'The Book Was Better': Are You Sure? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

'The Book Was Better': Are You Sure?

Do you really believe that?

381
'The Book Was Better': Are You Sure?
teeturtle

I love being a book nerd, I really do. I love being a writer and an English major. What I'm less fond of is the stereotype of arrogance that comes with those things.

For instance: "the book was better." It's a simple, harmless phrase that gets echoed over and over again by bibliophiles. For a long time, I would agree. I was 11 years old when the movie* "Inkheart" came out and I cried in the bathroom afterwards because they "ruined the ending." I still stand by that, I do.

However, I think there's a history behind that phrase. What you're often saying when you tell someone that the book was better is that you knew about the original work first, which makes you better. Even if that's not what you mean, repeating that until it becomes a mantra is a surefire way to sound elitist.

The book is not always better. Even despite the controversy the show has created in the last season, "The 100" TV show is infinitely better than the books in my opinion. It lacks many of the annoying romantic cliches, includes a more diverse cast, and is just more interesting to watch than it was to read.

Then there are TV shows and movies than are simply just a different story all together. My favorite movie, "Howl's Moving Castle" is nothing like the Diana Wynne Jones book, but I enjoy both equally. Sometimes I even relish in annoying people with facts about the differences between the two. I've never felt offended by the movie for being different than the book, and I don't dislike the book for not including some of the best scenes from the movie.

If you watch a movie before you know it's a book, there's a better chance that you'll enjoy the movie and the book equally, but if you read the book first you probably will miss out on the movie's excellence. Even fans of "Harry Potter," who got what was largely a great adaptation, can recall the infamous mix up of Dumbledore's reaction in "The Goblet of Fire" and the absence of Peeves.

So where is the line drawn?

Well, first, remember that it is a matter of opinion. You can love the book, but ask yourself if you really enjoyed the book that much more, or if you just like riling people up by telling them that the book is better. Remember that what you see in the book (your imagination, that is) is not always the canon. Remember that it is a matter of chance; so many movies are based on books that I know I've never even heard of before. Don't be disappointed if like doesn't have that person read the book first. It is OK, honestly.

Next time you want to say "the book was better," try approaching it from a different direction. Maybe be more specific about what you preferred, or what you missed out in the movie. Or, even, try talking about what you liked about the movie next time!

It's all fun and games to say "the book was better," and I agree so much of the time, but I realize also that it sounds just a little pretentious sometimes.

Go out and enjoy a movie, or a book, or both!

*Movie and tv show are interchangeable in this article.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Relationships

20 Things You Forgot To Thank Your Mom For

Moms are super heroes dressed in yesterday's clothing and they deserve an award for that.

1316
family
Facebook

Dear Mom,

You took care of me and my brothers our entire lives and you still continue to! I will not be able to truly grasp all of the hard work that you put into this family until I create my own one day. But, I know that there are plenty of times I forgot to give you a simple thank you or an appreciative smile. I thank you for everything that you have done for me and will continue to do for me. Here are some examples of those times where you had my back and I forgot to pat your back for saving me:

Keep Reading...Show less
pumpkin
Holytaco.com

College is hard. As people ages 18-22, we’re just trying to figure out what we’re doing with our lives, our careers, our eating habits, exercise routines, sleep patterns, and other necessities for adult life. We definitely don’t take proper care of ourselves; it’s basically impossible when we have essays, tests and readings due and somehow we’re supposed to eat right, exercise and sleep. We’re doomed to get sick. I have zero experience in science but when I get sick there are certain things I do to make myself better.

Keep Reading...Show less
Bob's Burgers
Hyannishyball

First of all, there is no shortage of fun when you're together.

And you often find yourselves entertaining each others terrible ideas.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

The Unwritten Rules Of "Talking"

What is "talking?" How does one "talk?"

9191
girl holding phone
NYCPRGIRLS

Now that it seems “talking” is the new way to date, and will stay that way until another idiotic term is used to describe the people who can’t settle down and just date someone, I feel as if it’s time to go over the unwritten rules of “talking.”

Rule 1. Having feeling without feeling.

Keep Reading...Show less
The Stages of Having FOMO in College
iamthatgirl.com

Are you one of those people that gets super upset when you miss out on anything? Well, you may have FOMO, or fear of missing out. In college it’s not hard to experience FOMO every once in a while. You just love doing everything and anything, so hen you have to miss out on something it's the worst possible thing in your mind. Whether you’re sick, have to work, or have so much work to do you could cry – FOMO will hit you hard in college.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments