The Right-Wing Response to Biden's Nominees Shows Who Conservative Commentators Think 'Deserves' Success | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

The Right-Wing Response to Biden's Nominees Shows Who Conservative Commentators Think 'Deserves' Success

The transphobic comments directed towards Rachel Levine and the racism and sexism levied at Vice President Kamala Harris are revealing of the wider right-wing argument that anyone from a traditionally marginalized group reaching a position of authority must be cheating the system.

63
The Right-Wing Response to Biden's Nominees Shows Who Conservative Commentators Think 'Deserves' Success
Image from @VP on Instagram


This was popular conservative commentator and overly-invested Harry Styles critic Ben Shapiro on Rachel Levine, the Biden administration's nominee for assistant secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services. Now, at this point, no one should be surprised by Ben's blatant transphobia (despite constantly whining that facts don't care about your feelings, he's quite adept at ignoring the constantly-growing number of studies showing that human gender identity is far from binary). But when it comes to Levine, Ben is balancing aggressive, in-your-face transphobia with an only slightly more subtle form of bigotry popular in right-wing circles.

Namely, that they (be 'they' BIPOC, women, LGBT+ people, or any other traditionally marginalized group) are only every successful as token diversity hires and they're out to steal from you, the perpetually, unquestionably deserving cisgender straight white man (or woman).

Now, to be clear, Levine has served as Pennsylvania's Heath Secretary for four years (where she was confirmed by the State's Republican-controlled legislature). Before that, she was Pennsylvania's Physician General for nearly two years. She founded Penn State Hershey Medical Center's adolescent medical division and its clinic for eating disorders.

Rachel Levine is, by any metric, qualified for the position she's been nominated to fill.

But according to Ben Shapiro, Levine's qualifications are only valid when they're used to criticize her. And, sure, go ahead and criticize her for policies you disagree with. She's a public servant, her work should be looked at by the public. Simultaneously, however, Ben tells on himself - Levine has enough experience that he can attack her for it, sure, but the only reason she was nominated must be because she happens to be transgender.

This isn't a unique take, either. When Joe Biden announced he was planning on nominating a woman as his running mate last March, my immediate reaction was to wish he hadn't said that publicly. Not because there wasn't a pool of qualified, deserving women who were up for the job - there were - but because I knew what right-wing pundits would say.

And sure enough, when Biden tapped Kamala Harris for the VP slot, you heard the same thing anywhere from Facebook comments to the Twitters of Republican congressmen - she only got the job because she was a woman of color. Yes, she was a Senator, and the Attorney General of California before that, but yeah, no, she must have been unqualified.

The implication in the "they don't deserve it" rhetoric is obvious. The only people that can actually deserve their positions, by the logic of Ben Shapiro and Rep. Greg Murphy, are heterosexual, cisgender, white men. If only we could go back to the days of hiring by 'merit' - where, incidentally, nearly everyone who 'made it' happened to be white men. The absence of marginalized groups in positions of power isn't because the best candidate was always the white guy; it was because everyone else didn't have the same opportunities. Obviously.

People will continue to celebrate the first transgender assistant secretary of Health and Human Services until people like Ben Shapiro stop spouting the transphobia that makes these accomplishments that much more notable. And if your first thought when you see a transgender woman appointed to the assistant secretary of health or a Black woman becoming Vice President is that they probably didn't deserve it anyway, the issue isn't so-called 'identity politics.' You're probably just a bigot.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Entertainment

27 Things 'The Office' Has Taught Us

"The Office" is a mockumentary based on everyday office life featuring love triangles, silly pranks and everything in between. It can get pretty crazy for just an average day at the office.

408
the office
http://www.ssninsider.com/

When you were little, your parents probably told you television makes your brain rot so you wouldn't watch it for twelve straight hours. However, I feel we can learn some pretty valuable stuff from television shows. "The Office," while a comedy, has some pretty teachable moments thrown in there. You may not know how to react in a situation where a co-worker does something crazy (like put your office supplies in jello) but thanks to "The Office," now you'll have an idea how to behave ifsomething like that should happen.

Here are just a few of the things that religious Office watchers can expect to learn.

Keep Reading...Show less
Grey's Anatomy
TV Guide

Being pre-med is quite a journey. It’s not easy juggling school work, extracurricular activities, volunteering, shadowing, research, and MCAT prep all at the same time. Ever heard of “pain is temporary, but GPA is forever?” Pre-meds don’t just embody that motto; we live and breathe it. Here are 10 symptoms you’re down with the pre-med student syndrome.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

Books were always about understanding for me, about learning the way someone else sees, about connection.

224
High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

I keep making this joke whenever the idea of books is brought up: "God, I wish I knew how to read." It runs parallel to another stupid phrase, as I watch my friends struggle through their calculus classes late at night in our floor lounge: "I hope this is the year that I learn to count." They're both truly idiotic expressions, but, when I consider the former, I sometimes wonder if there's some truth to it.

Keep Reading...Show less
school of business
CIS Markets

Coming from someone majoring in business at a school that thrives off of business majors, I know how rough it can be sometimes. Being a business major can be awesome, and awful, simultaneously. We work our tails off to be the best, but sometimes the stress can just tear you apart. Here are some struggles faced by business majors that will sound all too familiar.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

10 Things To Know About The First Semester Of College

10 things that most incoming college freshmen have no idea about.

1549
campus
Pexels

Starting college is pretty scary and fun at the same time. You are free of your parents(in most cases) but this is the first time you have no idea what the heck is going on. Here are 10 things you may want to know going into your first semester.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments