

If you are like me, you have an interesting personality. Basically, you love to be sassy and snarky, gossip, and act like a total bitch (not really), but deep down, you are actually a very genuinely nice person. The idea of actually hurting someone truly makes you feel bad, and you probably have never actually hurt someone’s feelings because your kindness always shines through, even if you do not want it to. Not sure exactly what I would call this type of personality, but if you identify with it, here are some feelings you can undoubtedly relate to.

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf
Cub Magazine

We all have a little bit of Blair Waldorf inside of us. You may not realize it, but you're probably guilty of at least nine out of ten of these listed points. So why don't we reminisce on the famous Blair Waldorf moments where we realized we were actually her at certain times through the series?

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

11 Confessions Of A Sleep-A-Holic

If your plans get cancelled, there is a 99.9% percent chance you are sleeping.

1869
woman lying on bed
Photo by Kinga Howard on Unsplash

1. What are some of your hobbies? Does sleep count?

I'm so good at sleeping I can do it with my eyes closed

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

7 Reasons To Watch One Tree Hill

"There is only one tree hill, Jaime Scott."

2046
one tree hill
Wikipedia Commons

If you need a new series to watch, I recommend One Tree Hill. I watched this series three times now and it only keeps getting better. If you need any more reasons beside the fact that all of the seasons are on Netflix for your binge-watching pleasure, here are seven more reasons to watch it.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments