5 Arguments Against Black Lives Matter Debunked | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

5 Arguments Against Black Lives Matter Debunked

From a concerned white ally.

5120
5 Arguments Against Black Lives Matter Debunked
Janaya Khan

In the wake of police shootings, I see activists take to social media, using the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter or referring to the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement. As a white person, I feel that it’s essential to progress that other white people use their voices to amplify those of the oppressed. However, any black person can tell you that white people often take up too much space in narratives about race and police violence. Instead of discussing how they can help, they make it about their feelings, something that I’ve seen in discussions about BLM. This is problematic because some white people superimpose themselves onto an issue that they don't exactly understand, and it doesn't help progress -- it hinders it. There’s nothing I can add to the movement that black activists haven’t said already, so I feel that it’s necessary to realize our mistakes as white allies and work on them together. These five points are arguments I’ve seen in response to the BLM movement, and why they’re easily debunked.

1. “I agree with the premise of Black Lives Matter, just not their methods.”

I tend to hear this from white allies denouncing the riots in the streets that take place after any number of high-profile police shootings. I can see where you’re coming from, but try to remember that the same kind of violence, vandalism and chaos can happen after a Super Bowl, mostly from white people. I’m a pacifist, but the BLM protesters deserve to be angry. They’re being senselessly murdered out of racism by the people being paid to protect them. If that isn’t cause enough for riots, I don’t know what is.

2. “All lives matter.”

An infamous one, this one has sparked a lot of controversy, and rightfully so. In practice, all lives do and should matter. But not all lives are being shot, beaten, or choked to death for minor traffic violations. Not all lives are subject to becoming just another name on CNN or Fox News, reduced down to their mugshots and petty crimes. Therefore, it’s important that we recognize this issue as a purely black one. Until we stop looking for reasons why a black person had to be murdered at the hands of police officers, we need to keep saying “black lives matter.”

3. “What about black-on-black crime?”

This one is nothing more than a diversion. While it’s true that many black people have lost their lives to gang violence, it’s crucial to keep in mind that gang violence and racially motivated police violence are two separate entities. Simply put, blacks don’t kill other blacks because they’re black. It’s not remotely the same thing. Not only that, but if a civilian kills another civilian out of gang violence, they're usually arrested, tried and convicted. The same thing just doesn't happen if it's a police officer. BLM doesn't just focus on the loss of black lives -- they focus on the lack of justice.

4. “Blue lives matter.”

In a similar vein to number two, many people use this to juxtapose the BLM movement and violence against police. Violence against police is never okay, despite what people outside the movement may think. People often use this saying to proclaim that there's a “war on police,” ignited by the BLM movement. Statistically, police are safer than ever before, with the number of police deaths steadily declining since 1973. In 2016, only 26 police officers have been killed in the line of duty. This mantra also compares a profession to a race. Police officers aren’t born blue, unlike black people, who have no choice in their struggle against racist police. Police have never been considered lesser or easily disposable because of their status as police.

5. “Out-of-context Martin Luther King Jr. Quote”

A lot of white people like to sanitize Dr. King’s words and life’s work for the sake of our own comfort. People try to claim that he would not approve of today’s movement because of some violence, but the BLM movement perfectly aligns with Dr. King’s legacy. Sure, he may have said people should "not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character,” but he wouldn’t have wanted us to pretend that racial injustice doesn’t exist. He may have said things in favor of non-violence, but he also said that “large segments of white society are more concerned about tranquility and the status quo than about justice and humanity.” And he was absolutely right. We may want peace and justice for all, but unless we listen to those who need it immediately, we’ll never achieve it.

It’s hard being on the sidelines sometimes, because we can feel powerless. But we must learn to step to the side so that the voices of those who are truly suffering can be heard. We need to channel our good intentions by speaking up for the movement, instead of questioning the movement itself, which will truly be helpful to the cause.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
ross geller
YouTube

As college students, we are all familiar with the horror show that is course registration week. Whether you are an incoming freshman or selecting classes for your last semester, I am certain that you can relate to how traumatic this can be.

1. When course schedules are released and you have a conflict between two required classes.

Bonus points if it is more than two.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

12 Things I Learned my Freshmen Year of College

When your capability of "adulting" is put to the test

2966
friends

Whether you're commuting or dorming, your first year of college is a huge adjustment. The transition from living with parents to being on my own was an experience I couldn't have even imagined- both a good and a bad thing. Here's a personal archive of a few of the things I learned after going away for the first time.

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

Economic Benefits of Higher Wages

Nobody deserves to be living in poverty.

302045
Illistrated image of people crowded with banners to support a cause
StableDiffusion

Raising the minimum wage to a livable wage would not only benefit workers and their families, it would also have positive impacts on the economy and society. Studies have shown that by increasing the minimum wage, poverty and inequality can be reduced by enabling workers to meet their basic needs and reducing income disparities.

I come from a low-income family. A family, like many others in the United States, which has lived paycheck to paycheck. My family and other families in my community have been trying to make ends meet by living on the minimum wage. We are proof that it doesn't work.

Keep Reading...Show less
blank paper
Allena Tapia

As an English Major in college, I have a lot of writing and especially creative writing pieces that I work on throughout the semester and sometimes, I'll find it hard to get the motivation to type a few pages and the thought process that goes behind it. These are eleven thoughts that I have as a writer while writing my stories.

Keep Reading...Show less
April Ludgate

Every college student knows and understands the struggle of forcing themselves to continue to care about school. Between the piles of homework, the hours of studying and the painfully long lectures, the desire to dropout is something that is constantly weighing on each and every one of us, but the glimmer of hope at the end of the tunnel helps to keep us motivated. While we are somehow managing to stay enrolled and (semi) alert, that does not mean that our inner-demons aren't telling us otherwise, and who is better to explain inner-demons than the beloved April Ludgate herself? Because of her dark-spirit and lack of filter, April has successfully been able to describe the emotional roller-coaster that is college on at least 13 different occasions and here they are.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments