'Bans Don't Work', Says the Party Banning What They Don't Like | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post

'Bans Don't Work', Says the Party Banning What They Don't Like

A.k.a there are a whole lot of hypocrites in government and politics

15
'Bans Don't Work', Says the Party Banning What They Don't Like

The latest anti-abortion legislation in places like Georgia and Ohio has furthered an already hot debate between opposing viewpoints. The Georgia legislation is, according to those who passed it, an attempt to overturn Roe v. Wade and effectively ban abortions in all fifty states.

While protesters and pundits alike argue the pro-choice and anti-choice debate, I've been left confused and angry about another piece of the argument.

When did the Republican legislators and commentators celebrating the abortion ban suddenly decide bans were effective?

The rallying cry around opposing gun legislation proposed largely by Democratic candidates has been that banning guns will not deter crime or keep criminals from obtaining weapons.

Yes, their argument is that a ban does not work.

{For the purpose of this writing I am not even touching the fact that most Democrats don't propose a total ban on guns, making the whole argument obsolete anyway, because I can only focus on one fallacy in this post.}

Now compare that to the abortion discussion this country is engulfed in right now. The Republican legislators behind the recent anti-abortion bills want to see abortion banned by the highest court in the land: the Supreme Court. Many of their supporters agree with this.

To that point, there is good reason to believe that many people who chose to vote for Donald Trump in the 2016 election did so because they knew a Republican president would appoint conservative judges to the Supreme Court when given the opportunity.

So, clearly, a lot of Republicans want a ban on abortion. For the sake of being a decent human being, I am going to assume most of these people do not want women to perform risky medical procedures on themselves instead of having it done in a medical facility by trained experts.

I am instead going to assume that these people truly believe a ban on abortions would actually stop them from happening.

That then begs the question I posed earlier: why do they suddenly think a ban would be effective?

It's logically inconsistent to argue a ban is effective in one policy area (read: something you want to be banned) and then argue a ban is ineffective in another area (read: something you do not want to be banned).

I happen to agree with the notion that complete bans on anything do not produce the intended results. However, that means I argue that position in any case.

Guns? I want to see stricter protections, but I know they cannot ever be completely banned from existence.

Abortions? I know that a ban on them will only force women to seek them out on their own in secret. I know this means that abortions will not stop happening, but that every women who gets one will now be at serious risk of injury or death as a result of them.

If I, a simple teenager with no government or political experience can realize that the argument to ban abortions but also be vehemently opposed to gun legislation because of the fact that bans don't work is inconsistent and does not make logical sense. why can't the lawmakers touting this argument realize it as well?

Maybe they just don't care that they are inconsistent. Maybe they realize that people blinded by partisanship and their own opinions won't question the leaders they have put total faith in.

No matter the reason, there is a lot of hypocrisy swirling with the push to ban abortions.

While we call out the bills for all of the reasons that have already been mentioned, I think we should also start asking lawmakers about their hypocrisy.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
one tree hill
Wikipedia Commons

If you need a new series to watch, I recommend One Tree Hill. I watched this series three times now and it only keeps getting better. If you need any more reasons beside the fact that all of the seasons are on Netflix for your binge-watching pleasure, here are seven more reasons to watch it.

Keep Reading...Show less
University of Mount Olive
University of Mount Olive

College is the most exciting time of a person's life. It really is. Exciting is not always a positive feeling though. Excited is a feeling that can be associated with nervousness, anxiety and more. Here are some real tips for college freshman that go beyond the typical, "Go to class," lecture.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

The 5 Pros and Cons Of Long Distance Friendships

Being friends with someone thousands of miles away has its drawbacks and perks.

1047
friends on the beach

True friendship is incredibly rare, and to find a friend that will be there for you through all of life's curveballs is something quite unique. To add distance into the equation, maintaining a real, true friendship can be a struggle. There are good and bad parts that come with long distance friendship.

Keep Reading...Show less
high school girls
Tori Horne

Friendship. It's defined as the state of being attached to another person by feelings of affection or personal regard, but what really is friendship? Is it that occasional hallway talk with that one person who always manages to cheer you up? Is it that relationship you have with someone where they can be gone for a long period of time, but when they come back, it's like they never left? Is it spending every waking hour with someone, and knowing every detail about their life? Is it the relationship that's filled with fighting, but filled with even more resolution? I've learned that it's all of these things, and every friendship is different. It's a beautifully dysfunctional mess that should always be cherished and never be taken for granted.

Keep Reading...Show less
cousins
Bailey Totten

I've known you your entire life. More than likely I held you in the first three days of it and at least one of us cried. Cousins are truly one of the best things in the world and while sometimes I complain about how many people crowd Grandma's living room on Christmas Eve, I wouldn't trade you all anything.

You are my best friends, the only people who can understand what it's like on Thanksgiving, and you are the spunkiest people I have ever met. But you as so so young, most of you are just now starting your adventures in the public education system. I mean, I'm so very young too. I'm not married, I don't have children, heck, I just started my adult life, but I do want to give you what little advice I have. My dears, these are the things I want you to know.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments