A Message to Leftists About the Supreme Court | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
News

A Message to Leftists About the Supreme Court

It's time to address the elephant in the room: one of our most undemocratic institutions needs major change, and we need to vote for it.

46
A Message to Leftists About the Supreme Court

The 2020 US election has proven a very divisive issue for many leftists and socialist-aligned individuals living in the US, and for good reason. While not a perfect candidate, Bernie Sanders' campaign (and to an extent Elizabeth Warren's) showed that there was potential in this country for the political Overton Window (the range of acceptable political discourse and thought within a country) to shift left, after enduring the harsh and reactionary presidencies of Donald Trump and formerly George Bush Jr. This chance at reform, this promise of hope, was squashed by the DNC, and everyone from progressives to socialists and communists were left in an unenviable position: the choice between two right wing candidates, and a seeming paralysis of the country's political discourse into a liberal-conservative binary (note that the usage of the term liberal here means a person with right wing economic views and left wing social views, the definition most commonly applied in countries that aren't the United States). There appeared no chance to fight against or even abolish the capitalistic hierarchies that cause millions in this country to suffer every year, and as such many leftists threw up their hands in frustration and resigned not to vote. If you are one of those who is still in this position less than a week away from election day, this is for you. Namely, I want to talk to you about the United State Supreme Court, and why the recent appointment of Amy Cohen Barrett should, if nothing else, be more than enough of a reason for you to vote for the Dems this year.

First, a few boundaries and issues of phrasing and framing need to be overcome. Firstly, we need to stop framing this debate in terms of optics, moral standing, and hypocrisy. There are many Republicans who blocked Obama's attempts to appoint a justice in 2016 because it was "too close to the election." These same politicians are the ones who confirmed Barrett. But fixating on this point is counter-productive and not the point––obsessing over optics doesn't serve anyone but an abstract "moral fiber" of our "character." The philosophical and moral victory in a debate will not stop people from dying. The time for theorizing is over and the time for action is now. This brings us to the second major point that needs to be emphasized: the Supreme Court is not, nor has it ever been, a democratic institution. The fact that several un-elected individuals, some of whom (Barrett falls under this category) barely have any experience in their field are able to have this much sway and power over the masses is not democratic, nor should we fool ourselves into thinking it is. These appointments are for life, they are not made by us, and often they will not serve our interests.

With this in mind, though, we still need to vote for Biden. Revolution and the abolition of undemocratic structures that come with it, such as the Court and the Senate, are far away. The state apparatus is too heavily armed and the population too politically divided and uneducated for any force significant enough to challenge Washington in a revolutionary way to emerge at this moment in time. For evidence of this, one only need look at the overwhelming force deployed against Black Lives Matters activists and protestors earlier this year to see how impossible this is at this moment in time. Right now we must at least understand the political structure of 21st Century US capital, and this includes the Court. The choice right now is whether we vote for someone who will make the situation worse, or potentially better. Don't believe what people in Washington tell you: the Court is not an apolitical agents, nor are its judges. Barrett serves Evangelical hardliner Christianity, she serves the Republican party and its corporate interests, and she serves Trump. With her appointment, everything is at risk: abortion rights, queer rights, the broken healthcare system we have, and voter rights could all be taken away. Biden has not ruled our stacking the Court, and we have no choice right now but to take his statement seriously. If not for yourself, vote for women who need access to safe contraceptives and sex education, vote for people who need healthcare and want to not have to worry about going bankrupt every time they see their doctor, vote for the thousands upon thousands of minorities who could be disenfranchised if voter ID and registration restrictions are introduced, and vote for our American gay and lesbian and trans and queer brothers and sisters and siblings who may soon have everything taken away.

So please, please, vote.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
6 Signs You Are An English Major

There are various stereotypes about college students, most of which revolve around the concept of your major. Unfortunately, we often let stereotypes precede our own judgments, and we take what information is immediately available to us rather than forming our own opinions after considerable reflection. If I got a dollar for every time my friends have made a joke about my major I could pay my tuition. One stereotype on campus is the sensitive, overly critical and rigid English major. Here are six telltale signs you are one of them.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

27 Things 'The Office' Has Taught Us

"The Office" is a mockumentary based on everyday office life featuring love triangles, silly pranks and everything in between. It can get pretty crazy for just an average day at the office.

1683
the office
http://www.ssninsider.com/

When you were little, your parents probably told you television makes your brain rot so you wouldn't watch it for twelve straight hours. However, I feel we can learn some pretty valuable stuff from television shows. "The Office," while a comedy, has some pretty teachable moments thrown in there. You may not know how to react in a situation where a co-worker does something crazy (like put your office supplies in jello) but thanks to "The Office," now you'll have an idea how to behave ifsomething like that should happen.

Here are just a few of the things that religious Office watchers can expect to learn.

Keep Reading...Show less
Grey's Anatomy
TV Guide

Being pre-med is quite a journey. It’s not easy juggling school work, extracurricular activities, volunteering, shadowing, research, and MCAT prep all at the same time. Ever heard of “pain is temporary, but GPA is forever?” Pre-meds don’t just embody that motto; we live and breathe it. Here are 10 symptoms you’re down with the pre-med student syndrome.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

Books were always about understanding for me, about learning the way someone else sees, about connection.

766
High School And College Sucked All Of The Fun Out Of Reading

I keep making this joke whenever the idea of books is brought up: "God, I wish I knew how to read." It runs parallel to another stupid phrase, as I watch my friends struggle through their calculus classes late at night in our floor lounge: "I hope this is the year that I learn to count." They're both truly idiotic expressions, but, when I consider the former, I sometimes wonder if there's some truth to it.

Keep Reading...Show less
One Book Made Me Question Existence In Its Entirety
Photo by Rey Seven on Unsplash

"The Stranger" by Albert Campus touches upon many heavy elements... but not in the way you expect. Although it touches upon the aspects of death and love, it also deals with a hidden philosophy similar to that of nihilism.

The story follows the short life events of Meursault, a Frenchman whose carelessness for his actions eventually ends him in jail and dependent on a jury of people to judge the ethicality of his decision and the punishment that he deserves. He eventually gets the death penalty and all throughout he is nonchalant and almost apathetic towards his situation. He finally snaps when the prison sends a priest to him to absolve him of his sins and to cajole him in confessing to the lord.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments