Reasons Why We Shouldn't Abolish ICE | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Immigration

Let's Not 'Abolish ICE,' Let's Get Congress To Actually Fix Immigration

What was once a far-left talking point has become a legitimate Democratic campaign policy, but what does it mean for immigration?

62
abolish ice poster

Since the family separation crisis initiated by the Trump administration's zero-tolerance policy by which thousands of undocumented migrant children were taken from their parents so that the adults could be jailed and prosecuted, people have been really angry about immigration.

When the administration "solved" the problem by throwing children in jail with their parents (which is against the law), the nation began looking for solutions to the broader problem of the way America treats its newcomers. After a frank assessment of the fact that there are immigration laws, many have called for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which monitors undocumented immigrants already in the country, to be done away with.

Obviously, there is a varied cocktail of small solutions out there that will reasonably reduce illegal entry, humanely treat existing undocumented immigrants, liberalize legal immigration and pass Congress that has yet to be found. But instead of searching for that precise balance of policies, many would much rather deploy a blunt instrument and see what happens.

It is unclear exactly what abolishing ICE would solve, what if anything would replace ICE, or how an ICE abolition bill would pass a Republican House and Senate with a majority large enough to bypass President Trump's inevitable veto, but many congressional Democrats, including Senator Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), have signed on to the idea.

In response to concerns that the legitimate law enforcement for which ICE is responsible would not be fulfilled if the agency were abolished, liberals respond that ICE is "a relatively new agency," so those obligations must not be very important.

ICE in its current iteration was authorized in 2003 in the wake of the worst terrorist attack in United States history. Its primary objective, like those of a large portion of the other components of the Department of Homeland Security, is national security. Of its $26.6 million budget for fiscal 2017, only $10.7 million was devoted to enforcement and removal operations. Of the 82,000 removals that were conducted that year, 83% were of criminals.

To be clear, U.S. immigration law is messy, confusing and bureaucratic.

A meaningful immigration bill has not been signed into law since 1986. Before then, immigration policy was a function of whichever nationality was the least liked at the time. Today, even though entering the country illegally is a misdemeanor, many Americans treat the action as the highest crime one can commit (see: Jared Kushner's felonious omissions of contacts with foreign officials, which hardly get mentioned by "law-and-order conservatives").

The Trump administration's particular approach to immigration enforcement is only aggravating a bad situation. Before the zero-tolerance policy, immigrants were released into the community under the supervision of a non-governmental organization, a social worker or were given ankle bracelets so they could be active in their communities while awaiting trial, all of which are far less expensive than detaining families indefinitely.

Slapping GPS monitors on migrants' ankles isn't the most humane thing to do, but it's better than throwing them in prison until they eventually have to go home.

There are no good options with regard to immigration. Nor, short of fully open or fully closed borders, are there any quick fixes. But something must be done.

The Trump administration's human rights violations were made possible by a century of a lack of political will, a problem which abolishing an agency responsible for national security will not solve. What is needed is comprehensive, compassionate immigration reform with bipartisan support.

If Congress can't pass a bill, or series of bills, that addresses this critical national security, economic and cultural topic, the crisis at the border will only get worse.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

15 Mind-Bending Riddles

Hopefully they will make you laugh.

196113
 Ilistrated image of the planet and images of questions
StableDiffusion

I've been super busy lately with school work, studying, etc. Besides the fact that I do nothing but AP chemistry and AP economics, I constantly think of stupid questions that are almost impossible to answer. So, maybe you could answer them for me, and if not then we can both wonder what the answers to these 15 questions could be.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

Most Epic Aurora Borealis Photos: October 2024

As if May wasn't enough, a truly spectacular Northern Lights show lit up the sky on Oct. 10, 2024

18396
stunning aurora borealis display over a forest of trees and lake
StableDiffusion

From sea to shining sea, the United States was uniquely positioned for an incredible Aurora Borealis display on Thursday, Oct. 10, 2024, going into Friday, Oct. 11.

It was the second time this year after an historic geomagnetic storm in May 2024. Those Northern Lights were visible in Europe and North America, just like this latest rendition.

Keep Reading...Show less
 silhouette of a woman on the beach at sunrise
StableDiffusion

Content warning: This article contains descriptions of suicide/suicidal thoughts.

When you are feeling down, please know that there are many reasons to keep living.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

Power of Love Letters

I don't think I say it enough...

460516
Illistrated image of a letter with 2 red hearts
StableDiffusion

To My Loving Boyfriend,

  • Thank you for all that you do for me
  • Thank you for working through disagreements with me
  • Thank you for always supporting me
  • I appreciate you more than words can express
  • You have helped me grow and become a better person
  • I can't wait to see where life takes us next
  • I promise to cherish every moment with you
  • Thank you for being my best friend and confidante
  • I love you and everything you do

To start off, here's something I don't say nearly enough: thank you. Thank you, thank you, thank you from the bottom of my heart. You do so much for me that I can't even put into words how much I appreciate everything you do - and have done - for me over the course of our relationship so far. While every couple has their fair share of tiffs and disagreements, thank you for getting through all of them with me and making us a better couple at the other end. With any argument, we don't just throw in the towel and say we're done, but we work towards a solution that puts us in a greater place each day. Thank you for always working with me and never giving up on us.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

11 Signs You Grew Up In Hauppauge, NY

Because no one ever really leaves.

28118
Map of Hauppauge, New York
Google

Ah, yes, good old Hauppauge. We are that town in the dead center of Long Island that barely anyone knows how to pronounce unless they're from the town itself or live in a nearby area. Hauppauge is home to people of all kinds. We always have new families joining the community but honestly, the majority of the town is filled with people who never leave (high school alumni) and elders who have raised their kids here. Around the town, there are some just some landmarks and places that only the people of Hauppauge will ever understand the importance or even the annoyance of.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments