We Need To Stop Making A Scapegoat Out Of Fraternities | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

We Need To Stop Making A Scapegoat Out Of Fraternities

Fraternities are not the source of the problem, they are a symptom of it.

154
We Need To Stop Making A Scapegoat Out Of Fraternities
University of Rochester

The word "fraternity" is so often associated with scandal, with binge drinking, or with new-member hazing. And I have heard it all. In fact I bought into some of that rhetoric for most of my life.

But is this public perception of fraternities wrong? How could so many people have a skewed perception of a phenomenon present on almost every college campus?

We ought to reevaluate how we perceive Greek life. I don't intend to deny that there are definitely problematic aspects to some fraternities; I'm not going to justify binge-drinking, nor will I justify any fraternities that haze their members. Instead, I will argue that fraternities, as a whole, ought to remain institutionalized because the alternative is much worse.

Most concerns with fraternities are societally-based. The most salient anxieties about fraternities are the harms that the aforementioned inflict upon society and college campuses. Whether this is sexual assault, or binge-drinking, or the pledging process (which I've heard described as a "cycle of abuse"), this belief is particularly damning. And with a new story coming out every few months about some form of sexual assault perpetrated by members of a fraternity, these beliefs are becoming increasingly dogmatic.

These views become more solidified when media outlets like The Guardian post a survey-styled study that concludes that men in fraternities are more likely to commit sexual assault. Let's disregard that the study was only conducted at one university and was only indicative of their college campus, and that another study found that fraternity members were less likely than non-Greek students to display hyper-masculinity and hold aggressive attitudes toward women. For a moment, let's assume that the conclusion The Guardian arrived at is a correct one. What do we do then?

The debate to this point has been mostly whether or not fraternities are actually, on the whole, responsible for this sexual misconduct and abuse-form of hazing. This is a different kind of article.

I ask you to put aside whatever preconceived notions you hold about Greek life and ask yourself two questions about fraternities, assuming the above is correct:

1. If a university bans fraternities as a whole, will the alternative (banning fraternities) yield more positive results?

2. Can we truly separate campus culture from fraternity culture?

In order: let's imagine what will happen if all universities ban fraternities on their college campuses. Disregard the backlash the university will receive in response, but rather look towards the response by the fraternities.Even if college administration legally prohibits Greek life, a group of rebellious college students will nonetheless secretly create Greek organizations. Fraternities represent catharsis (Read: partying), you'll find that fraternities are resilient.

Members of Greek organizations will simply go underground in the exact same way they went underground at Brandeis. And this is far from preferable to school-sponsored fraternity activity, because that can at least be somewhat monitored and regulated. If an incident of alcohol poisoning occurs at a frat party, the individuals in the fraternity will not be able to call the EMT service on campus. Instead, they will be forced to call 911, which they will be less incentivized to do. Why? Because the house is being rented by a few college students off-campus, and calling authorities to your unofficial fraternity house will not look good on the landlord, and you are likely to lose your lease.

Brothers of that house can also face underage drinking and negligence charges. An on-campus fraternity is going to be able to call the medical services at the university itself. On-campus fraternity members will also be more likely to report those who have consumed alcohol past their limits because they may be required, many times both by the university and the fraternity, to take courses to raise their consciousness on the importance of intervening when one has had too much to drink.

Fraternities will become far more opaque when not under the eyeful scrutiny of the university. If there is at least some university regulation, and the fraternity is located on-campus rather than off of it, their activities become far more apparent to the university, and the university is able to regulate the fraternity and definitively modify what it wishes to modify.

Onto the second question; at what point can we make the distinction between culture on a college campus and the culture inside a fraternity? It appears quite obvious that "frat culture" is a reflection of campus culture. This holds true for any organization, yet many don't make that same distinction for Greek life. A club (and its members) for mental health activism is going to be much different a university where communal self-care is emphasized than a university where individualism is valued above the aforementioned self-care.

In that same vein, if one attends a huge "party school", they will find many of the problems associated with the university will be found in the fraternity itself. Moving these fraternities off-campus is ignoring the actualproblem. As Martin Schwartz and Carol Nogrady of University of Minnesota Duluth described in Violence Against Women, anti-fraternity efforts largely ignore the actual problem, and sexual and alcohol education on college campuses as a whole must be prioritized.

Fraternities are not the source of the problem in some universities, they are a symptom of it. There needs to be widespread reform to intervene and prevent all forms of sexual assault and exploitation on college campuses.

The problems people oft-times find with fraternities, therefore, are problems that must be addressed at the university level. The fraternities are not the problem - lack of education about alcohol and about sexual assault is.

Once you look at fraternities through the lens of the two questions I have posed, I urge you to reevaluate the way you look at fraternities.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Drake
Hypetrak

1. Nails done hair done everything did / Oh you fancy huh

You're pretty much feeling yourself. New haircut, clothes, shoes, everything. New year, new you, right? You're ready for this semester to kick off.

Keep Reading...Show less
7 Ways to Make Your Language More Transgender and Nonbinary Inclusive

With more people becoming aware of transgender and non-binary people, there have been a lot of questions circulating online and elsewhere about how to be more inclusive. Language is very important in making a space safer for trans and non-binary individuals. With language, there is an established and built-in measure of whether a place could be safe or unsafe. If the wrong language is used, the place is unsafe and shows a lack of education on trans and non-binary issues. With the right language and education, there can be more safe spaces for trans and non-binary people to exist without feeling the need to hide their identities or feel threatened for merely existing.

Keep Reading...Show less
singing
Cambio

Singing is something I do all day, every day. It doesn't matter where I am or who's around. If I feel like singing, I'm going to. It's probably annoying sometimes, but I don't care -- I love to sing! If I'm not singing, I'm probably humming, sometimes without even realizing it. So as someone who loves to sing, these are some of the feelings and thoughts I have probably almost every day.

Keep Reading...Show less
success
Degrassi.Wikia

Being a college student is one of the most difficult task known to man. Being able to balance your school life, work life and even a social life is a task of greatness. Here's an ode to some of the small victories that mean a lot to us college students.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

6 Signs You're A Workaholic

Becuase of all things to be addicted to, you're addicted to making money.

637
workaholic
kaboompics

After turning 16, our parents start to push us to get a job and take on some responsibility. We start to make our own money in order to fund the fun we intend on having throughout the year. But what happens when you've officially become so obsessed with making money that you can't even remember the last day you had off? You, my friend, have become a workaholic. Being a workaholic can be both good and bad. It shows dedication to your job and the desire to save money. It also shows that you don't have a great work-life balance. Here are the signs of becoming a workaholic.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments