3 Myths About Criminal Punishment | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

3 Myths About Criminal Punishment

Does punishing crime make it worse?

134
3 Myths About Criminal Punishment
Foonacha

In our attempts to see justice done and to discourage bad behavior, we often turn to punishments to teach those danged criminals a lesson. Frequently, however, those punishments are unhelpful and can even be completely counterproductive. Here are three myths about the way that we punish criminals in the United States:

1. "Torture can get useful information."

Let's assume for the sake of argument that torture is morally acceptable and assess purely on the basis of whether or not it works. Given that the goal of torture is to get information, it is basically useless. Actually, it is worse than useless. Researchers have consistently found that it provides false and misleading information.

The United States Army Field Manual warns that information gathered by torture can be faulty. That's because, during torture, truth becomes irrelevant. And when the interrogators don't know if the information is true, the torture may continue even if the detainee tells the truth. At that point, the captive will fabricate information with the goal of telling the interrogator what he wants to hear. "It is enormously well documented (including by the Senate study of the CIA program) that torture generated enormous amounts of false statements," said Lisa Hajjar, a professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara.

Many interrogators have thought they can tell when a tortured subject is lying, but their guesses were no better than flipping a coin. Members of the Bush administration claimed that torture helped the Bush administration during the Iraq War, but it didn't. Most cases of supposedly successful torture they named have since been debunked. It is unfortunate that they decided to legitimize torture, since even before the 9/11 terror attacks, "the CIA itself determined from its own experience with coercive interrogations, that such techniques "do not produce intelligence," "will probably result in false answers," and had historically proven to be ineffective. Yet these conclusions were ignored."

Even without the substantial ethical objections, torture is not worth it – especially considering how it damages our reputation abroad.

2. "The War on Drugs is working."

The War on Drugs is failing partially for the same reason that Prohibition did: the laws of supply and demand. Trying to remove all drugs using government force lowers the supply of drugs, which raises their price, compelling more drug providers to enter the market to make a profit. The result is a frustrated government spending $500 per second (over $1 trillion in total since Nixon) locking people up at an unprecedented exponential rate.

Beyond that, our approach to the drug addiction has been fundamentally flawed. We have often assumed that taking drugs – especially "hard-core" drugs like heroin – for a long period of time must lead to addiction. But hospital patients who are hooked up to morphine rarely, if ever, end up addicted, despite the fact that they receive a much purer and stronger form of heroin.

One reason that researchers found why those patients do not become heroin addicts is a stable social environment. In many drug experiments, a rat was put into a tank with two water feeders, one normal and one laced with heroin. Unsurprisingly, the rat became addicted and only drank from the heroin water. Experiments which stopped there were used to justify the War on Drugs. However, when Bruce K. Alexander ran the experiment again with more mice in a larger tank including a "playground," the mice drank almost exclusively from the non-heroin water. Mice became addicted only if they were socially isolated and deprived of other sources of happiness.

So criminalizing heroin and other drugs has not only backfired economically like Prohibition did, but it has also backfired by forcing drug users into the conditions where they are most vulnerable to addiction: homelessness, social isolation and deprivation of other sources of happiness.

To be fair, the validity of Alexander's "Rat Park" experiment has been disputed. Some further experiments have replicated it and some haven't, although the latter were performed under different conditions. Still, Alexander found the same effect with alcoholism in Native American populations, among other historical examples.

More importantly, Portugal actually decriminalized all drugs in 2001 and its "drug situation has improved significantly in several key areas. Most notably, HIV infections and drug-related deaths have decreased, while the dramatic rise in use feared by some has failed to materialise." Heroin use fell to about half of its late-1990s level. So it should come as no surprise that many are suggesting that we take the same approach in the United States.

3. "The death penalty deters murder."

It seems like common sense that the threat of being killed would stop someone from killing. Some studies has appeared to back this up, finding a relationship between capital punishment and lower crime. However, as soon as other variables (e.g. incarceration rates, life sentences, which homicides are eligible for the death penalty, etc.) were taken into account, the deterrence effect disappeared. A sizeable body of research has supported that murders – which are often committed in the heat of the moment rather than premeditated – are not deterred by capital punishment.

On critical examination, even the "common sense" idea does not make sense in real life. Murders are frequently not premeditated, so criminals would not take the consequences into consideration. Even if they did, why would they think that they would end up with the death penalty considering how sparingly it is applied in modern times?

Ultimately, all three of these are flawed policies that should be changed if not repealed – the sooner the better.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
nothing on to-do list

Winter break is a cherished time for many after enduring a grueling fall semester. It’s a time of relaxation and time spent with loved ones over the holidays. However, once the new year rolls around, we’re all ready to go back to school. Here are thoughts every college student has during winter break.

Keep Reading...Show less
Relationships

10 Facts All People In A Large Family Can Confirm During The Holiday Season

The holiday season can be the best and most stressful time of the year, especially when more people are involved.

2890
kids jumping

The holidays are full of lights, sweets, sweaters, and your favorite movies. There's nothing quite like this period from the beginning of December through January. Christmas, Hanukkah, and New Years. The fun of it all.

I don't know about you but with my large Italian family something is always going on during this season. It can be the most wonderful time of the year while also being the most hectic. These are a few things you know if your family is anything like mine during this time.

Keep Reading...Show less
10 things that happen the second Thanksgiving is over
reference.com

To those who celebrate, you just spent an entire day cooking an elaborate meal with all of your favorite foods. You probably ate your body weight in pumpkin pie and mashed potatoes. What happens now? Oh yea, Christmas. It’s time to take out all of the decorations and Christmas themed things that have been sitting in the attic since last year; it’s time to make a reappearance. So, here are 10 things that happen the second Thanksgiving is over.

Keep Reading...Show less
Adulting

18 Things I Want To Do Now That I'm 18

I'm technically an adult, so I'm legally required to live a little, right?

5462
Happy Birthday Cake

For the entirety of my high school career, I was always seen as the goody-two-shoes. I never got in trouble with a teacher, I kept stellar grades, and when I wasn't doing extracurricular activities, I was at home studying. Even when I did go out, it was usually with a bunch of fellow band geeks. The night would end before 11:00 PM and the only controversial activity would be a fight based on who unfairly won a round of Apples-to-Apples when someone else clearly had a better card (I promise I'm not still holding a grudge).

Now that I'm officially an adult, I want to pursue some new things. I want to experience life in a way that I never allowed myself to do prior to entering college. These are the years that I'm supposed to embark on a journey of self-discovery, so what better way to do that than to create a bucket list?

Keep Reading...Show less
Featured

10 Life Lessons from Christmas Classics

The holiday classics that shaped my life

3416
10 Life Lessons from Christmas Classics
Flickr

The holiday season is full of stress, debt, and forced conversation. While we rush through the month of December, it's important to take a step back and enjoy the moments before they're gone. Most families love to watch Christmas movies, but these beloved films provide more than entertainment. Here are 10 life lessons that I've learned from the holiday classics we watch every year.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments