Why The 2020 Mulan Was A Huge Disappointment To Asians | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Lifestyle

Being Asian, I Feel The 2020 Rendition Of 'Mulan' Was A HUGE Disappointment — Here's Why

Now here comes the fun part: deconstructing Disney films and their morals and themes.

540
Being Asian, I Feel The 2020 Rendition Of 'Mulan' Was A HUGE Disappointment — Here's Why
Disney

The basic premise of "Mulan" is essentially a woman who is breaking the glass ceiling while simultaneously defying gender roles and her Asian culture's traditions.

Mulan is a woman who was raised by her family (predominantly her mother in both versions, as well as her grandmother in the animation) to be wed as a bride to a wealthy, respected man to bring honor to her family.

In Southeast Asian culture, filial piety is a cornerstone of all families.

Each member pays respect to their elders, and for each ambition fulfilled, they bring respect to the clan. In addition, the eldest son possesses the role of preserving the family name, especially from their father's mantel.

Men are expected to be strong, smart, and maintain power. Women are expected to be emotional, nurturing, and practically only there to raise children.

It is explicitly mentioned in the remake that Mulan's father is ashamed of her because she was not born a man. Because of Mulan's childish antics, everyone except her sister treats her as an outcast unfitting to be a bride.

This is cemented when she is publicly shamed by the Matchmaker.

The culture is forcing her to act "womanly" so she doesn't embarrass her entire lineage. When her weak, elderly father is drafted for war, Mulan sees the opportunity to not only save her father from his untimely death but to ultimately redeem herself.

In the animated version, there is a crucial scene that the remake neglects: Mulan cutting her hair.

By cutting off her hair, which Mulan has grown for her entire life, she casts away her past and one of her key "feminine aspects" in order to survive and thrive as a "man" in the army.

This resonates with people who identify as transgender, and the struggles they face today with societal norms. Mulan struggles to suppress her feminine characteristics at the camp — not only to prevent her from being discovered as a woman but also to suppress the closeted, masculine nature her people deem as "dishonorable" (athletics, acting out, a boisterous nature).

Moments that cement this are: when she binds her chest and when attempts to reason about her "ideal women" to her fellow, childish, sexist male comrades.

On a side note, several people consider Shang to be one of the first LGBTQ pioneers in Disney animation, as his relationship with Ping/Mulan can be seen bisexual.

Several in the LGBTQ community believed this was a missed opportunity for Disney to offer more representation in media, as he was retconned into two different people who do not share this unique perspective/interpretation.

In addition, Shang can be seen as a conduit for change, as he opens and embraces Mulan's identity. He realizes a warrior is not defined by their body, but by their will to survive and fight. This is amplified in the animation, as Shang works with Mulan, as well as three of his men who abandon their previous notions of masculinity to masquerade as women in an effort to defeat the Huns once and for all.

The biggest sin that the remake commits is in the treatment of Xianniang, the shape-shifting witch that aligns with Bori Khan, Shang Yu's retcon counterpart.

She is a powerful sorcerer and yet is treated and named as a "dog" by her male counterpart, who claims that she would be nothing because she is both a woman and a witch.

Xianniang has to pair with Khan because she feels she doesn't belong, as no one would accept her and her magic.

Khan, as abusive as he is, is her only chance at finding a place in society. Everyone else has rejected her.

This becomes more tragic when she sacrifices herself to save Mulan from the Khan. By using her femininity as a crutch, and her death as motivation for the main character, the people behind the remake used her until she did not serve a purpose in the plot.

Disney basically used her and Mulan as mannequins the plot together, failing to actually give them a voice due to poor writing and lack of imagination.

With all of this in mind, the remake is merely another movie focused on flashy, dramatic action with CGI.

Sadly, this brings attention to the double-standard in today's society. Women often have to conform to male standards in order to thrive in many industries dominated by men.

Women face persecution and discrimination because they are either too feminine or not feminine enough while men face zero-to-little consequences by hopping on these remarks.

People in the LGBTQ community feel they need to suppress their true nature in order not to feel hurt or judged. It is important for bias to not consume us all.

In order to create change, we must be aware of the problems and of those suffering from them. Once we do that we can ensure they receive support from a community that loves and accepts them.

That is when we can fight to make change possible, so they can be deemed as equal and honorable as everyone else.

Gifer

Report this Content
Student Life

28 Daily Thoughts of College Students

"I want to thank Google, Wikipedia, and whoever else invented copy and paste. Thank you."

581
group of people sitting on bench near trees duting daytime

I know every college student has daily thoughts throughout their day. Whether you're walking on campus or attending class, we always have thoughts running a mile a minute through our heads. We may be wondering why we even showed up to class because we'd rather be sleeping, or when the professor announces that we have a test and you have an immediate panic attack.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

The Great Christmas Movie Debate

"A Christmas Story" is the star on top of the tree.

1933
The Great Christmas Movie Debate
Mental Floss

One staple of the Christmas season is sitting around the television watching a Christmas movie with family and friends. But of the seemingly hundreds of movies, which one is the star on the tree? Some share stories of Santa to children ("Santa Claus Is Coming to Town"), others want to spread the Christmas joy to adults ("It's a Wonderful Life"), and a select few are made to get laughs ("Elf"). All good movies, but merely ornaments on the Christmas tree of the best movies. What tops the tree is a movie that bridges the gap between these three movies, and makes it a great watch for anyone who chooses to watch it. Enter the timeless Christmas classic, "A Christmas Story." Created in 1983, this movie holds the tradition of capturing both young and old eyes for 24 straight hours on its Christmas Day marathon. It gets the most coverage out of all holiday movies, but the sheer amount of times it's on television does not make it the greatest. Why is it,
then? A Christmas Story does not try to tell the tale of a Christmas miracle or use Christmas magic to move the story. What it does do though is tell the real story of Christmas. It is relatable and brings out the unmatched excitement of children on Christmas in everyone who watches. Every one becomes a child again when they watch "A Christmas Story."

Keep Reading...Show less
student thinking about finals in library
StableDiffusion

As this semester wraps up, students can’t help but be stressed about finals. After all, our GPAs depends on these grades! What student isn’t worrying about their finals right now? It’s “goodbye social life, hello library” time from now until the end of finals week.

1. Finals are weeks away, I’m sure I’ll be ready for them when they come.

Keep Reading...Show less
Christmas tree
Librarian Lavender

It's the most wonderful time of the year! Christmas is one of my personal favorite holidays because of the Christmas traditions my family upholds generation after generation. After talking to a few of my friends at college, I realized that a lot of them don't really have "Christmas traditions" in their family, and I want to help change that. Here's a list of Christmas traditions that my family does, and anyone can incorporate into their family as well!

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

The 5 Phases Of Finals

May the odds be ever in your favor.

2547
Does anybody know how to study
Gurl.com

It’s here; that time of year when college students turn into preschoolers again. We cry for our mothers, eat everything in sight, and whine when we don’t get our way. It’s finals, the dreaded time of the semester when we all realize we should have been paying attention in class instead of literally doing anything else but that. Everyone has to take them, and yes, unfortunately, they are inevitable. But just because they are here and inevitable does not mean they’re peaches and cream and full of rainbows. Surviving them is a must, and the following five phases are a reality for all majors from business to art, nursing to history.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments