Why Banning Pit Bulls In Montreal Won't Accomplish Anything | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Lifestyle

Why Banning Pit Bulls In Montreal Won't Accomplish Anything

Saying all pit bulls are bad just because one pit bull did something bad delves into a much deeper problem rooted in our society.

13
Why Banning Pit Bulls In Montreal Won't Accomplish Anything
Google Images

On September 25 in Montreal, Canada, city legislators voted 37-23 in favor of breed-specific regulation, outlawing any dog that resembles a pit bull.

This means that any dog that resembles a pit bull (American pit bull terriers, American Staffordshire terriers and Staffordshire bull terriers) that is in the shelter in Montreal is not allowed to be adopted, and therefore has to be euthanized. For those who already own pit bulls, a set of rules was put in place that allows owners to keep them -- that is, IF they follow the rules.

Now anyone who owns a dog that is considered a pit bull has until March to get a background check and pay a $150 fee for a special permit. The dog then has to be sterilized, vaccinated and microchipped. If that wasn't enough, the dog also has to be muzzled and kept on a four foot leash at all times while in public.

This new law resulted due to a series of dog attacks in the city. One of the more well known cases was when a woman was attacked and killed by a neighbor's dog that resembled a pit bull in June.

Mayor of Montreal, Denis Coderre, defended this new law, saying, "I have a responsibility as the mayor of Montreal to protect the citizens."

So far, all this ban is doing is sparking controversy not only in Montreal, but around the world. The American Bar Association wrote a letter to Mayor Coderre questioning the legality of the ban. Celebrities like Sophia Bush, Rachel Ray and Nikki Reed have spoken out against the ban. The SPCA (Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) in Montreal even said that they're going to cancel its contract with the city because of the ban.

I understand wanting to keep people safe, but giving death sentences to dogs who have done nothing to deserve it is unjustified. Forcing good dogs in shelters to be euthanized just because one dog from their breed committed a crime cannot be considered fair. Forcing people who own pit bulls to pay a fee and forcing good pit bulls to wear muzzles in public cannot be considered just. Punishing the bad dog is one thing, but punishing dogs who have done nothing to deserve it is another.

In one sense, this is part of the problem with our world. We group people together in order to discriminate, and then justify our negative thoughts and actions toward them by reasoning that once there was a bad person that was similar to that group of people that acted negatively. We need calling groups of people "bad" just because their race, religion, etc. matched that of a criminal.

While I know that dogs don't fall under the "people" category, it's the same concept. Of the 2,000 dogs that the Montreal SPCA takes in every year, one third of them are pit bulls. This means that Montreal is going to euthanize 700 dogs who have done nothing to deserve this sentence, simply because there was one dog from their breed that did something bad.

Euthanizing innocent dogs isn't what is going to keep the city safe. There will always be some bad dogs in the world just like there will always be some bad people in the world. The only thing this law is doing is sparking anger in the citizens of Montreal and bringing people together from all over the world to fight this wrongful ruling. But hopefully, if enough people band together to fight this, we can get the law repealed.

So what exactly can we do to help? We can keep fighting the Montreal government by signing this petition, writing to them here or even helping the Montreal SPCA find homes for the pit bulls sentenced to wrongful deaths.

Stand with thousands of others across the world to help these dogs get the justice they deserve.


Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
13 Real Thoughts Every College Student Has At Some Point
Good Call

There are a few thoughts that go through a college student's mind on a day to day basis. Some of those thoughts come from class, some of then come from when you are bored in class. Here are sixteen thoughts that college students think of on a day to day basis.

Keep Reading...Show less
mouse with a cookie

One of my biggest pet peeves is when someone does not try to help their self before asking others. How can someone else be expected to help you if you do not first do that yourself? I'm all about helping those that need it when the time comes, however whenever someone does not even attempt to help him or herself first then that becomes a huge problem. As we all have learned, people tend to take advantage of us in one way or another. I am sure we all read this short story when we were younger and it follows that same principle:

Keep Reading...Show less
39 Traits You Know You Have If You're A Libra
Flickr

If you were born between September 23rd - October 22nd, then you are a Libra. Let's be real, Libras are the best because you are the perfect balance of all things in life. Some may find this boring, but they don't know anything about what it means to be all things at once. As Libras, we hold much on our shoulders that no one can understand. These are traits you know to be true if you are a Libra:

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

12 Types Of Drunk Girls You'll See In Every Friend Group

"Getting drunk with your best friends is an experience in and of itself. It takes us on wild and ridiculous adventures with the people we trust with our lives."

1550
friends
Cloud Front

Getting drunk with your best friends is an experience in and of itself. It takes us on wild and ridiculous adventures with the people we trust with our lives. Each one of you plays a vital role in making sure the night goes (relatively) smoothly.

Keep Reading...Show less
Kardashians
Cosmopolitan.com

Finals week is so rude! So, there's no one better to explain it than the Kardashians themselves!

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments