11 Definitive Feelings I Have About Musicals | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

11 Definitive Feelings I Have About Musicals

Not every musical can be all that jazz.

78
11 Definitive Feelings I Have About Musicals

Theatre news has been swarming our computer screens this past week. Every show is getting in their last minute premiere to be Tony-eligible. Tony nominations will be read this year by the wonderful Christopher Jackson and Jane Krakowski. And we finally got a Tonys host with only a couple weeks away!

Amidst all this buzz, a recent Facebook trend also began to spread where everyone was making known their taste for musicals. From best to worst, underrated to overrated, people were coming in strong in terms of what they thought was all that jazz and what didn't make the cut. Because of this, I decided to reflect on my own choices:

1. Musicals I Love: "West Side Story", "Follies"

I love nothing more than some good old fashioned Sondheim. Both of these works are a pinnacle in terms of engaging storytelling, gorgeous showstopping numbers, and reflecting on some tragic times in the most beautiful and poetic ways possible. Can’t go wrong with either of these as they are both masterpieces.

2. Underrated Musicals: "Merrily We Roll Along", "Dogfight"

Both shows with scores that were taken for granted at their time and still now. "Merrily We Roll Along" is one of my favorite shows as well as scores. A score that showcases Sondheim’s best from his innate need for speed without also using a reprise of the originally sad song to be even sadder later. "Dogfight" is also just as memorable. It seems so simple but proves that a love story you root for doesn’t have to be extravagant to be mesmerizing.

3. Overrated Musicals: "Legally Blonde", "Fiddler on the Roof", "Wicked"

Let’s just face it guys, "Legally Blonde" was never that great a musical. It was cute, a good laugh, but at the end of the day is much better regarded over time as a movie. "Fiddler on the Roof" while acclaimed a classic staple in musical theater I just never got on board with. It’s tediously long and aside from a few numbers is pretty forgettable. And "Wicked"? "Wicked" is pretty self-explanatory if you’re a legitimate theater fan.

4. Musicals I Hate: "Cats", "Love Never Dies"

Mr. Andrew Lloyd Webber, I understand you have done a lot for the theater community and I thank you. But what happened here? You really dropped the ball, my friend. No matter what anyone says a musical about cats was never a good idea. I don’t care if produced “Memory” or had any acclaim, With "Love Never Dies", I mean no musical can ever top its predecessor. Plus, Christine never would have gone with the Phantom let’s be for real. Leave the Angel of Music where he belongs sir.

5. Guilty Pleasure Musicals: "Phantom of the Opera", "Rent"

Aside from my previous disdain for Webber, I’m no monster. "The Phantom of the Opera" is the guiltiest of pleasures to belt out to when you’re feeling sad or dramatic as a prima donna. "Rent" is always a good time. Though it may be stereotypical to adore, it will always have a special place in my heart. No day but today y’all.

6. Musicals I Am Most Excited To See: "Anastasia", "Dear Evan Hansen"

Though the chances are slim, I would do anything to be able to see these. "Anastasia" was a cornerstone of my childhood and to see that magic come to life would be phenomenal. Especially because of the changes they have made from screen to stage to actually make it more successful! "Dear Evan Hansen" already has great acclaim and I would love to be able to see the show whose soundtrack I can’t stop listening to!

7. Musicals I Cherish: "Man of La Mancha", "Into the Woods", "Next to Normal"

These are the musicals I hold dearest in my heart. "Man of La Mancha" is such a surprisingly twist on the epic tale of Don Quixote that balances between past and present of what it means to dream. "Into the Woods" centers on how our lives contain both light and darkness making them all the more worthwhile. "Next to Normal" is an epic that takes the typical family drama to a whole new level making us realize how we have no idea what could be going on next door.

8. Musicals I Sob Through: "Les Miserables", "Once"

"Les Miserables" is an epic and long-ass book for a reason, solely written by Hugo to produce tears. Death after death just gets worse and it feels like a time where justice doesn't prevail, but ultimately it proves to be a story of how you can be redeemed and achieve salvation. "Once" though may seem simple, it proves how the ordinariness of life can be the most beautiful as we just fail to notice it.

9. Gamechanger Musicals: "Rent", "Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812"

Yes, it gets a second mention on this list because "Rent" truly changed musical theater. Way before "Hamilton" or "Spongebob" or anything, "Rent" was the shit that turned Broadway upside down. It will never not be noted how impactful its inception and reception was as a revolutionary work of musical theater. On the other end of that spectrum is "Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812", a work that is ambitious in a completely different way. Dealing with 19th century Russia, a techno-pop-rock opera and everything under the moon score and adding aspects of immersiveness and diversity to a classic tale. Could not appreciate it more!

10. Musicals Whose Songs I Skip: "The Book of Mormon", "Bye Bye Birdie"

Though "The Book of Mormon" had its due, it’s not one of those shows I really find myself listening to as a cast album. So much of the enjoyment of that show is in watching it, and the score just seems like not enough as a stand alone to keep me hanging on. "Bye Bye Birdie" is just so incessantly overbearing with its peppy teens and adults who can’t seem to grow up. I skip the dial whenever I hear it in my vicinity.

11. Musicals I Could Listen to On Repeat: "The Last Five Years", "Waitress"

"The Last Five Years" is a musical that I could listen to a thousand times and find something different every time. It’s also a story that’s universal being able to transcend its setting only becoming more resonant as times goes on "Waitress" is also stellar in terms of a score that can be on shuffle all day. Sara Bareilles is as catchy and sentimental as ever making you want to belt out your heart as well as cry into your pillow over love, life, and the struggle for self-acceptance.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
cousins
Bailey Totten

I've known you your entire life. More than likely I held you in the first three days of it and at least one of us cried. Cousins are truly one of the best things in the world and while sometimes I complain about how many people crowd Grandma's living room on Christmas Eve, I wouldn't trade you all anything.

You are my best friends, the only people who can understand what it's like on Thanksgiving, and you are the spunkiest people I have ever met. But you as so so young, most of you are just now starting your adventures in the public education system. I mean, I'm so very young too. I'm not married, I don't have children, heck, I just started my adult life, but I do want to give you what little advice I have. My dears, these are the things I want you to know.

Keep Reading...Show less
ORHS Graduation
Kristen Sack, ORHS Graduation

You are a senior in high school, you have made it to the final year that you have been looking forward to since the first day of freshman year. Whether this has been the worst or best four years of your life, appreciate it. You will never have these times back, you will never be in high school again. It is hard for someone still in high school to wrap their brain around, but there will be a day when you wish you could be in the shoes you're in right now. Here are 15 things I have learned being in college that I wish I knew as a high school senior:

Keep Reading...Show less
one tree hill
Wikimedia

Everyone, and I mean everyone has heard of the show "One Tree Hill". Many people think that this show is the best thing they've ever watched and others won't bother watching it because they know they'll get hooked. And yes, I know many people have written about this show before, but I couldn't resist. I could re-watch every season multiple times to the point where I can almost quote an entire scene. Trust me, once you start "One Tree Hill", you will be hooked. There's way too many reasons to list as to why you'll love this show, and these are just a few.

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

5 Ways To Bring Positivity Into Your Life When All You Want To Do Is Drown In Self-Pity

It seems like life has been serving up more bad than good and in all honesty, the only thing you want to do is crawl under your covers and hide from the rest of the world.

2304
5 Ways To Bring Positivity Into Your Life When All You Want To Do Is Drown In Self-Pity
Photo by Kinga Howard on Unsplash

The first two weeks of classes have come to an end and they have been anything BUT easy. It seems like life has been serving up more bad than good and in all honesty, the only thing you want to do is crawl under your covers and hide from the rest of the world.

Although this seems like the best solution, it is also the easy way out. Take it from the girl who took basically a whole week off from her life because she just could not handle everything that was being thrown at her. This caused her to feel extremely lonely and even more stressed out for being behind in classes that JUST began.

Keep Reading...Show less
friends

1. Thank you for being my person.

2. Thank you for knowing me better than I know myself sometimes.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments